Johnny's Pizza (Cary)

Very great staff here! They’ll take care of you. The gluten free pizza is good, definitely not just an Udi’s crust they’re passing off as their gluten free option. It’s nice to have a spot to get real pizza!!

Johnny’s Pizza is simply excellent! Their pizzas are always fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. The variety of toppings and crust options cater to every taste. The service is friendly and efficient, making dining there a delightful experience every time. Highly recommend! Justin the manager is great and fun to talk too!

A great environment. The staff interacted with my son and we got to see through the window how they make the pizzas fresh every minute.

They also let me get the lunch special at dinner time. 2 large slices with one topping and a drink for under $7.

Note that the pizza is made fresh. I thought getting two single slices would be <10 minutes but I was wrong. It took around 30 minutes for me to get my food. Deliciousness takes time.

Loved the gluten free pizza and subs. They even have gluten free cheese ravioli! Johnny and his staff are awesome! Definitely recommend.

I stopped in to Johnny's Pizza for lunch and it was delightful! The 10" pepperoni pizza was a perfect lunch with some leftover for a cold pizza snack.

The pizza had a thin crust that was crispy on the edges and easy to fold with just the right amount of cheese and a generous amount of pepperoni.

The staff was friendly and attentive.

If you're in the mood for a delicious lunch or craving some mouthwatering pizza, I highly recommend giving Johnny's Pizza a try. I'll definitely be back soon and can't wait to try something else on the menu.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Johnny's Pizza in Cary, and I have to say, it was a fantastic experience. From the moment I walked in, I was impressed by the warm and inviting atmosphere of the restaurant. The decor was tasteful and modern, with plenty of seating options for both small and large groups.

But the real standout at Johnny's Pizza is the food. I tried several dishes during my visit, and each one was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The pizza was a particular highlight, with a crispy crust and generous toppings. But the appetizers and salads were also impressive, with fresh ingredients and creative flavor combinations.

What really made my visit to Johnny's Pizza special, though, was the level of customer service I received from the staff. Everyone was friendly, knowledgeable, and went out of their way to ensure that my dining experience was enjoyable.

All in all, I highly recommend Johnny's Pizza in Cary to anyone looking for delicious food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere. It's a true gem in the local dining scene, and I look forward to returning soon. I give it five stars

I attended an event at Johnny's Pizza in Cary, NC today. I had not eaten at Johnny's Pizza before, so I was eager to try their food. Johnny's Pizza restaurant has a warm and welcoming vibe that makes you feel like family. The space within the restaurant is utilized well. It is not cramped nor too spaced out. It is just right. The staff greeted me with a smile, was professional, and welcoming.

I like pizza but it is not typically my go to food item because of the overly greasiness. Johnny's pizza was not very greasy at all. I was highly impressed by that. The dough was sufficiently thin, slices were large, and the flavor was fantastic. I don't eat pork or beef, so I had the cheese pizza. The flavor of the cheese pizza tasted original. After taking my first bite, I felt like I literally had a custom made pizza as it was not a familiar cheese pizza flavor/taste as from other pizza restaurants.

I also had the opportunity to try two flavors of their wings. They were both great! One tasted like honey barbecue, and the other more like a garlic Parmesan flavor. What I enjoyed most about these wings is that they were cooked properly. I prefer my wings to be adequately cooked and not soggy inside. These were done perfectly!

Another highlight of today's event, besides the camaraderie, the ambience, and the food, was that I got to meet Johnny, the owner, in person. Johnny was very personable and approachable. He was friendly and down to earth which I appreciated. He has a wonderful personality, and seemed very genuine.

I thoroughly enjoyed my visit at Johnny's Pizza. I will definitely visit again.

I worked a little outside Philadelphia for a few yrs and loved the cheesesteaks. This is where I come when I want to get my fix.

We have been to Johnny’s a few times. The pizzas are fast and huge, and every time I forget how big they are. Pro tip: we enjoy sitting upstairs where it is a little quieter.

