Tony's Pizza

The waitress was the sweetest young woman I've ever encountered, the food was outrageously delicious and the prices were very reasonable

Best pizza in the area. Taste is delicious. They don’t hesitate in the ingredients. I ordered a Pizza Lover without meatballs and a half pepperoni and half cheese. Amazing. The staff is friendly.

One of the Best places my husband and family have been to to eat. Food is incredible and the Family who owns it are absolutely delightful. I'd eat there everyday if I could. I highly recommend the white pizza, fajitas and pasta dishes. Thankyou for your great service.

The food and the service were excellent. Easy to choose from the menu since you have the option of going with Italian or Mexican. The mussels in the sweet red sauce were the best I've had. Looking forward to trying more items on future visits.

I was just thinking about this place today....I use to go here religiously but that was when I lived closer.....This place is legendaryyyy. I'm talking about the Mexican Menu. That chimichanga, flauta, quesadilla combo meal they have is just too good. Their fajita mix is amazing. To be honest, not a single Mexican restaurant I found till this day offers a combination meal the way Tony's does. For those who are unaware the owners owned a Mexican restaurant down the street from Tony's. They closed it down to open up Tony's and offered the Mexican menu. The portions are big, atmosphere is good, prices are good, if you don't go here to try their Mexican food you will regret it...trust

ITALIAN & MEXICAN FOOD IN ONE PLACE? AT FIRST I WAS A LITTLE NERVOUS TO TRY BUT MY EXPERIENCE TURNED OUT FANTASTIC! I WAS WITH SOME FAMILY. WE ORDERED A BUNCH OF APPETIZERS AND JUST WENT CRAZY. SERVICE WAS ON POINT. OUR SERVER VANESSA WAS PHENOMENAL. I WISH I LIVED CLOSER BECAUSE I WOULD DEFINITELY BE A REGULAR. BYOB!!!

I grew up a few blocks from Tony's Pizza in the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, glad to see it's still there! It was a treat for us kids to walk down the street to pick up 2 large cheese pizzas on Friday nights! :)

My favorite pizza place around! 😋 hands down the most delicious food!

I live in Rockaway & been coming here for years. Tbh I don’t know how the Mexican food is, I have always ordered either a calzone or chicken roll & a Caesar salad. Reason why I come is because they FRESHLY MAKE the calzone or chicken roll. It is going to take 15-20 mins but it is worth it because it is fresh & gigantic! Their Caesar is delicious as well. One thing I like are their portions they are gigantic & the prices are great for the size. The head chef (who now owns it) has been there for 2 decades plus? If I am not mistaken he bought the store from the previous owner & added his own flavor. Awesome place, been coming here for over 10 years.

We came here for a friend's birthday party. The food was delicious 😋 👍 we would love to come back again. The waitress Sandy was fabulous. She served so many people at the same time and was very attentive to our needs. Thank you!

Great Mexican food! Who knew! I ordered the Nacho Supreme and the soft shell chicken tacos. WOW! Great tasting, hot and fresh. First time here and it won’t be my last. On street parking or free municipal parking lot in the back.

Always great food and service. Their Bruschetta pizza is absolutely amazing! Their salads are amazing!! They have this lemon vinaigrette we just absolutely love!!

Is this still owned by the testino family or is it all mexican now?

In my opinion,the best place around for Italian and Mexican food. My granddaughter and I do a date night and our go to is always pizza and hot mussels. Tony's has been a Pompton Lakes fixture every since I've lived her and that's 50 yrs.
The take Bid Bucks and give change back if needed. Would strongly recommend trying it if you haven't already been there.

Love the food at Tony's! Their white pizza slices and their grandma pies are so good! They also make great salads and wraps- you can easily get two meals from their large salads. My co-workers and I order from them atleast once a week.

I just want to say Thank You toTonys. Having just moved here from right outside NYC and working in Manhattan I'm used to some really good pizza. I've gone thru a few places before finding them and they really hit the mark each and every time so far. Nice deep sauce , great cheese and a great crust. I was really worried about finding a good pizzeria out here. So thank God for Tony's lol.

Great pizza. The crust and bottom are cooked to perfection where you get a nice crunch, but not that stale/burnt kind of hard. The mozzarella is delicious and they throw tons of it on even when you just order a plain pie, which for some people could be more of a negative than a positive. Prices are fair and affordable. Highly recommend to any pizza lover!

Just ordered for the first time. Their chicken calamari antipasto special is awesome. So much food for a great price and everything DELICIOUS! 😋

Amazing food! Friendly staff. Easily located building. I would definitely eat here again. They have a smaller seating area in the front for a more casual visit but also have a large dining area in the back for a bigger crowd. Their prices are fair and they are very accommodating. I have eaten here a lot throughout my life and would recommend to anyone.

Love Tony's food been going to Tony's for over 25 year's. Awesome food!