Primo Pizza NY Style

Primo Pizza is inexpensive for this area, especially for the amount of food but the quality is the best I’ve had in a long time. The flavors are DELICIOUS. We ordered spaghetti and meatballs, a medium cheese pizza, and a side Ceasar salad for delivery thru Slice App. Everything is exactly what I have been craving. The pizza was perfectly cooked with crisp, yet chewy crust. The perfect amount of cheese - not greasy, creamy, and salty. There’s just enough sauce to taste it, but not be messy. The meatballs are to die for with the perfect amount of spice & the spaghetti noodles were cooked to perfection (wild to imagine for delivery!). The tomato sauce has a lovely flavor & is not acidic. Personally, I could go for more sauce on both the pizza and spaghetti (the flavor is just wonderful) but it is great the way it came! Will definitely order again!!

It is the best pizza me and my family has had ever. The pizza is thin but not crackery or crunchy, it’s perfect and do not get me started on the fries, they are perfectly salted :D the staff is friendly and caring and there is free refills

Our first time at Primo Pizza and the pizza we ordered was really good and cooked to perfection. Next time I'm in the Cary area we will be stopping by.
It would be great if there was a Primo Pizza NY style in the Henderson, NC area. 🥰🍕🍕🥰🍕🍕🥰🍕🍕🥰

Very friendly service the pizza is great as close to NY style for Cary, excellent value as well- we got the Friday special will return for sure

Woah wasn’t expecting this. The pizza was amazing, cheese to bread to sauce ratio was perfected on our pie. They even did a great job with the crust! I got wing with my order as well and these wings were amazing! Tasty, cooked great and sauce on them was just perfect. Last thing was the ranch dipping, I have never had ranch that tasted so good, idk if it’s in house or they buy it else where but I must know where they got their ranch from!

Wonderful pizza! We ordered the 18” vegetarian and added pepperoni. What a treat! Used the app SLICE for delivery and it was prompt, pizza arrived still hot and ready to eat. Ingredients tasted fresh and cooked to perfection, plus you could sense each in an harmonious bite! Balanced sauce, enjoyable spicy taste of the pepperoni (I don’t like spicy food), my 3 year old loved it.

This place is great! The service is always fast and friendly. I use the Slice phone app and it lets you pay/tip in the app so all I do is walk-in and pick up. Just as easy as the large chains, but tastes so much better.

The picture is their Grecian Pie. They have lots of veggie options in their specialty pizzas which is nice.

AWESOME, great, super delicious pizza! I moved an hour+ away last year and missed this pizza (and garlic knots) sooo much had to detour to get a pie. Great food and friendly faces!

Best 🍕 place in Cary NC.

Love this place! Great NY style pizza, excellent selection of toppings and they don't charge a fortune to add extra toppings. They do deliver!

Most authentic NY pizza I've had since moving to NC.

Awesome food at a reasonable price. Very busy with carry out orders. I was traveling for work but would definitely visit again.

Very good NY style pizza! We ordered 2 larges, a veggie and 1/2 plain, 1/2 peperoni, both well done (a little crispy). They both looked picture perfect, were very good when we first had it and then as reheated leftovers. We'll be back!

Oh my gosh I had the best experience here! Their slices are SO FRESH and SO GOOD. I also got the penne alfredo with chicken and it’s some of the best alfredo I ever had. I will definitely be back very soon!

I ordered the Hawaiian pizza and garlic knots and it was DELICIOUS! Pretty good prices too!

We had our doubts, but the pizza is very good. Owner is full of dad jokes, which adds to the informal vibe.

Just ordered pizza from here for my workplace and it was awesome! The gentleman who took the order over the phone was awesome, the price was great, delivered on time, the delivery driver was very nice (possibly the same gentleman who answered the phone), and the quality of the food was perfect. Everyone at my workplace loved it! Will be returning and will be recommending to everyone.

I wanted to order from here a couple of times before I left a review, now that I’ve done that I’ve gotta say that this is one of the best pizza places in Cary. Sauce is good, toppings are fresh, dough is light and flaky. Delivery shows up quickly even when they are busy. Highly recommend.

This place's pizza makes me reminisce about a NY style pizza place I used to frequent back in college. It's got that perfect slice flop, enormous pieces, and (rarest of all pizza qualities) the right amount of sauce. Not too much, not too little.

Though it adds insane amounts of taste and glory, I will admit that the pizza has quite the grease. It's that wonderful grease that shows you the love in the crust and cheese. It's the kind that makes pizza amazing, but it also gives legendary heartburn. I mitigate this by pregaming with a half dose tums, then following the meal with the other half.

Anyway, great shop, support local.

This is my favorite pizza place in the area. The pizza is always so good and so fresh. The owner is one of the nicest people I have ever met. Every time I go in with my coworkers, he sits down to talk to us and you can tell he genuinely cares about his customers.