Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza

Menu looks amazing! 👌🏻 Atmosphere is very warm and cozy and even tho I'm not ordering, just yet, Ive been given a water to wait on. Absolutely thoughtful staff. So polite. I feel like they work real hard and that's what I'm here for. 🫶🏻💪🏻

The wait time was a little long for the stromboli as they were making it fresh but it was the best stromboli I ever had, nice soft dough and cheesy string pull. We also ordered the fire wood pizza which was nice a crispy as well as the garlic knots, all piping hot. Our waitress was excellent in making sure we were taken care of and she had this great upbeat attitude which made for a great first time here, will definitely return!

Delicious as always. I got the gluten free Detroit style with cup & char pep. My husband got the wood fired garlic base with cup & char pep, and mushrooms (not gf).

Great spot, friendly staff and great pizza! We always get the Risotto bites or fried pickles as an appetizer and they're always good. Have tried numerous pizzas but the 12" crust and size is the best. Bit of a Pickle is our favorite and go-to but the Buffalo Chicken, 3 Little Pigs, Veggie Monkey and The Daino are all delicious. I don't think you can go wrong here. Orders are always on time and cooked to perfection. Definitely recommend!

I've been a fan of Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza for a long time. Visiting them at food truck rodeos, festivals and the NY State Fair. I've always have had a consistently well prepared and delicious pizza. They have two brick and mortar locations. The North Syracuse location is the original. They opened their second location at Township 5 in Camillus back in the fall of 2020. This review is of their Camillus location. I have been to this location numerous times and always order three wood fired pies on each visit.
The wood fired pizzas come in 10 inch and 12 inch pies. For this visit the three wood fired pies all had a nice crisp crust. The Margherita had fresh mozzarella and the perfect flavor balance of basil and garlic.
Tessa's Veggie had fresh vegetables such as tomato, broccoli and pecorino. You didn't miss a veggie in every slice.
We also wanted to try a "novelty" type of wood fired pizza. We went with one that Toss & Fire created for the NY State Fair, the Bit of a Pickle.
Garlic, Applewood bacon, Mozzarella, Cheddar, dill pickles and a ranch drizzle. Don't sell this pie short. All the flavors worked well together. I learned not to term some foods a "novelty" until I try it! Instead I will change the term to unique. They still have a couple more "unique" pies that I have not tried yet!

The chicken wings were ordered extra crispy with hot Buffalo sauce. An order comes with ten wings. They were nice sized wings and glad I ordered them extra crispy because when I got home they seemed like they had a normal crisp to them. Will not knock that since it was takeout and I'm sure if I ate at the restaurant they would of been as ordered.

The staff are always welcoming and able to answer any questions you may have while placing your order. Once you order they give you a vibrating beeper to let you know when your order is ready. If it's longer than 20 minutes I like to walk around Township 5 checking out the other shops.
You can also order online from their website.
Toss & Fire also has normal NY style pizza oven pies along with Detroit style pizza. I haven't tried their Detroit or NY styles yet and probably won't until I go down the line of their wood fired menu.

Had the Detroit style pizza that was awesome, nice beer selection, good customer service,

This place was delicious! I was a bit wary when I first got there, it looked like a Blaze type place (if anyone has been to the chain out West) but this wasn’t Blaze at all. They had SO MANY OPTIONS! It actually made us a slight bit anxious because we were overwhelmed with the choices. We ended up with a NY style 4 cheese pizza and we added some broccoli, onions and garlic. It was absolutely perfect. We saved half of it begrudgingly because we wanted to eat it for dinner too. Our waitress was a sweetheart as well! It was my husbands 30th birthday and he said it was everything he wanted and then some!

We've never try Detroit style pizza before, so when we found out about this place, we were excited and it didn't disappoint.
The place is nice, with a few tables and a bar area. Nicely divided if you just want a slice to go, just enjoy a quick bite, or have more time for a proper table dinner.
Our server was amazing! She was so friendly and helpful, was very refreshing, we even tipped her extra because of how nice she treated us.
Now, the food. It was everything we thought and more! We'll be coming back for sure! The dough is so nice and fluffly, it reminds me of focaccia. It has some extra cheese on the edges, and the toppings are delicious. They are also very accommodating to vegetarians, which is one of reasons we tipped extra.

