Tony Boys Sandwich House | Livingston

Exactly what I wanted! I was craving an Italian sub with good bread and the right ratio of ingredients. I did customize the #23 with extra lettuce and added bacon. The bread was fresh, with a nice firm outer crust (but not crumbly) and soft inside. Loved the thinly shredded lettuce and red onion. I will definitely be getting sandwiches from this place, again.

Wow! Super professional sandwiches. The nutty pig sandwich with chicken cutlet was so amazing. Fresh crispy tender chicken cutlet , crispy smoky bacon and peanut butter sauce and jelly. Tons of options from sandwiches to salads and wraps. Shakes. Sodas. I wanted to try everything on the menu but I was so full. Had a few tables inside to hangout and some outside seating when it’s nice out. Fast friendly service. This is my new favorite place I will for sure be back to try everything on the menu.

The best lunch & dinner. Anything Hotsy Totsy is amazing and the fried Mozzarella is to die for. For lunch try the Friday special or the #10.

The sandwiches here are so delicious flavorful and filling… fresh ingredients and super fast delivery…. I can’t wait to try a salad next… you can definitely split a sandwich if it’s lunchtime the portions are huge… definitely get your moneys worth

This place is awesomely amazing and delicious beyond expectations. I am not from the area, and someone mentioned that this place is great.... AND THEY WERE RIGHT!!!

During my time in the area I have made it my point to try multiple sandwiches, and none of them ever disappointed.

I even got crazy and tried their chicken sandwich with peanut butter, jelly and bacon. At this point I'm totally convinced that every sandwich on their menu is just as spectacular as the next.

Though.... I do feel as if the Dan Marino is my absolute favorite. The sliced steak is perfect. They don't skimp in any way. The sandwich is stuffed to the gills and is overflowing with all its goodness, as seen in the picture attached with this review. Their homemade coleslaw is spectacular and nothing beats throwing potato chips in an already delicious sandwich. Not to forget to mention the incredible sauce that coats the sandwich. And if your extra gluttonous as I was.... I even added bacon to it... because why f'n not!!!

Big thanks to Tony Boys and their staff who is incredibly nice, friendly, and accommodating!

If this review is your deciding factor for trying this Livingston community staple, just tell them Movie-man Eric sent ya!

Can't wait to try another one of their creations the next time that I am in town!

One of the best places to have chicken cutlets sandwich. All of the sandwiches taste really good, fresh and tasty. Also the service is good and the staff are very nice and fast also the owner is a very nice person. I recommend that place

excellent! excellent. excellent. chicken cutlet sandwich is delicious and has the right amount of chicken, lately some places are so cheap not Tony boys!

tuna was excellent too

a ton of selections for drinks and some really cool chips

didn't try their chocolate chip cookies but they look pretty delicious

can't wait to go back!!

Absolutely great sandwiches and a very friendly service. Came by for the first time yesterday and all three sandwiches, Mr goodbye, Doozer and the Melt all were wonderful, filling and flavorful. Will definitely come back again. LLP

I’ve gotten takeout from here a decent amount. Tonight I had a chicken parm dinner with penne…wow. One of if not the best chicken parm I’ve had in recent memory for takeout and dine in.

We order from here probably every other week, and they have the best food! Not only is the food great, the people who work there are awesome and always friendly. I mistakenly placed an order for pick up and I called hoping they could switch it to delivery, and they did! All around great place for a sandwich (and their spicy slaw is so good, too). 10/10 recommend!

Excellent customer service, fast and clean.

The sub was exceptionally fresh, and delicious. I recommend this place to everyone.

This is our second time ordering from Tony Boys. Delicious both times! The best sloppy joe I’ve ever had. Surprisingly some of the best milkshakes we’ve ever had as well- HIGHLY recommend the Red White and True shake- soooo good!

Best sandwiches in the area! Everything is fresh, tasty and ready quickly. It's great for takeout as you can order online and then grab it off the pickup shelf near the front registers. I love the Stallone, Murph, Parm, and #10 chicken cutlets. Cheesesteaks are perfect too (get the Doozer). After 4pm there's a dinner menu with great pastas.

I’m from Ohio and was in NJ for a work thing. This place served the best sandwich I ever had. The Angry bird- chicken cutlet, pepperoni , honey, pepper spread and some other ingredients I’m desperately trying to figure out so I can make it myself here at home. It was awesome, thank you. I wish there was a place like this in Ohio, why do you tease me Tony

Delicious sandwiches, favorite spot to go if I’m at city.

So me and the fiancé just moved to livingston from queens and have been struggling to find good places here

I’m happy to say we found our sandwich spot at Tony boys. I’ve been there about 4 times and each time I’ve been satisfied with there food. Sandwiches really are delicious and they have good shakes also. Tuna sandwich is probably the best one I’ve ever had.

Always great food and service. The chopped salads are full of fresh ingredients, beef steak sandwiches are amazing, especially the Hangover! And now they have added milkshakes to the menu...hands down best milkshakes around! If you’re looking for an awesome milkshake don’t waste your money at the burger/shake chains or diner, give Tony Boys a try!

Yes, this place is the best. Great spot to hit 1 or 2 times a week if you work nearby. The food was fresh, prepared professionally, service rocked, and place was super clean. Prices are average, but you are getting what you pay for....quality.

Our weekends are never quite complete unless there has been at least one visit to Tony Boy's sandwich shop. Ever since they opened up a few years ago they have been our go to for a great lunch and easy dinner. Personal favorite is the West Coast with Buffalo sauce. So good!

Just inhaled a buffalo-style chicken cutlet sandwich. Amazing. First time here, can't wait to come back!