Cold Spring Pizza

Stopped in after a late lunch at the Cold Spring Depot. Incredible vodka slice. Loads of thick mozzarella and an exceptional sauce with the perfect sweetness. They have double chocolate cookies that are warmed up in the oven too and were just as good as the pizza. Really good stuff at this place. Well worth a visit if in the area.

Vacationing in the area, and came in on New Year’s Day for a couple slices and loved it so much, we came back for a whole pie a few hours later. These guys definitely know what they’re doing! Absolutely LOVED it!! Angel even offered to make me a vegan pizza. It’s not on the menu, but the accommodation was very much appreciated!!

Amazing pizza! I usually don't buy pizza in slices but these are the best pizza I've ever had! I ordered two and immediately went back for another two!

Their chick-fil-a pizza is AMAZING! Though it’s packed with calories but I will burn them off on my way up the trails, lol.
It’s like having Nathan’s french fries with bacons and cheese, and add chicken cutlet on it, but even better! My favorite slice this year!
And they make their own sauce in house, that’s another plus.
And friendly service, ordered a slice of ricotta cheese with eggplant as well, total was $10. Nice price for all that food.

We had the best penne alla vodka here!!!! The pizza was equally delicious and we definitely recommend anyone in the area (or even out of the area) to visit. The service was excellent and we could not have had a better dinner in cold spring.

Really nice place and the pizza was great!

Friendly service in an old school pizza shop with a nice atmosphere - the pizzas are huge and taste great!

Wow! Great find! The specialty pizzas - garlic & marinara or eggplant & ricotta - are the way to go. We grabbed those and a half mushroom pie that was also delicious, but on return visits we will load up on the house pies! Knock it back with a couple of cold Stewart's sodas.

I’ve been lucky enough to live just a few doors away from this pizzeria for about two years now. The pizza is stellar, like the greatest that NYC might offer, the customer service is amazing and friendly. I genuinely enjoy popping in just to see everyone even if it’s not time for a meal. Funny thing though, they do some of the greatest wings I’ve ever had. I made a special request to turn up the heat tonight and WOW did they deliver. Absolutely 10/10 recommend stopping in if you’re in the area, or here for a day trip. You won’t be disappointed!

This is not the cold spring pizza I remember 20 years ago. This guy makes beautiful pies excellent cheese sauce ratio. Krispy crust at a good thinness. It's a good solid New York slice of pizza. Can't wait to go back.

When you say "atmosphere" for a pizza joint, this place is pretty much textbook.

Obviously a family run operation, I got great vibes from the (father/son/cousin?) pair running the pizza oven and counter.

I tried three slices and gotta say on two of them it was knocked outta the park. Unfortunately the third had probably been on par too long and topping was a bit tough - but the others more than made up for it.

Lots of regulars and returning customers during lunch.

This is a fun family friendly pizza place. Definitely worth trying anything they say is good or fresh.

Classic village pizza shop! Could not ask for anything more. Pizza is great and the service is even better. Perfect place to bring kids. Secret sneaky menu item.. whatever soup they have bubbling that day. Other pizza shops come and go, but there is only one Cold Spring Pizza.

Fair prices and very friendly staff. We recommend it!

People friendly place, fast service and good pizza. This place also sales ice cream (even in November) and they have a bathroom for the customers. Anymore, who ever visited Cold Spring NY, understands the importance of it. Other businesses are NOT so customer friendly.

Awesome and delicious pizza! Tried it once with friends, been back already, and we'll be back again.

Edit 2023
Pizzas are fantastic, pastas are great, chicken wings are excellent too.

Excellent NYC Pizza! This place is really good and I'm very picky with Italian food(I grew up in Queens). The regular slice is good. The Sicilian is awesome. It's perfect. Try a slice and you'll be hooked. I take home a whole Sicilian pie everytime I'm there.

always an awesome time here. chill atmosphere, I know most people there, and their Margherita is the 2nd best I've had. Reasonable prices but make sure to bring cash. They got Canadian coke too 😁

Oh good GOD!! My taste buds are in shock. Flavor, flavor, flavor! Hospitality? Was incredible. Mike, the owner, It was great having a good time with you at the table talking about your story and above all my favorite conversation: cuisine. When I return to Texas I will definitely share my visit with you and Cold Spring pizza. meraviglioso, buon tempo, buon cibo, e molte benedizioni!! tutto il meglio! Ciao

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "A Culinary Revelation! Coldspring Pizza in picturesque Coldspring, New York, is a true gastronomic gem! From the moment we stepped into this charming mountain town, we were transported to pizza paradise. The pizzas? Simply divine. The sandwiches? Mouthwatering. And don't even get me started on the focaccia bread – it's pure bliss! If you're looking for an unforgettable dining experience beyond NYC, look no further than Coldspring Pizza. Five stars doesn't do it justice! 🍕🌟

Great place to have a slice of pizza. Also had a very nice selection of craft beer. Located towards the end of the village.