Di Fara Pizza Tavern

Amazing!!! We are visiting from NY (40 minutes outside Brooklyn), so when we saw this location listed as Brooklyn-style, we knew we need to try it. It surpassed all expectations. The garlic knots are also the best we’ve ever had: quality ingredients and the service is fantastic too. We will definitely be back when we are in the area.

Growing up in NYC, everyone knows the famous Di Fara's Pizza of Brooklyn. Boy was I excited when I learned that Di Fara's was opening a new Di Fara's Pizza location in my new hometown, Cary, NC. Brought a group of former New Yorkers to Di Fara's recently for dinner. Wow!! Off-the-Charts! Had the Pizza Classico with sausage, meatballs, grills onions and peppers. Fresh and delicious. Fun, casual NY-themed ambiance and great vibe. We will be frequent visitors to Di Fara's!! Accolades to all!!

Okayy so we are new to NC. We are New Yorkers and have been looking for New York style thin crust pizza... Di Fara yes yes I would 100% recommend. The pizza was absolutely delicious and the drinks, the service!! I loved everything about it!

We have finally found some decent pizza in the Raleigh area. We are the snobby New Yorkers always trying to find pizza good enough to take the edge off. Also our waitress Lexi was awesome. We will definitely be back.

Amazing place and atmosphere. The pizza tastes incredible, ingredients are fresh and organic. One of the best spots to stop in Cary. Barbara was very helpful and charismatic. We will be back soon with our Italian friends . They have a great area for dogs.

Di Fara pizza has been a fantastic addition to downtown Cary! While I will not claim to be a pizza connoisseur - what I can tell you is that these pizzas (whether you get a whole pie, just a slice, or the amazingly huge calzone) have the freshest ingredients and have never disappointed - and I have eaten there (take out and on location) many times! Their staff is always so nice - whether it’s the guy or gal I’m picking up the pizza from, the bartender, or the server taking care of my dog and I outside. So I must mention how nice and dog friendly they are as well. They have a huge outdoor patio that is heated in the winter and has fans for the summer. And anytime I show up with my dog - day or night they have been so accommodating. Not to mention she lovvvvves their crust too. Such an amazing family run company - be sure to check them out!

Had dinner here yesterday. Their pizza and garlic knots are highlights. Loved their cocktails too.

Di Fara Pizza in Cary is a slice of Brooklyn in North Carolina! As a New Yorker, I was a little skeptical about trying a "Brooklyn-style" pizza joint outside of the city. But man, was I pleasantly surprised!

First things first: the classic pizza is just as good as the one in Brooklyn. The thin crust is crispy, yet chewy, and the sauce is tangy and flavorful. And of course, the cheese is melted to perfection. It's just like how I remember it from back home.

But what really caught my eye (and taste buds) was the Chaos pizza. Now, this is not a classic pizza, but it's worth trying if you're feeling adventurous. It's loaded with toppings like sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and even olives. And somehow, it all works together in perfect harmony. It's like a flavor explosion in your mouth!

Now, I will say that the Cary location is not as chaotic as the one in Brooklyn. There's no shouting or throwing of ingredients here. But honestly, that's okay. The pizza speaks for itself.

Overall, I highly recommend Di Fara Pizza in Cary, especially if you're a New Yorker missing a taste of home. And if you're feeling bold, give the Chaos pizza a try

Went with a friend as we go to a new restaurant at least once a month. I suggested this place as I saw they had highly rated pizza and they did not disappoint! A little pricey but worth it and our server was very friendly and courteous! Kind of a small menu, but no complaints from me as you can always add your own toppings!

We were in the mood for some pizza on a nice cold Friday evening. Wanted to try something outside of downtown Raleigh and were recommended Di Fara.

It is hidden in the outside of downtown Cary next to the railroad tracks. Not a lot of parking, so that was difficult. The place was slammed but we were able to get seats at the bar.

Some very good pizza and beer selection. I would say they need some NA beers, which was disappointing that they don’t have that.

But the Pizza itself was tasty and thin sliced.

I would recommend going here for any occasion. Plenty of seating outside and in.

We've lived in the area for almost a year and are wondering why we never came here before now. Delicious pizza!!! Great atmosphere, friendly service, tasty food and drinks. We stopped in Saturday lunch time and it wasn't crazy busy. Kid friendly, although bring your own food for them if they have a dairy allergy.

Di Fara Pizza Tavern was recommended to me by a friend at work. I had been complaining that it was hard to find Pizza at a quality that I could justify the carb-load for.

I first ordered Di Fara to-go, and I knew from the atmosphere of the shop and the wait that this place was popular. I had a sicilian style pizza and garlic knots. They were phenomenal, and the portions meant that one person was able to get more than a few meals out of it.

I returned for an in-person order most recently, and my waiter was a very kind gentleman. He made sure I was taken care of, and checked in often during the wait. Unfortunately the wait was longer than I could bear while also trying to eat in, so I got it to go. The food was just as great as the previous time, so they get bonus points for consistency and service!

The price can be a bit steep compared to other pizza spots, but the authenticity and quality that you get here is worth extra.

Had two different types of pizza and meatballs. All of it was a 6 out of 5!

The staff and the family that owns and operates the restaurant couldn't be nicer and provide better service. Already planning the next time we will be back. If you are anywhere near downtown Cary highly recommend Di Fara for any occasion!

Absolute pleasure and a hidden gem. We went because of a Instagramer Foodie recommended it. It was worth the road trip. Garlic knots are money. The marinara is gold. That said you better be ready, bring friends, or be ready fot leftovers one the Calzone. Oh and the meatballs are delish too. OMG got me ready to burn gas, the road, and a few dollars to get my taste buds right.

This has to be the best best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. The staff are amazing. The food is divine. The atmosphere is very friendly and casual. Perfect for a hang out with your family while you’re enjoying what downtown Cary has to offer. Great place to meet up with friends to watch sports. Just all around a wonderful spot.

It's the best pizza I've had since I've been in the United States. It is crispy, fresh and delicious 10/10.

First time visiting. A foodie I trust reccommended it. As someone who used to live in NYC, having great pizza right here at Home in NC was a huge treat. Will eat in next time for sure. I'm told the Calzones and Margherita pies are reeeeeeally good as well! Definitely going back. 😊

Loved the pizza here. Good customer service. We ordered a regular pie woth spicy peppers and onions. The pie was 18 inch and we 4 thought we wont be able finish it.
But we did! We loved it so much.

Best pizza I've ever had. The texture of the square pie (deep dish pizza) is perfect. I would also recommend the chaos pizza (we like to add pepperoni to it). Have never had any complaints at Di Fara. The owner is a nice guy who really seems to care about his customers a lot.

Best Pizza in NC hands down. We had reservations in the igloo and had the best time! Pizza was amazing and came out hot! Every piece was delicious from the crust to the sauce to all the fresh toppings! The staff and our waitress were all so friendly! We'll definitely be back to this Gem! The Pizza was a little pricey, but after you take just one bite, the price doesn't matter anymore! You get what you pay for! 💯