Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

Stopped in for some slices while on the road. Was very pleasantly surprised by the pies! Nice crispy thin NY crust and yummy taste! Wish they had pizza like this close to home in CT where my Bronx born and raised husband can enjoy!!

The best pizza hands down.... If you are driving anywhere near Brewster you need to stop by and get a slice..... Any style any toppings... They are all great! A must have!

Amazing. Best pizza around hands down. Quality ingredients with nice staff.

Gaetanos has the best pizza around! We moved to CT, and what they call pizza in CT could be more accurately described as a tragedy. When we want good pizza we drive all the way back to Gaetanos. Every pizza they have is worth the drive, but our favorites are buffalo chicken and sesame chicken. If you think your pizza place has the best buffalo chicken slice then do yourself a favor, and swing by Gaetanos for an upgraded version of your fav. You won't be disappointed.

The Pizza is good, thin crispy crust. Strombolis and Jamaican Patties pretty good too. Always a good variety and the service is polite.

This place is such a gem! Very tasty pizza and everything else! So glad we gave it a try, now ordering 2nd day in a row! My personal favorites are Italian Wedding soup, pepperoni peenwheels and the take-out boxes they give you the food in, so convenient and cute! Staff is very nice and friendly. Will be back soon!

If you like your pizza on the thin crispy side then this is your place period ingredients refresh on the vegetarian pizza generally very pleased

They have my favorite new york style pizza, with a friendly and efficient staff, and a very clean restaurant. Highly recommend!

As coming from the city I always eat great pizza and I’m happy to say that the Lasagna Pizza here is also great pizza and a must have, this pie has now entered my top 3 slices of pizza!!!

Some really good pizza slices, especially the specialties pizzas. Would recommend stopping if you can.

Generally good, just make sure you check the prices of what you order, sometimes make a mistake. I got a cheese Sicilian ($3) and a specialty slice ($3.75) and got charged like $10.19. they don't add a surcharge for a card so I'm not sure where the extra $4 came from, but I like to place and I go there often, so it's not that big of a deal for me. Just check with what you get.

Great food for a great price. Relaxed atmosphere. I liked how you could see the different selections in a case and then they heated them up for you. Everything we had was delicious.

Delicious, fast, cheap, amazing staff. One of the best pizza places I have ever been to. Clean and kind. Couldn't recomend more

I was at the shopping center for something else, and the smell drew me in. Sometimes all the toppings on the pizza makes me switch from my original plan which would be a plain slice right from the oven. I stuck with my gut and got the plain slice. It was by far the best plain slice of pizza I've had in quite some time. The crust was thin and crispy, the cheese was sharp and stringy, the sauce was incredible- just the right amount. This experience peaked my curiosity, is this the best slice around? I tried a few other local places in the area and they did not compare. I went back yesterday to see if my first experience was a fluke and ordered a plain slice again. I was not let down, it's literally the best plain slice and I will continue to go back ! Highly recommend!!! Too busy eating and enjoying to take a photo but will try to remember next time.

Very good prices are very reasonable people that work there are nice friendl food is

on sept. 7th.based on one large cheese pizza medium well done I couldn't ask for better . I prefer a thinner crust pie but it went well with the boys an me ..................I'll be back...............

Truly incredible. A hidden gem! Sesame chicken pizza - it will change your life. A massive selection of pizzas and pastas. Calzones and pinwheels and strombolis. Having lived in NYC, this is top notch Italian.

Excellent spot to grab some great slices and rolls. Plenty of variety for everyone. Will come back.

Great thin crust pizza. Crust has a great crunch. Good sauce and appropriate grease level..😁. every time I'm in town, I hit Gaetanos

Great pizza before, during and after the pandemic! Great service, too. Family friendly. Nice selection of Coca Cola drinks.