Otto Tomotto's

Oh my goodness-I found a new place I love! Otto Tomatto's! I had the Seafood Pesto, and my husband had the C-food Medley. They were both seriously delicious!! We got a dessert to go because I had never heard of Tubolare before. I had no idea what I was missing! Suffice it to say, we'll be returning!

I've been a few times and it's never a disappointment! Top notch all around. I've gone for an adult only night out and with the whole family, including a toddler. I've also ordered for take out/catering. Always warm and inviting. Highly recommend!

Long time patron, but haven’t been since Otto’s moved into the bigger space. Had a quick dinner with a friend because we were too tired to cook and she had never been before. It was excellent. It was a quiet night and we came in only an hour before they close. We still had good service and a delicious meal. It’s nice to see how Otto’s has grown and evolved since it was first opened. My friend and I were both employees at the Victor TGIF, and I remember when the owner used to stop into TGIF after closing all those years ago.

Otto Tomotto's Shrimp and Bacon Risotto is a delicious and inventive dish that is sure to please any seafood lover. The portion size is generous, providing a satisfying meal without feeling heavy. The risotto has a rich and creamy texture that is spot on. The Arborio rice is cooked to perfection, and offered just the right amount of bite while still being creamy and smooth. The addition of shrimp brings a delightful seafood taste to the dish, with each piece cooked to perfection. Bacon adds a smoky and savory element that complements the seafood flavors surprisingly well. The combination of these ingredients creates a harmonious blend of flavors that left me craving more. The dish has a subtle hint of garlic and herbs, enhancing the overall taste without overpowering the delicate flavors of the shrimp and bacon. It was evident that the chef paid attention to every detail, resulting in a dish that was thoughtfully crafted.

We love the atmosphere and friendliness of staff every time we go. Their Alfredo sauce is top notch. They are also one of the few places in the area that has veal parm, my guy’s favorite.

Always a great meal, polite service and generous portions.

This is an Italian restaurant that simply does not get talked about enough! The food here is phenomenal and has been since I first went to this place years ago. The Route 96 Pasta Bake will make you wish there were seconds, and the portions are worth the prices.

This place was incredible. I loved the food. Unfortunately I do not have a menu in front of me but I certainly hope with enough leftovers to take care of lunches for a couple days. The wait staff was on the ball and courteous. I would definitely recommend this place.

we stopped here on our way to ohio from new england, and it was so good we genuinely might make it an annual tradition. the bread and water came out right away and was fantastic. soft and garlicky. we had calamari, which came with poppyseed sauce (which i never would have tried with calamari on my own, but it was delicious!), as well as an excellent caesar salad. i had gnocchi with beans and greens, which was very warm and tasty. my husband had shrimp and sausage diavolo, which he greatly enjoyed. servers also made a point to make sure the (very plentiful) leftovers went right side up in the boxes to prevent spilling, which was very helpful and thoughtful.

Awesome atmosphere. Very cozy and homey. Very clean and organized. Wait staff are cordial and friendly. Spoke with Susan “Momma” owners son, several times as she made her rounds. It is very evident that she takes great pride in the restaurant. The highlight of the evening was the food. Fresh. Hot. Delicious. Our new favorite restaurant.
Thank you-

Second time eating here and we always make a point of stopping here when we're in town! Best home cooked Italian food in the area. Service is always attentive and helpful when choosing your meal. C-food medley is my favorite but many classics to choose from!!

My wife and I were greeted by a very friendly staff member and seated and asked if we had been there before we had not so he proceeded to inform us of menu items very helpful brought fresh bread to table and was also very helpful with our ordering we will definitely return.......ps food was awesome

The food was delicious! Portions were generous! Service was fantastic! Prices were fair! The only drawbacks for us was distance. We'll definitely visit again!!

Sat down quickly by the incredibly friendly and attentive front of house manager Alex. Amazing Italian classics along with interesting cocktails. Don’t skimp out on the tubolare! You have to check this place out.

Very nice place with excellent service! My steak was delicious ... everyone else in our party praised their meals as well.

Pleasantly surprised at how healthy and delicious the menu options are! Fun and clean atmosphere. Friendly staff

Great food, delicious and plenty of it as well (big meals). servers are very kind!

Excellent meals: I had the Italian Fish Fry and my wife ordered the Seafood Pesto.
The food came out in a reasonable amount of time and was piping hot! The service was cordial and attentive. One of the owners came by twice to make sure we were having an enjoyable dining experience.

I've taken my grandkids here 4 times now. Each time they and I have been happy with our meals. The older one loves the lasagna (as do I ) the younger has less adventurous tastes but has gotten his own pizza that he takes half of home. Me I'm well pleased with every meal I've had I especially like their sauce which is very tomato forward not overpowered by garlic or spices. The bar is limited but the food is exceptional well worth the trip. Try you'll like it.

The staff here are incredible - open to teasing and getting in on a joke with my wife, a totally enjoyable atmosphere with generous portions.