Highly recommend, try the Detroit style!

I'll start by saying that I like ny style pizza and I love wood-fired. There's only two other places in town that do a good job besides Toss & Fire, but not many other choices. Toss & Fire consistently does a great job. My husband always picks up pizza for work. Just a pepperoni is delicious. Sundays, we have family get-together and this is our choice. My kids love this place as well. They have an appetizer, Garlic Bites. It's so good. It's like a pizza of garlic and Romano I believe. Comes with marinara. 😋
My daughter loves the Bee Sting. Has sopressata and honey drizzled. All their pizzas are done well. Chicken wings are delicious. Cheeky monkey 👌 and the girls that work there are so kind. They're the example of great customer service.

T&F has the BEST wood fired pizza I've had anywhere in Central NY or Southern Tier... I prefer ordering "well done" to get a good amount of char... great toppings, and plenty of them. Love the garlic oil option instead of tomato sauce.

Really good artisan pizza. This place is definitely in another league from your standard pizza shop. Staff are always friendly and helpful. They also have a great list of craft beers on tap!

On 08/23/23 we held our wedding in Skaneateles in which Toss N' Fire catered.

In short, the food was amazing, the service was exceptional, and they made sure they was a constant rotation of fresh pizzas for our wedding guests to enjoy.

We opted to go for a buffet style as opposed to the food truck where you walk up and order a pizza, and we couldn't be happier. They were able to setup their own tables with signage for all of the items we purchased, including the multiple different types of specialty pizza. They then made sure there was never a time where a pizza was empty, as they were able to anticipate which items would be going fast.

I also wanted to mention that one of the pizza-makers (I apologize for not getting his name). specifically came up to my wife and I to ask us what kind of pizza we would like, and then bring us our own personal ones to our seats. It was very kind, and we felt as though it was something he did not need to do, but offered to do it anyways.

Toss N' Fire not only has an amazing restaurant, but their catering is also top notch, and if you would like to have a wedding where you and your guests enjoy amazing pizza and other items, I could not recommend them enough.

Tonight was my first time ever ordering I had a salt potato pizza which was fricken bomb and I also had the most amazing like holy crab amazing mozzarella sticks that were shaped like calzones and they were huge and I’m mad I didn’t order more. Only complaint is they didn’t have sour cream for my pizza but other than that this is my new favorite place..

Amazing food, amazing beer, and amazing service. They over do it on the oregano but that’s all I can find bad about this place. You won’t regret it.

Our family tries to support local restaurants during the pandemic. We ordered 3 pizzas from Toss & Fire last night. The ordering process was quick and easy through GUBHUB, and delivery was on time. We had the Cheeky Monkey, the Chicken Bacon Ranch, and the Caprese. We all agreed that the pizzas were unique, had good taste, and the crust was perfect. Overall, a very good experience. We will be trying more of their unique flavors in the future. Thank you to Toss & Fire for staying open and serving the public.
***We ordered again this weekend, even better with pick-up instead of grubhub. See pictures.
***After yet another order, our family decided on 5 stars. Rating upgraded. Excellent pizza!

Had Toss & Fire (again) today, amazing as usual! So quick and delicious!

As always we tried them at the Fair and absolutely fantastic taste. Service was quick and employees at the fair were very friendly. They have also shared that Gyro pizza at the fair is the best, which we will try next time.

Definitely will try again.. taste is mouth watering. Highly recommended.

I live within walking distance of another pizza place. I drive to Toss and Fire because their pizza is much better. Love the variety of different specialty pizzas. They do an excellent thin crust pizza. No one else in the area does the wood-fired pizza as well as they do. Plus they have a great selection of craft beers on tap as well.

We had Toss 'n' Fire cater for our wedding, and it was delicious. Lots of specialty pizza flavors, and sides available. Nick is very personable and accommodating. Prices are reasonable as well. We highly recommend Toss 'n' Fire for catering on any occasion. We also love to eat in their dining room.

The food and service are always incredible. We really love the caprese salad, Detroit style pizza (all of them!) and the great craft beer selection.