Sal's Pizzeria

The new bar is awesome! Food was great and the bartenders rocked. It was so busy but they didn’t seem to leave anyone waiting!

So delicious! The red sauce was on point, the RATIOS of my pepperoni slice were perfection. This spot definitely hit the spot for my NY pizza cravings. The staff was awesome, hard working, attentive and helpful. Definitely recommend this joint.

I just moved here from downstate NYC and was shopping in the area n seen Sal's. I stopped in and decided to have their Grilled Chicken panini n OMG....IT WAS AMAZING!!!! I had Sat down in the bar section and the lady who served us was very pleasant and even the group of people who came to watch college football were very friendly. Everyone knew everyone. It just felt like a great neighborhood friendly place to go to for good food, drinks and nice company. I will DEFINITELY be back!!!!

Thank you Sal's! After a day of canoeing on beaver lake we definitely worked up an appetite. We have heard great things about the food and pizza so decided to give them a try. We are a family of 6 so we never know if there will be accomodations for our party size. We got there around 3:30 and got greeted and sat right away. It was only the bar tender but we didn't mind this at all. She got our drink order right away and did a fantastic job making my Manhattan. We didn't realize that there was a different menu for lunch and dinner so when we started reading the menu we were surprised that we couldn't find some of the items we heard about. After a quick explanation from the server and because it was so close to their dinner hour the staff allowed us to order off the dinner menu. We were so grateful for this because the food we ordered was exactly what we wanted. Everything was delicious and everyone was happy and satisfied. My favorites were the chicken wing pizza on the cauliflower crust, the pasta fagioil, and the lobster raviolis. But everything was great, service was excellent, and the kitchen staff gets 5 stars for accommodating us so graciously. Thank you.

Stopped in because I heard they made sausage rolls in the area. So also ordered a calzone to see how well they were made, and even grabbed slices while there. I cannot say enough positive things about the food I had. If you haven't tried a sausage roll from here do yourself a favor and order one.

Delicious pizza and wings.
Phenomenal service. Our server was Mary Jo (MJ), and she was simply wonderful!!
This was our first time dining here, but it most certainly will not be our last.

Sal’s in Baldwinsville. Thank you for not making me cook on Mother’s Day and able to feed my children and grandchildren! Sorry pictures were taken after many scoops were served!🤣Chicken riggies medium, which everyone raved about! Had a nice kick even though ordered medium due to feeding grandchildren and kids that don’t love the heat 🔥 like I do! Antipasto was excellent and meatballs! I ordered 5/13 for a pick up at 2pm 5/14. Was hot and fresh for hours the way they package. I would definitely recommend for an occasion you don’t want to cook!

The pizza sauce is perfection. I got "The Naz" and it did not disappoint.

Had dinner on day 3 of opening. At the new bar, great atmosphere. The owners are wonderful entrepreneurs. They give back to the community. Very engaged.
Great food. Fun time. Watch your favorite sports team.

Amazing pizza and they have a desert that is too good to exist. Peanut butter moose.

If you are a late night person. Call and confirm they are open. Google web says 10 pm on Thursday. Door says 9. Doh.

My go to pizzeria! Fantastic entrees and great pizza. I got the loaded French fries too and they were fantastic.

Always a great meal here, and tonight was no exception! Curry shrimp was perfect, and the Tiramisu was a fantastic finish to the meal!

Wow what an amazing place in Baldwinsville. The food, staff, and wine are all off the hook. Check them out ASAP!

Nice place. We had 6 people, so we Ordered 2 large pizzas, wings, and an anti pasta. Also got a pitcher of lemonade. Everything was very tasty. Total before tip was $75

Solid pizza and the real winner here are the wings with their house sauce. Most of the time we order here for just the wings. Not sure how other menu choices are but I hear good things. Staff is always friendly and the place is always packed which is a good sign. If you haven't tried em yet give it a go.

Very good food, both the spaghetti bolognese and lasagna tasted like everything was home made, I like my lasagna to have a lot of extra sauce and this one was spot on

My group of friends ordered pizza and wings for game night last night. We got 2 large Pizzas and an order of their house wings. We duh right in and it was all sooo good. I'm not a huge wing person but they were delicious. Then we get a knock on the door and they came with a 2nd order of wings that we didn't even call about and they said "sorry we gave u the wrong wings, here's the right ones" . We didn't even notice we had the wrong wings nor did we call and complain so that was fantastic customer service.

Absolutely amazing food. Been here twice and it's my go to spot. I grew up in an Italian family and their stuffed meatballs are just like my mother's. Sauce is on point, best Alfredo I've had eating out as well. 5/5 would recommend

Fantastic food and great service. It's a bit noisy there while construction is underway, but still worth the trip !

The food is PHENOMENAL!!! Best chicken riggies anywhere,hands down,no contest. And although prices can be a little steep , Tuesday is a two for one special that last I knew included riggies, which is quite the deal at the price. Garlic knots and pizza are also first class, service friendly. They have my permanent business.