Sugar Island Cupcakes And Bakery

Beautiful specialty shop. Fantastic customer service. Very customer friendly. Gluten free and vegan selections. Try the carrot cake and vanilla gluten free cupcakes. Sooo delicious! Highly recommend.

I was on vacation this week. Just realized this bakery was close to our condo. The owner greeted me and my husband and was the friendliest person we met this trip. I bought a cupcake called "Yolo" it was honestly the best cupcake I have ever had. Tonight is our last night here and I had to go back and by another one. Lisa I am so glad I got to meet you and I can't wait to have some goodies next year!!!! Its going to be hard having a delicious craving 10hrs from home.

The cake I ordered for my son's 6th B-Day was incredible. Taste was outstanding and the beach theme was well done.

Lisa and her crew did an excellent job for us! I called from up in NC and she prepared and delivered a wonderful bunch of cookies and cupcakes to our very old step mom in a nursing home in St Augustine. They were very well received and we got glowing remarks about how great they looked and tasty. Our step mom said more than 5 times in a recent phone call how great they tasted. I would recommend the service and products at this location anytime! Thank you again Lisa!

We were in town this week from out of state. It was my moms birthday today. I really wanted her to have a nice cake but didn’t know of any good places, because we are not from around here. I called in to order a custom 8’ layered chocolate cake yesterday, and it was ready this morning, in less than 24 hours from me ordering it! The lady on the phone and in the store was so kind and helpful. The store was so cute and decorative, with treats great for any occasion. And the cake was one of the yummiest and richest chocolate cakes I have ever had! My whole family and I really enjoyed it. I would recommend this place to anyone! Seriously the prettiest and most perfect cake for my amazing mom! :)

Sugar Island Cupcakes & Bakery recently made our wedding cake. Lisa did an amazing job! My husband and I are not big cake and/frosting fans, so we were so excited to find out that Lisa could make a gluten-free chocolate/peanut butter cream naked cake with a crumb coating.... and it was delicious!! Everyone loved it and we look forward to stopping by the next time we are in town for some cupcakes!

My birthday cake was the most moist and delicious cake I’ve ever had - SERIOUSLY! It was beautifully decorated, and topped with a starfish, shell, and a sand dollar that looked real, almost too pretty to eat! The cake was ordered at the last minute (the day before my birthday) and the owner was able to fit it in - thank you so much!!! Highly recommend this gem of a shop!

I ordered a round large gluten free cake for a birthday party. Custom decorated butter cream frosting outside and cream cheese filling on three layers of vanilla cake. It was AWESOME in every way. Everyone loved it. The custom decorations were way beyond my expectations. It truly set the mood for the grand finale. Highly recommend. Thank you for such a wonderful cake.

The cupcakes were moist, fresh and amazing!!! I would recommend you stop in for a treat.

I absolutely love this place !! So amazing I ordered my sons 1st birthday cake ! He has a special diet and she made sure to meet his needs and make everything perfect !! ❤Lisa is amazing with extreme talent ! The cake was moist and just perfect !!! I have no complaints! Professional service and a perfect set of cakes she went above and beyond the description I wanted ! She gave me better than what I asked for !!! I highly recommend her ! Oh and her smores bars are to die for 😍😍😍

We had less than a week to plan a wedding because of a threat of hurricane in our area and I called Lisa and she helped us out on very short notice. The cupcakes were delicious and beautiful!! Thank you so much for your kindness during a very stressful time for us.

I just recently moved to town and these are my favorite cupcakes!! Everything is fresh and baked with love. The owner Lisa is incredibly friendly and ready to make custom orders. You should definitely visit this bakery and don't forget to try the biscuits!

We ordered two pies for Thanksgiving and they were incredible! We had six adults and two young children, and one pie would have been enough - they're enormous! The pumpkin was smooth and luxurious, and the apple was crunchy on top and delicious inside. I highly recommend this bakery!

I went in to get an assortment of items. The YOLO and cheddar biscuits are delightful. The Owner was very nice and polite, I hear they are coming up with a new cupcake that is butter-finger based. This could aaaaarrrrgggg-uably be the best cupcake yet. After having a salted carmel cupcake I dropped off the assortment at my mother house. She called me at work (my mother never calls me at work) and said "what are those little biscuit things, they are delicious".

The decor is awesome and the display of desserts is fantastic. Best I have had!!

Stopped in for a quick bite before my rehab next door. I am a baker myself. I loved the biscuits as well as the peanut butter ball. She warmed the biscuit up for me and the peanut butter ball was perfect. I'll definitely be back!

I've had 6 different cupcakes from this adorable bakery and they were all delicious (hence I devoured them) The coconut was my favorite! I'll be back for a cake for my son's 1st birthday.

I have to share the experience I just had with this company. They/Lisa won my heart forever. With Flagler College Graduation being postponed and not being able to be with my daughter in her "graduation day", I wanted to do something special for her. I had hoped to have some flowers and a cake delivered to her. Unfortunately, Lisa informed me they no longer deliver. BUT she called me back 5 minutes later to tell me she is going to make this happen for my daughter. She too was a Flagler Mom and get's it. I am forever grateful that human compassion still exists and all the more reason to support small businesses.

Fantastic Service, My sister has celiac disease so she cannot have Gluten at all or she gets violently ill. Sugar Island had Gluten free cupcakes just for her.

I ordered a gluten-free chocolate peanut butter naked wedding cake. It was by far the best cake I have had. Would recomend this place for every occasion.

Awesome. Awesome. Awesome Cupcakes. We had the coconut dream & cinnamon spice. Icing melted in our mouths. Yummy!!!