Papa John's Pizza

I forgot to order lunch for a work event and needed lots of food, fast. The owners did an amazing job getting my BIG order out quickly and it was delicious! They even helped me carry it to my car.

Thank you Johnny and June!

Friendly and fast. The cheesy alfredo pizza was awesome! If they keep this on the menu I will definitely be back for more. I also ordered a small pepperoni and meatball which was good too, but the red sauce could use a little more spice in my opinion. Over all I had a excellent experience here.

I ordered a pizza for delivery to where I'm staying at the past couple times I've gotten Papa John's they've been really good they're actually better than Domino's

Always great and friendly service here. Never had a wrong order, and the orders are always completed timely.

Love this location. We always receive fresh hot food. Customer service is excellent. Even when an error was placed on our end they went above and beyond to get us fresh pizza and wings.

We have ordered from this Papa John's since they opened and probably should have left a review sooner. They usually deliver in about half the estimated time with perfect order accuracy. In general we have liked Papa John's Pizza for a long time but this one is just a smidge better than the rest we have had. Always feel like there is a little bit more of the good toppings and pizza is almost too hot to eat when it arrives.

Ordered this pizza to my hotel room in Stillwater great service from the guy who took the call to the delivery driver. Arrived within a half hour and was piping hot and good quality. Have pretty good specials for pricing as well. This chain has been consistently good here and back in my area out of state. Was glad they had a location here I could order from.

If I could rate them ten stars I would. On time, hot, wonderful ordering experience and they offer gluten free crust. We are a Papa John's family now!

Been waiting YEARS for Papa John’s to open again in Stillwater. I am beyond happy with my experience. EXCELLENT customer service! Stopped for carry out and met the owner herself. I am happy to become a loyal customer of hers.
I am disappointed in the people giving bad reviews based on long wait times or simple mistakes for a newly opened business. This business, its owners, and employees don’t deserve a bad review based on being extra busy during their first days. I urge them to give it another try. I’m sure they’ll be more than satisfied.
For the love of pizza!!

Newly opened restaurant under new ownership so my fiance and I decided to get Papa John's (Her favorite..) There was a slight wait due to a huge demand for their pizza and despite an obviously earnest effort by all employees involved there were still unhappy customers without the self awareness to realize they were trying their best and waiting a few extra minutes for what was a phenomenal pizza (Far better than our normal Domino's order) was not the end of the world.

All in all a great new spot with owners who clearly truly care about their customers and their restaurant. People just need to relax; sometimes good pizza is worth the wait and they're clearly working to be better! We will be ordering from this spot again!

The pizza was perfectly made. The person on the counter, I believe was the owner, was very friendly and welcoming.

I’m in town for a wedding and I searched for pizza delivery and papa johns was first and I was happy!! I called the guy on the phone was so so nice. I was told a hour for delivery and it only took 24 minutes to get!!! The delivery drive was such a gentleman it’s nice to have some be so kinda and nice when delivering to a hotel, then to get the door he had a big smile and so polite!!!

Thank you your store is a ROCKSTAR!

Great location, great pizza. Sometimes they will forward your order to a call center, and inevitably that center needs to forward my call to the restaurant because I am trying to use a coupon (hopefully like anyone else ordering pizza). A minor inconvenience.

Fast and friendly delivery. Good value. The pizza dough could be tastier, but overall it was delicious. Toppings were fresh and flavorful.

The best pizza, great prices, phenomenal service and the friendliest staff and owners. John and June truly run a great family business and do so much for the community as well. 10/10!!

Delivery is so fast. Never waited more than 30 minutes for my order. Food is always fresh and consistent. So glad to have them back in town.

Great pizza and appetizers! Get your food delivered Hot and yummy! Can't beat prices! So glad they are back in town!!

Great food and really nice staff.

Ordered Tonight- Pizza arrived faster than expected, was deelish and the driver was great and very friendly! Thank you sir!

Love their pizza. No prices on menu because you order by size and can get has many toppings as you want at no additional cost.