Mama Mia's Germantown

Carry out on Friday night, the young man who was working was so friendly. He recapped my food order. Pizza was just as delicious as eating in the restaurant. Everyone who knows me knows how much I love the pizza and Mama Mia’s

Thank you for keeping these family recipes alive from your first location in Milwaukee since 1954!! We’re so fortunate to have your famous garlic bread, pizza, salad and lasagna right here in our own back yard. Food and service was amazing. And that margarita was beyond. Soooo good!! Cheers to a great place, great people and a great legacy.

Love the new location! So much more space. Our server was McKenna and she was great! The garlic bread is the best!

Food and service were great. Large portions. Friendly fast service

The original Mama Mia's recipes.... DELICIOUS. Limited menu when we were there...pizzas garlic bread, salad, lasagna, maybe spaghetti. The garlic bread (to die for) and pizza has even a tad more flavor than North Lake Inn or Bluemound Rd, but nonetheless, the original flavor... And it was awesome. The pizza crust, sauce, sausage all three same and wonderful. There was one size salad for$12. I thought it was pretty small for that price and was barely enough for two people.. but we like salad. I just think it should have been at least 50% larger. And it definitely needed more dressing but once we got extra it was delicious. The location is open, but going through some changes. Apparently it used to be half Mexican restaurant half Mama Mia's (nicely divided and different decor on each side... But if I understood correctly, the Mexican half is going to be taken out and replaced with a smokehouse/bbq type restaurant. When you enter it looks like you are inside a Mexican restaurant but the hostess will seat you on the Mama Mia's side... so no, you're not in the wrong place if you feel confused.

So, we had 1 large pizza w sausage, 1 Salad w garlic bread, 1 more garlic bread, 2 sodas . It came to $42 plus we added our tip.

I will definitely go back to this location. I am very VERY happy to know the Mama Mia's recipes are still live and well!

Never disappoints! Have both dined in and carried out. LOVE the garlic buttery bread, pizza and have Gluten-free options too! It gets a bit loud inside but otherwise service has always been spot on too. Thank you!

Lasagna was amazing, the pizza was 🍕 just as good. Appetizers were right on point. Garlic bread 🍞 the best in Wisconsin. Just go and eat ,you won't regret it.

Mom and I enjoyed a great dinner! Our server, Tabitha, was wonderful and so personable! We both scarfed our garlic bread and our lasagna was rich, cheesy and delicious. Social distancing and masking guidelines were followed and we felt very safe. I will be back again - want to try the lemon chicken. Highly recommend.

Busy night, so service was a little slow, but worth the wait. The lasagna and garlic bread are the best around! No one, I'm my humble opinion, does lasagna and garlic bread better than Mama Mia's.

Visited recently and was pleased with the level of service and quality of the food. We had the chicken alfredo and spaghetti with meat sauce and meatballs. Portions are generous and took home the leftovers. One note is the awesome buttered garlic bread. Perfectly toasted and delightfully buttered.

Have had their pizza and garlic bread a number of times. Just amazing taste and always incredible service and food. The people complaining don't know what they are talking about. No frozen pizza can compare.

Wanted to watch a basketball game so they let us eat at the bar. The Chianti wine was good. I had their pasta with marinara sauce and Italian sausage and mushrooms. My wife had their lasagna..her favorite. Their garlic bread was yummy and tasty. Needless to say we had plenty for take home. The service was friendly and attentive.

Ordered a large take out order for my kids birthday party. The men in the kitchen this morning were pleasant and polite! And the chicken parmesan, spaghetti, garlic bread and salad were delicious! A lot of yum this is good while the family was eating! Would definitely recommend Mama Mia's for party catering!

The garlic bread & salad are still the best anywhere I’ve ever eaten! We were there for my birthday on Friday September 7 at about 6:30 and although they were short staffed they still got us seated and served in a really reasonable amount of time considering the circumstances! Very satisfied on all fronts.

Stopped in last Sunday to have lunch with my parents and everything was great! Our server, Ethan was very polite and professional. I ordered the lasagna and was not disappointed. So good! Definitely will be back

The pizza and garlic bread were exactly like the original mama Mia's Andrew was our waiter and he was absolutely awesome can't wait to go back

I hosted a surprise 30th birthday party for my husband at Mama Mia's and I can't say enough good things about this place. Everything was seriously perfect! From the food, to the service, to the room itself....it was all wonderful! Allison was so helpful and kind to get in touch with me ahead of time so I could order all the food and she got every detail right. Jess was an amazing waitress. I highly recommend her.... she was so attentive, friendly, and just did an overall great job. Thank you Mama Mia's for helping me host a special night for my husband that he will remember forever! :) I am SO grateful for all of you! -Brittany F.

Our dinner was a carry out which sounds like, OK. But when I got home from Mama's the Lasagna pan was still so hot I could have used a hot pad. The Mostocolli was just as hot and delicious. The Garlic breads were buttery and wonderful. The hostess was very helpful checking on my order. I would definitely recommend going here. They have very reasonable daily specials and Happy Hour from 4 - 6. What more can we ask for? Thanks for everything.

The service we received on 7-16-19 was amazing. I believe Matthew was our waiter but not positive I remember correctly. Was there with a girlfriend to catch up. He was so in tune with our needs. It was so refreshing to see a waiter that actually knew his job and was so nice. Extremely qualified.

This place is my first choice!!!
Food is great, and the servers-staff are outstanding ❤.
Went there for my birthday, forgot my present, they found it and made sure I got it back. Restored my faith in humanity 😍. Plus the leftover pizza was great too!!