P B & Jay's Café

Needed the extra boost to my morning and stopped in. Beautifully decorated and charming cafe with some baked goods offered but they were out the day I dropped by. The my have ample sitting outside for those warm days and plenty of cozy seating options inside as well. Friendly staff and great coffee menu to suit just about anyone’s needs. Attached to a local thrift antique shop for shopping fun. Group favorites iced late mocha done just right! Cheers!

During my first visit there, I got thrown out because I refuse to wear a mask. So, I boycotted them for a very long time. Then, one day I was craving a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and stop by. The sandwich was huge and excellence. So good, that I will forgive them for their mask tactics. I will return. Oh, and when they’re busy parking is very tight. Lastly, I wish they were open on Sunday.

Cute little place in Fletcher. The snicker doodle cookie I had was great and I took a quiche home to make for later.

Cute little coffee shop with some great breakfast and lunch foods as well. Visited on 2 different trips to the area recently. Quiche, muffins and the espresso bourbon brownie were all delicious.

The decor and the ambiance is beautiful and relaxing. The service was sweet and polite. I ordered a ham and swiss quiche and a chai latte with a shot of expresso. The quiche was served toasty warm and my chai was perfect. I took mine to go, but there's plenty of places to stay and enjoy your food. Highly recommend giving this Cafe a try. I know I'll be back. 😋

Oh my goodness! I had the banana Nutella wrap which was heavenly!! Also the latte with almond milk and brown sugar cinnamon syrup-- perfectly made! (Also got a biscotti to go). I'll be coming here regularly whenever I'm in town. Yummers!

Savannah and Corey made us some of the best lunch we’ve had in a while. Food and coffee was perfect. And the atmosphere and in the shop feels like home. We’ll be back again and again.

Lovely staff, great food and coffee! My husband loves PB&J sandwiches and the name of this cafe did not disappoint. Definitely coming again next time we are in town!

What a cute coffee shop!! I started my morning here with a sugar free Hazelnut Wake me up! It did just the trick.

We looooove PB&Jays Café! My boyfriend and I have tried all their speciality sandwiches and a few of their hot drinks, we are never disappointed!

Excellent spot! We have lived in Arden for 3 years now and we have finally gotten to drop in after passing in on the road a bunch! The food was fantastic, never thought a PBJ sandwich could get fancy but they do it right!!! And the coffee was spot on! We found one of our new breakfast/brunch spots close to home!

Best quiche I’ve had in a looooong time. And the chai is superb! Glad I found this little spot after a frustrating experience at the airport. Thank you!

I gave a three only because I ordered a pecan scone that turned out to be a bacon and chive. I called to make them aware. They were apologetic and offered a refund (I have received it as of yet). I also ordered a pb&j with wheat berry bread and a coffee. I hadn't eaten all day, and it hit the spot. The atmosphere was calm and the service was warming. The three young ladies were pleasant to speak with. I will visit again.

**Update..I never received the refund 7/26/23**

I’ve been wanting to try this place for a while and I’m so glad I stopped in after a Saturday morning workout! The staff was extremely patient, kind and knowledgeable as I waffled between some tasty items on the menu, and they were great about making recommendations and bearing with my indecision. Super prompt service, too. I had the Sunrise sandwich, which was the perfect balance of sweet/savory and not too heavy. Will definitely be back!

This local coffee shop and café has a great vibe. Easy to do some work at a table. Good coffee and friendly staff. They even have the “good” ice. IYKYK!

I loved this place! So cute. I met a friend there for coffee and breakfast. It was my first time in the Cafe, and the staff was so friendly! They explained the whole menu to me, and I didn't feel rushed to just make a choice and order already. The whole menu is cleverly based on PB&J, and all the menu items were reasonably priced from $5-$10. I had an Americano coffee and the Breakfast Banana Split. Both were excellent. Thanks, PB&Jay's. I can't wait to come back and try more of your offerings!

Very cute spot! Loved the outdoor seating and the order window. I forgot my mask so I was grateful to have a way to order from outside! The pecan butter is AMAZING! So good! So glad to have a spot for coffee and a kid-friendly snack right next to a playground! GENIUS! Thanks!

My husband and I went here the other day for lunch. We love Baked Pie Company so we were excited to try their new sandwich cafe. I got a Peanut Butter and Fig sandwich with Brown Sugar Bacon, which was amazing, and my husband got their Ham and Swiss Quiche, which he really enjoyed. We also got ourselves a little rice crispy treat. We definitely will be coming back, everything is delicious and all the employees were wearing masks, which is a definite plus.

In Feb of 2021 I asked PB & Jay to help me with the purchase and delivery of a gift for a dear friend in the Fayetteville area. I live out of state. Kirsten was absolutely amazing. We communicated mostly by text because of my exceptional schedule at the time. And my friend enjoyed the products, the package was well packed. And Kirsten sent me photos of everything so I could see / feel part of this process. So grateful and highly recommend these folks. Hope to stop by sometime I'm in the area. Thank you PB&Jay and thank you Kirsten!

One of the hidden gems of Fletcher. Great atmosphere inside and outside. Excellent location where you can walk a few feet to a playground (Kate’s Park). Quiche and bakery items were delicious. Friendly staff!