Tally's Silver Spoon

AMAZING! When you come here get the 3 course indecision menu. You will not find a better deal in the whole city for 45 dollars. A delightful experience as the chef delivers their choice of dish from on or off the menu. I got a strand and lobster dish, a delightful salad, and a sea bass dish! High quality cooking and high quality ingredients! Service was fantastic with speedy refills and low wait times. The atmosphere of the restaurant is also quite nice! If you are in town make a stop here for a wonderful experience!

First this restaurant was highly recommended from just above every person when we asked where are the must visit restaurants in Rapid City. So finally we made it downtown to try it out! The location is great and surrounded by tons of shopping and bars. We went around 9:30am and we were sat right away. One strange thing was the hostage was tucked inside the door frame when you enter the restaurant. Anywho our waitress came right away and took our drink and food order. Since it was breakfast I decided on the crepes and the husband ordered the chicken fried steak. We didn’t have to wait too long before our food was delivered and let me tell you, I was so mad for not ordering the same thing as my husband because whatever they put in their gravy was excellent. The crepes were also delicious but highly recommend the biscuits and gravy or the chicken fried steak. The restaurant didn’t seem very big but quit quickly starting filling up with a wait list. While eating we overheard the waitress tell others that they needed to wait across the street in Starbucks as they didn’t have a waiting area in the restaurant which seemed weird but hey who doesn’t like Starbucks and a chance to get some chubby chipmunk chocolate. They have a nice bar area too and I was hoping they would serve mimosas but there were no alcohol options for breakfast. I will say $7 for a glass of orange juice was a bit crazy. I know they offer a kind of mystery dinner meal that we want to try when we come back where the chef selects your meals. Overall very great experience with staff and atmosphere.

The portion was so BIG. Didn’t expect it. They had the bison pasta I think it’s super cool. A comfortable environment for dinning. Feels like people come here for the atmosphere but not their food(even though the food was also good lol

The food was great, the service was prompt and friendly. Everyone was working hard, and it showed. It is well worth the money.

I got the duck, duck goose and it was great! I offer this tiny critique- the dish is missing something crispy- which I think could easily be solved by the sweet potatoes cut smaller and roasted or fried crispy.

Anyway, we loved it!

(I forgot to take a pic before I dug in so I took a picture of my bar neighbors food to show their lovely presentation!)

Such a great place for breakfast! We haven't had a chance to try lunch or dinner here, but the menu looks amazing! Service has always been top notch as well!

Ordered takeout lunch for work; the host was friendly, and the order was ready on time. I had the banh mi (Vietnamese style pork sandwich) and it was one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had in my life. Totally worth upgrading to sweet potato fries, too. This place never disappoints, I’ve ordered from here a few times and I recommend you do too!

Love this restaurant! Offers an "indecision" menu giving the chef full control to deliver courses of their design. Every dish was excellent! Highly recommend.

//Update// Revisited Tally's again, this time with the whole family. Our server Sean was outstanding and once again the food was sublime! Cannot wait to go again...

Great local breakfast joint. Service was excellent. Migas, chicken fried steak and biscuits and gravy were all very good.

What a delightful discovery. Had a wonderful time, the service was some of the best I've experienced in a while, and the food was exquisite. Everything had a delightful balance. Additionally there were options: some of us went big and some of us kept to a budget. Tally's gives you variety. But the bison may tag marsala (I even tried it with gluten free noodles) Oh my! This chef knocked it out of the park on that one. Will return.

Was getting a little disappointed with restaurants in Rapid City until we stumbled upon this jewel. Wow! What a find! Stopped in for brunch and glad we did. My wife had Eggs Benedict and I ordered Migas. Both were delicious (understatement!). Pleasant surroundings and tip top service. Highly recommended if you are in the area.

