Belly Up Bar

Belly Up certainly lived up to the fish fry hype! And had a absolutely delicious, house made, Bloody Mary.

We had their Fish Fry on Friday...AH-MAZING! We've gone to a lot of fish frys in the area, and Belly Up's was probably one of the best we've EVER had! Fish was very tender and crispy, fries were great, and the coleslaw was a perfect combination! We ordered everything to go (it was still hot when we got home even) because we had a little one with us that was getting antsy, otherwise we would of most definitely stayed for the exceptional atmosphere! Looking forward to our next visit!

Very good fish fry, and cold beer.

Friendly small bar with great staff from the bartenders to the waiters to the kitchen. I had a fantastic experience. Will definitely be going back. Great fish dinner for the right price. Good drinks. Not a long wait to sit down or get dinner and drinks. Cannot recommend higher based off my first experience. Cash only, but they do have an ATM available. Worth bringing out the cash.

My favorite little hometown bar! The staff is friendly fun and good company, the fish frys are unbelievable German potato salad is unreal!!!!great prices on drinks, old school jukebox which I love!! And always friendly regulars there sharing stories with everyone.

Best fish fry around ! I Love the Perch. Can’t go wrong with pancakes or German potato salad or the fries!!! My favorite is the German potato salad. I’m a fisherman and I’d rather throw them back and go here. Honestly no one asked me to write this. I truly think it’s the best!!

Fun little place. Bartenders are always super friendly and attentive. Prices are fair. The customers are also a lot of fun and so nice. Always a good time here.

Not surprising that this place was packed. Their fish fry was well worth the wait and the German Potato Salad was the best l've ever had. The service was outstanding. This will definitely be a Friday destination again.

Best fish fry around. The German potatoe salad is the best !

One of my favorite small time home-y bars in the area. One of our (group of friends) usual “go to’s” for Packer games. Jello shots (via “syringes”), cheap beers, friendly staff & regulars + inclusive games with good payoffs & sometimes a 1/2 time buffet. Always a great time had by all!!!

Sarah the cook is an amazing cook and very friendly.

Excellent corner tavern fish fry. Good old fashioneds as well. Nothing fancy, just good food. Make sure to try the potato pancakes or classic German potato salad (warm and vinegary).

Regularly we drive into surrounding area looking for great fish fry's and Fried Chicken dinners. *Majority of our weekly menu consists of healthy, organic foods so this is always a treat. Tonight we chose Belly Up Bar in Menomonee falls, WI. WOW! We walked in, small quant atmosphere, a little crowded but friendly people all around us. The waitress apologized for the wait (we really hadn't waited more than 5 minites), she checked on us throughout the meal but not the point of being annoying. The food ... reasonably priced, perfectly cooked and it's definitely the place to go for an old fashioned. This speaking from a healthy, fit 40 year old. I'm excited to come back.

Corner bar atmosphere, great selection of music playing. Food was very good. Highly recommend the grill top cod.

Quaint little pub in a cozy neighborhood. service is good and friendly. fish fry is excellent, broasted chicken very good. worth checking out.

Great bar with small town feel. No fancy drink menu, no ipa on tap, just old school wisco bar. A classic.

Love our neighborhood Belly Up bar. Great wings and Lori, the bartender is awesome, as well as Steph.

Fish fry is great. We've been here before and will definitely be back again.

Great fish fry !!!Delicious potato pancakes. very sweet waitress, .... great night at the Belly Up Bar😆

Fish fry is the best! Owner's tattoo is the bomb, be verwey, very, careful asking about seeing the mouse!