Marcileno's Pizzeria & Grill

I've been getting their pizza delivered or carry out for many years. It is the best pizza in Sussex like they say or anywhere. I always get the Sussex Supreme thin crust with no green peppers. I don't understand all the negative reviews.

Amazing experience all around! Super nice server, generous with the toppings and fast service!! Pizza and cheese bread were amazing! We will definitely be back!!

WOW! I had a very, very good cheeseburger and seasoned fries. The buffalo wings were meaty and fantastic. I had pizza and a slider on my last visit, also very,very good as wel. Check this place out , you will not be disappointed. Friendly staff and great service.

Ordered the Smokehouse Bacon Cheeseburger all the way, onion rings, 2-liters and the food and delivery service were excellent! I love a hamburger the is not condiment shy, and the A-1 rocks this hamburger. Onion Rings were hot and not soggy, and delivery was within 30 minutes. Loved the food, and the delivery service is good. Loved it so much that I am ordering again tonight!

I live in Colgate and they delivered!

Service: Very polite (Both the girl who took my phone order and the driver), incredibly fast (Was told it would be 1 hour for delivery but only took about 1/2 that!!!).

Pizza: Ordered a thin crust with pepperoni and black olives. The sauce was very tasty, the only thing was the amount of toppings. It was a little light for my taste, there could have been more. Yes, there was toppings on each piece but would have liked to have had just about 25% more and it would have been perfect!

Price: Total for a large thin crust pizza w/ 2 toppings and a 2 liter of Coke delivered was $22 and change. Not shabby.

Overall: New to this area and this is the first place I found that would deliver to my house. They WILL be delivering again!!! Great pizza, great service, you guys will be back, oh yes, you will be back....

Terrific, juicy chicken with just the perfect skin (not too thick, not too greasy, just right)!!! Very good pizza and wonderfully patient and kind take out phone service. I called without knowing the menu and received stellar service without the hint of annoyance or complaint from the woman who answered the phone. All the relatives loved the food!

It looked like not a single employee was over the age of 20. The storefront definitely needed some updating but my friend and I just wanted to sit and eat some pizza so we did stay. I'll tell you this, I have never been served by a friendlier group of people. Everyone there made it a point to ask if we needed anything. A delivery boy even stopped on his way out the door with an order to ask if he could get us parmesan or crushed red pepper. I wish I would've known they would be so nice and respectful when I paid for my order so I could've given them a bigger tip. And the pizza was good too! Little too much sauce even for my tastes, but a fantastic crust. I will definitely be buying their again if not to just support this awesome staff.

Visited for the first time today and I have to say this is the best pizza I have had in a while! We got the hand tossed pizza with pepperoni and sausage and it was delicious! Perfect amount of toppings and super cheesy (which is a plus in my book) with what tasted like a garlic bread type crust. Very friendly and helpful staff that can be expected from a small town type restaurant. This will for sure be my new go to place when iam craving some homemade pizza.

I Must say this is the best pizza that I've had since my last visit. Every item that I have tried on the menu was superb! Will recommend this establishment to my friends. Pay a visit, you won't be disappointed. Friendly staff, great service. A+

I think they are vary caring about the food . I have food delivery from them. Allways hot. Pizza is great, brosted chicken is also good. Never had a bad meal from them . Frindly people on phone that you can understand when they speak.

Great pizza. The thin crust is the best. I am very critical of pizza and I am hooked on their pizza. I wish they had a punch card deal for every pizza you purchase. Any true pizza lover will appreciated their crust, sauce and meats. If not, go back to your Pizza Hut!

Excellent pizza, nothing over powers anything, and very generous with the cheese, crust was beautiful and crispy with a lovely hit of garlic.. blew me away. I. can see lots of pride put into his pizza shop. Would recommend!!!

I had a good experience, asked for garlic bread at the last moment. Front woman had it ready in just a few minutes.
Sauce is similar to Pizza Hut, which I like!

Excellent pizza!! They do seem understaffed, however. Every time I order, they tell me it’ll be 20-25 minutes and it ends up being double the wait time, however, it is worth the wait!

I love the food that I've tried; lasagna, burgers, and fried veggies were great, sauce on their pizza was not as spicy as I like, but still very good! They really load them up! I plan to try the chicken some time soon.

Great food. Don't listen to anybody complaining about undercooked chicken. People tend to freak out over any sight of blood, even if the meat is cooked. And as long as the meat is cooked completely it's fine.

I have had the BEST pizza here , best place around !!!! The past two times I've ordered , they used a bit tooo much pizza sauce, and I did not receive my magnets lol!? Other than that....I'm hooked!!!

Didnt get my ranch with the breaded mushrooms but thats ok. They r beyond delicious without it. Philly steak and fries equally delicious!

The pizza was delicious! My kids loved it & they are picky! We'll definitely go back! Highly recommend it! 👌

This place is amazing! The customer service is up to par, the food is amazing and Milly was beyond helpful and nice. Will definitely be coming back.