Johnny's is easily now my favorite pizza in Raleigh. As a native New Yorker, I know pizza. Johnny's manages to deliver a crispy thin NY crust, light on the oil, a perfect cheese pull, a sauce that lacks high acidity and they are heavy handed on the toppings for the value. The service here is excellent and I will continue to visit for pies and wings. They have a plethora of flavorful wing sauces. Honey mustard being my favorite.

I dined yesterday for the 2nd time with my family. There is plenty of indoor booth seating and outdoor patio tables. We decided on the meat lover's pie and Buffalo wings. The Duke game was on the big screens so we enjoyed that. The young man at the register was very kind and delivered our food to our table rather quickly. Our pie was hot and packed with all the meat you can dream of. Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon... you name it ! The slices at Johnny's are as big as your head. The pizza is totally worth the 20 minute ride to this side of Cary. Add Johnny's to your bucket list while in the area.

Service is above & beyond for a local pizza joint. The vibe is an independent, family-owned place. They use great cheese & marinara. GF pizza is good but a bit pricey. I can recommend this to folks looking for a casual place to eat good pizza!
🍕 🍕
I actually called in a takeout order and something got mixed up, so I waited a while for my food, but then they gave me a lot of extra food to make up for the wait!

What a great place. Shout out to Justin. He made us feel like family. He really elevated our experience. Everything was amazing, the pizza, mozzarella sticks, wings, salad. This is a real Pizzeria. No shortage of items on the menu here, something for even the pickiest eaters to find. Thank you for having us, we will be back!

I’ve lived in Cary for a year and a half and we have pizza night frequently. We’ve tried multiple pizza places that are highly reviewed. All of them came out subpar. I ordered Johnny’s to go and and once I got home and took a bite I said to my girlfriend, “this is what I have been looking for.” I have now found my favorite pizza restaurant around here. I do not say that lightly. I am genuinely impressed.

Went in for lunch on a Sunday and it was basically empty. The pizza was great though, and with the lunch special, it was a great price! For a total of 4 slices (which are very big) and 2 fountain drinks, it was just $15. The lunch special currently costs (as of 7/30/2023) $7.58 after tax for 2 slices with 1 topping each and 1 drink.

What a delicious dining experience!

Everything I tried what absolutely delicious! Let's start with the appetizers. Mac and cheese bites, wings, and jalapeño poppers. The mac and cheese bites? Fried perfectly. Can you go wrong with deep fried mac and cheese? No you can't. Jalapeño poppers were cheesy goodness with a great marinara or ranch dipping sauce. And the wings? Cooked perfectly, good sauce. Great start to the meal.

Then the pizza. We ordered the veggie Supreme and the bacon chicken ranch. I didn't try the veggie because I'm not a veggie fan but the bacon chicken ranch? Beautiful. Fried chicken, bacon bits and ranch dressing on a cheesy pizza. Genius!

Then there was the desserts. Tiramisu was perfect. They also had these little deep fried Nutella rolls (my favorite) that had me drooling!

Everyone was extremely friendly! Service was wonderful! I'll definitely be back!

Placed an order through Slice this evening. Was slightly disappointed when the pizza arrived, as my order was mis-read at the restaurant, prepared and delivered. Called Johnny’s and without question, they offered to replace the entire order. Already having received half the order, I simply requested a new pie. The wonderful folks at Johnny’s were quick to make it right! Thanks again y’all!

Been here multiple times and brought friends here. Best pizza spot in Cary! Their wings are good as well. Reasonably priced, friendly staff, nice atmosphere. They also have a lunch special 2 slices + a drink for $8.

I didn't even know they had options for dietary restrictions! Got a gluten free pizza with a generous voucher last week and was by FAR one of the best pizzas I've ever had!
Not only was the pizza top notch, but the staff was extremely friendly and even remembered me when I came to pick up my order! Thank you Team Johnny's Pizza!! Can't wait to come back!

Great food! The customer service from the staff to Justin was absolutely amazing. We went an hour before they cloesd and they were patience.
The NY style slices are huge! The pizza is not greasy either. I will be back!

I was pleasantly surprised with this pizza joint! I’ve been trying to find a good “go-to” for a Friday night pie and I think Johnnys is now my favorite for the Cary/Apex area! I had the Philly cheesesteak and I am already drooling for my leftovers for lunch!