Pony Tails Taffy

It's like a one stop shop for souvenirs and sweets. They sell fudge, popcorn, candies by the bag, their own taffy, and much more. Further down the restaurant, they sell souvenir stuff like cups, magnets, Keychain, shirts, etc. Parking is light but it's a quick stop before you leave the island.

Very fun place with lots of neat gift ideas. Lots of candy too! Don't forget to let the kids ride the horse inside!

This place is huge and has a wide array of candies, sweets, fudge, chocolates, and just about anything else to satisfy a sweet tooth! There is also a nice gift shoppe area in the store carrying various beach vacation theme gifts. The woman at the counter was one of the nicest people we met on our stay and was very courteous and friendly and gave my daughter a very sweet little gift while we were shopping in the store.

Awesome celebration of candles, ice cream and all kinds of sweets.

Fun giftshop to stop at. Has a lot of candy and souvenirs.

My son’s favorite place on the island! Great variety of candy and other fun souvenirs too. The employees were very helpful and kind.

Amazing peanut butter fudge and taffy. Very clean store shelves were fully stocked very largecollectionofcandy and fudge. The staff was very friendly and fast. I highly recommend shopping here

This is a wonderful store with candy, ice cream, and souvenirs. My 5 year old niece loved the vintage horse ride at the front of the store (and they give you free tokens for it). The staff is so friendly and we loved everything we got.

I like to come here every time we go to Chincoteague as a matter of tradition. Fun souvenirs if you’re into that, pretty broad selection of beach, chincoteague, and vacation themed odds and ends. I mostly come for the taffy which is delicious. Highly recommend!

The kids loved picking out candies they had so much to choose from

Haven't had taffy or fudge is so long and Pony Tails didn't disappoint. This was my 4 year olds first time trying these and she loved them. I used to work here before it was sold to the Dolle Family and the taffy tasted the same but the fudge was definitely a lot better now and a whole lot more flavors. I joined the free loyalty program which is free. Who knows this could be a good place for fudge for Christmas if they are opened.

Loads of different kinds of candy, including taffy in many flavors. They also have lots of souvenirs, sweatshirts and the like. We always stop here when in town

This is a candy store. Lots of cool stuff. Make your own bags is nice.

This place had so much candy and souvenirs hey even had chalk for kids to drawl also my daughter was very pleased with there mechanical horse very good place very pleased

Chocolate candy was fresh and delicious. They opened extra registers for check out when they got busy. Freeze dried candies did not disappoint. Great stop for children of all ages. 😉

Love this place. Many hard to find gifts here.
Good ice cream too.

Great gummy assortment as I love all gummies! Taffy is also good!

Wow! Willy Wonka move over. Something for everyone. From oldies but goodies to current sweets. It is also a delight to the eye as the colorful store brought a smile to my face.

Great Salt water taffy, candy icecream and other good stuff. Love this place.

This place is a child's fantasy. The selection is huge. Ice cream, chocolates, penny type candies galore. Great stuff for bring home gifts and a mechanical pony to ride...