P&M Orange Street Market

They have all sorts of sandwiches. Wanted to check this place out after watching Joel Hansen take on a food challenge there. The hot sandwiches are really great! The atmosphere and outdoor seating felt super homey.

Ate the first half so fast I almost forgot to take a picture. Lit. Just make sure you order right. You’re not here for a diet, you’re here for a bomb sando that will make your day yaaaaaaa heaaaaaaard

I worked with Maria in catering and had a great experience. Food was very good. I ordered for a family event and delivery was very important. The delivery person was communicative and confirmed food arrival. Maria was super helpful in the selection process and very knowledgeable. Highly Recommend.

Terrific neighborhood deli with great sandwiches, prepared foods, small grocery items. Super friendly, discount if you pay in cash. An East Rock treasure.

Love that this place is local to New Haven for a quick bite. They make quality breakfast, lunch, and dinner options. I enjoyed their breakfast sandwiches (Sausage, egg and cheese on a roll) and their lunch options (Italian Combo) as I am at work. Highly recommend this place if you are looking for something to eat in the area!

Two weeks later and people are STILL raving about the fantastic food and service Pino and his crew provided for my daughters wedding.
Their catering is top notch! The food was amazing, the staff was courteous and pleasant, and Pino saw that every last detail was taken care of. These people clearly love what they’re doing.
Don’t hesitate to hire P&M for your next gathering. You won’t be disappointed!

I have lived and worked in the East Rock neighborhood for many years and P&M Orange Street Market is a staple in my life. Whether it's to pick up milk or another staple on the way home or to buy a freshly made delicious meal for my family at the end of a busy day, P&M is a lifesaver. What makes the experience so wonderful is the staff. I know each of them by name and they know me by name. The gals up front at the register are consistently welcoming, friendly, and helpful. The folks behind the deli line are always working hard and quickly while still taking the time to ask how my day is going or to circle back to a conversation we might have been having the previous time I was in the store. Pino the owner and Barbara the manager are always on hand for questions, special orders, or just a friendly hello. The wonderful outdoor seating area has always been a plus but now, during the pandemic, it is a safe and easy place to meet up with a friend or a colleague for lunch or a snack. P&M is a family owned neighborhood business that is part of the fabric of the neighborhood and treats everyone like family. A true gem!

Love visiting P&M whenever I am in New Haven! Excellent food, wonderful customer service, great coffee! The owner Pino is a phenomenal Chef with a heart for all people and keeping Yale students well feed! Try the Braciole if you get the opportunity! 🤩

This place has great sandwiches! Always fresh and delicious. Staff is always very friendly. The market is very nice with very fresh produce and a nice selection of lots of essential food items.

I go to P&M at least once a day, sometimes twice! The staff is friendly, the breakfast sandwiches are huge and reasonably priced, different lunch specials every day! They also have ample outdoor seating for nice days. I can't recommend this place enough.

Great sandwiches and great vibe outside. The grocery selection is sort of small and pricey but has most necessities. Nice to pair with a beer from next door! No bathroom... Closest might be Archie moore's

One of the best markets in the area for lunch! They have great selection with plentiful salads and delicious sandwiches and wraps. We order lunch from P&M on a regular basis and it is always on time and fresh. As a bonus, it is always a pleasure to see their delivery man, Bruce and Pino, the owner, is a class act.

Great lunch spot in the heart of East Rock! Community Staple & variety of options

I’ve been going to this store for a while, tried almost everything on the menu, and created great relationships with everyone at p&m! Great customer service and recently really positive experiences despite the pandemic. I definitely recommend to anyone visiting or living in New Haven!

Reasonable priced grocery store & deli. Love the frozen pastas especially gnocchi. Best thing is that they sell G-cafe breads as well!

I go all the time for sandwiches, salads, and groceries. My experiences have all been very good. I especially like the Cobb salad - it is absolutely massive (even the smaller size).

Had the pizza truck at our home for a party. Staff was great!! Pizza was amazing. Everyone was happy!! Will definitely use again!!

Great environment, delicious food, fast service. Manager was incredibly nice and helpful. Cute little outdoor area to enjoy your food. Definitely will be going back!

P & M is the only spot I eat eggplant parm besides my moms cooking, it's my go to when I come here, everything is always so fresh, even when you have things catered. Orange street location has outdoor seating with thr packy next door so it's the best of both worlds for ya!! You will not be disappointed whether your grabbing lunch, something you forgot at the bigger chain store or catering a whole family feast they have you covered!!

Delicious food and great service! The extensive, freshly made menu is delightful! The fast and friendly service is exceptional! Their catering services are top notch! A New Haven MUST!