Pop's Frozen Custard

The best tasting burger of my holiday. Fries were great too. Delicious hot food and wonderful sundaes for desert. Not the biggest of places, but delicious food for its type….

Small but super cute burger & custard joint. Custard window is great for a quick stop. We had the mushroom Swiss jumbo burger, a black angus cheeseburger, and a patty melt. All were great.

I HAD THE ANGUS 1/3 IB BURGER WITH CHEESE ketchup mayo fried onions pickles. The food was hot and freshly made. The fries were coated with light batter. The food was delicious. Their staff were friendly and professional. They have a very large food and custard selection. Will definitely go there again. The restaurant was clean, the decor was unique. I give it a check it out if in the area. So much better than Wendy's, Burger King or McDonald's

Love Pop's! It is my favorite custard place to go to! The oreo cream is amazing! At Christmas they fun flavors such as hot coco and other flavors. The staff is friendly and helpful. The food is delicious! My family loves it too.

Excellent food, service and atmosphere! Has the vintage restaurant feel and is a great location close to Lime Kiln Park as well as the main Village Park. However, because of this the low amount of seating hurts them in the summer time so I don’t recommend staying during dinner rush.

I'd give six stars if I could. They've turned the big greasy Wisconsin burger into an actual art. Incredibly quality especially for the reasonable price.

Love this gem my #jbabe took us too!! Babe said they have been around for a long time and I’m sure I know why?!! The place itself is very welcoming and cozy. The staff and service was perfect, and the custard was on point!! We have yet to try the all American food so that will definitely be our next visit. So far the BEST custard I’ve ever had!!! Way to end our Sunday Funday!!! Thanks guys!!

It's the Top of the Pops! What a great, old school frozen custard place! Totally retro in all the right ways!

This is a great little dive of a place: small, clean-feeling, kitschy, and with a substantial menu (relative to its genre). I can recommend getting a burger and custard. Interesting detail also: the water was cold, crisp, and glorious. It seems so odd to be raving about water, but it really makes a huge difference!

We had some of the creamiest, most wonderful custard we’ve ever tasted here. My stepson had the vanilla, which was completely free of ice crystals and absolutely smooth and dense.

I had a special flavor of the day called “French Silk,” and it was a rich chocolate confection with dark chocolate pieces in it. It was simply exquisite.

We’ve always liked this place, but I think it’s even better now than it was years ago.

In addition, the staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful, and made us feel welcome. Overall, it was a perfect frozen custard experience, Wisconsin style!

This place is an institution that's been in the town and open longer than I've been on this Earth. I used to go to the high school just up the way and we'd stop by here all the time for food.

About 6 years ago management changed hands, And it's very clear that the new owners are trying very hard to keep the original experience alive.

It's a small place but the food is amazing. It's the best custard you can get in Wisconsin hands down.

My go to order for years has been a large cheese fries to go. The fries are always crispy and delicious, And the tree sauce they use here is just amazing. That being said I've never had a bad experience at this place in my entire life

AWESOME! We are new to the area and have heard great things from this place. Worth the hype and the stomach ache! Haha ❤

Being humble I stumbled into this restaurant in my desperation for A no-meat meal. Quickly I was informed that they offered A veggie melt🤤with a side of onion rings♨. I’m definitely going back 💯

Pop’s custard is sooo Good!! I haven’t been back here since my High school days. It brought back some fond memories. I took my girlfriend here and she loved it. She added the puppy chow to her sundae and she ate the whole thang. She usually doesn’t finish. We will definitely be stopping back anytime were in the neighborhood!

This place is no doubt the best bang for your buck while having delicious custard. They have a wide variety of custard options. Nowhere have I seen as big a malts/shake menu and items such as the puppy chow sundea make going to Pop's a place that can please anyone. The prices are refreshing as one can order a burger and 2 scoops of custard for under $10. Try finding that anywhere else. The atmosphere is the standard small business custard stand. Nothing fancy but gets the job done. Pop's is for sure going to be a frequent stop for us whenever we are in the mood for a great desert while not breaking the bank.

They have the best Custard of anyone out there. Don’t fret about the long lines in summer, it moves faster than you think and it’s worth the wait.

Mmmmm! When craving a sweet treat, stop here and get some custard! The custard is good, the hot fudge is good, the peanut butter sauce is good, and the sundaes are wonderful. They have a great selection of unique sundaes you just can't get everywhere else (like the Strawberry Schaumtorte Sundae).

What a great little find in Menomonee Falls. First, the food. My jumbo cheese butterburger was outstanding, served with a load of grilled onions and pickles. You add your own ketchup and mustard at the table. The fries were fresh from the fryer and crispy - delishous. Finally the chocolate custard was very creamy without a hint of icy chunks. Overall, highly recommended. The seating area is quaint with 90s country decor. Not my style, but it felt like home. I think the place was filled with regulars in a wide range of ages. I'd visit again!

Amazing burgers! I haven't tried anything else because I'm obsessed with their burgers, but they have a big menu with many other things. The staff has always been friendly in person and on the phone, which I absolutely appreciate. I love that they have a walk up window so you don't have to go in. If you're looking for a great burger in the Falls, this place is it.

This place is a small place that has delicious food. Onion rings are great, French fries are made fresh and hot. Butter burgers are good too. My next visit I will try the pork chop sandwich. Then end your meal with their great frozen custard. I chose a root beer float with Sprecher Root Beer. It can get crowded fast! Staff is super friendly.