We had a wonderful dinner experience at Tally's Silver Spoon. Our service was excellent, the server was very knowledgeable in regards to the menu as well as to matching a wine to our entrees. We started out with the curry muscles as an appetizer, they were wonderful. Three of us ordered house salads to start, they were very good The vegetables were crispy and fresh. Our fourth member ordered soup, he said it was very good as well. For entrees, two of us ordered the elk tenderloin and two of us ordered the buffalo marsala. All entreees were really good. For dessert, we all actually had the date night which is a date cake with date ice cream. It was very mild and smooth, not too sweet yet sweet enough.

A very classy experience. The restaurant has a pleasant ambiance and is nicely nestled in a quiet downtown location. Their menu is quite diverse with appetizers, burgers, pastas, salads, and extravagant entrees. The bison Maytag Marsala mushroom pasta was amazing. It was loaded with bison tenderloin and mushrooms. The pasta was cooked perfectly and the dish was abundantly flavorful. The black hills Buffalo burger was way above average - a burger elevated. It was also cooked perfectly, juicy, and just all around delightful. The service was good. We got everything we needed promptly and accurately. This was a great experience - no complaints here.

While traveling to Rapid City to explore the National Parks and monuments in the area, we were looking for a good dinner stop on a Sunday. Tally’s was one of the few places open, but wow were we happy they were and so impressed with our meal. Its clear ingredients were high quality and their dishes had sophistication without feeling pretentious. I had their Bison Marsala and my fiancé did their Buffalo entree. The appetizer (mushrooms) were incredible as well. Not only was the food great, but Sean, our waiter was out of this world. He gave great recommendations, explained the dishes in great detail, and provided wonderful customer service.

We definitely recommend this spot. We’re even talking about coming back another day before we leave the area!

Amazing breakfast! The chicken fried steak is killer! I was not impressed with the bison steak but I may not be appreciating its unique and more robust flavor. You can’t really go wrong with Tally’s!

Delicious food and outstanding service! Sterling recommended a great appetizer, and was knowledgeable about the menu. He stayed half an hour past close to serve us, and didn't make us feel rushed. Great Ribeye with farro, and excellent Carbonara. Definitely a place we'll eat at again soon!

What a find! We were in town for a few days and ate there twice! Bison was delicious 😋 with fettuccine and mushrooms. Brunch too was amazing! The ingredients were fresh, the service friendly, a must when visiting Rapid City!

This was my first visit to Tally's. Went with a couple of friends/ coworkers. The food, service, and atmosphere were excellent. They do have some dietary restrictions ( Gluten free options) if you need them. It's a nice place where you can actually feel very comfortable, have a wonderful meal and enjoy a few hours. The staff was also attentive but not overbearing. I hope to return soon.

The food was really good. I got the vegetarian breakfast, which was surprisingly good. The wheat pancakes with yogurt were also really good. Good coffee!
The place was pretty busy, with a wait. When we went, the wait times weren't bad and the hostess was very accommodating and friendly.

I recently visited this place because I have heard good things about it, and it did not disappoint! I ordered the chicken sandwich with a side salad. The chicken breast was perfectly seasoned and very juicy. The ranch that came with the salad was also an incredible bonus because of how creamy and rich it tasted. Besides all of the food tasting good, it was brought out to us extremely quick. Caleb, our server, had a great attitude got us anything we needed.
Overall, I would recommend this place to anyone in the area looking for an exquisite restaurant to enjoy a nice meal. Tally's Silver Spoon is a very elegant restaurant, and would be perfect for a date night or a Friday night dinner. Before stopping in, I highly recommend making a reservation because of the limited seating available. I hope to return back soon!

Always love Tally’s, it’s my go-to brunch spot! Last week I had the special, I wish I could remember what it was called, it was absolutely amazing it was some sort of braised bison on hash browns and the most perfect bread that reminded me of a stepped up cornbread. It was out of this world, 10/10, I hope they have it on the menu again… better yet if it was made it a permanent dish. ☺ I’ve always had amazing service from host to servers, never a single complaint. I’ve been there several times where the wait is over 30 min and I can tell you it’s worth every second! Also, no matter how stressed the staff must be due to how busy they are they never once have shown anything but kindness, respect, and patience!
I have and will continue to point anyone and everyone to Tally’s for brunch.