Church Street Produce

The local fresh figs were the highlight of our first visit to Church Street Produce. These trees seem to grow very happily on Chincoteague island.
We ordered a Tomato Pie to see how it may be different than what we get in Norristown, PA. As you can see in the pictures, the Tomato Pie had a nice flakey crust with a savory filling of delicious fresh tomatoes and a nice blend of Italian spices with a generous layer of cheese then baked. We received a text message that our Tomato Pie was done and we showed up promptly to find the friendly staff pulling our pie from the oven. We took it to our home for the week and enjoyed it right away while it was still hot from the oven. I assumed that my child, who stays well away from stewed tomatoes, to my surprise, really liked CSP's Tomato Pie.
From the establishment name, I expected produce, so was pleasantly surprised to find an eclectic assortment of gift items, including handmade jewelry, while the produce selection was somewhat limited.
Well worth checking out when on the island!

Had the tomato pie. Awesome. A must try, if you can get one! They sell fast. Wonderful people.

Fresh produce at reasonable prices. Also sell great pies! There is a "pickers" section of antiques and collectibles that's always changing.

Church street produce was a delight! My partner and I got the tomato pie and it was like nothing we’ve ever had before; delicious! We ate by the bay and fed some fishies with left over crust of the pie and they seemed to enjoy it as much as we did. Highly recommend. You have to preorder a day or two for the pie but it’s well worth it. Highly recommend! Also very kind and personable service.

super friendly service. fresh produce and the best pies! the chocolate pecan pie is amazing. just the right amount of chocolate and not too sweet.

Nice little place to get some produce. We also ordered a tomato pie, and it was delicious!

Best tomato pies ever. Love all their pies. Great owners a cute store.

Tomato pie! It's a thing, and it's delicious! Paula and her husband bake up some tasty pies!

Very nice visit. Ample vegetables. Very pleasant visit. Did not know about it until it was on the ticket for the weekend

Tomato pies, brownies, fruit pies, and the best, freshest produce on the island.

Great produce + handmade and vintage shop. Very friendly staff!

Fresh vegetables. Really good corn and tomatoes. Exxcellent ... yummy tomato pie!

Wonderful pies. Must order ahead of time.

Run, don't walk to the best pies in the tri-state area.