New York pizza, pasta & more

Staff are extremely friendly and they've even memorized my order 😆! You can order custom individual slices which is great. Service is fast, one slice takes about 7 minutes. The pizza is topped with a ton of cheese, so bear that in mind. Definitely recommend.

I ordered a small combo pizza and it was great! Thin crust with the perfect amount of toppings. The customer service is amazing. Everyone is always so nice and welcoming :) love spending my lunch hour here.

Staff is really friendly and courteous.
I definitely recommend it.

Good pizza deals 👍

Luis and his team are amazing! I come in each week to pay for the weekly Thursday pizza my daughter’s school orders. They are so kind and friendly and are always welcoming. The restaurant is very clean with great New York decorations. I would highly recommend coming here! My daughter, her friends, and all the teachers and staff say how delicious the pizza is.

I recently tried a New York pizza, and I must say it exceeded all expectations! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the tomato sauce had a rich, savory flavor. The generous amount of gooey cheese made each bite a delight. A true taste of authenticity, and I can't wait to indulge in this culinary masterpiece again! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I have FOUND my pizza!! From the fresh, delicious crust to the plentiful toppings! I’ve been looking for a good pizza in the Redwood City area and was pointed towards vesta- which is not to my liking at all!! I recommend you try New York pizza, I don’t think you’ll be disappointed!

The pizza is tasty!
I usually order for myself a slice combo.
It comes with a canned soda of your choice, a GIANT SLICE of pizza, and a dipping sauce! You just can't go wrong.

Great pizza! Great people working here! Fantastic service and they're always smiling! Oh and they are not shy when it comes to toppings! 🙃😋

Recommend for sure,the combination pizza was so tasty and crispy,the wings that I ask for lemon pepper and mango habanero so good,definitely going back soon. 👌🏽

Very nice and funny lady taking the orders. Made a special request and made it super easy and didn’t make it seem like a hassle.

Truly great pizza to order or take out. The owner has been here for almost 20 years and takes great pride in his business.

I always have a delicious meal at San Carlos New York Pizza. The service is excellent.

Really does remind me of slices in NYC. Great friendly service. Our "go to" pizza in San Carlos.

We have been going to New York Pizza in San Carlos for 14 years. Great pizza and great people.

We have been costumers since 2017. They don’t change anything it’s been always so delicious 🥰🥰 we LOVE IT. Costumer Service is amazing

This last order was the second time I ordered catering and I couldn't tell you how many time I have ordered from them on a personal level prior.

The food is always great. It doesn't matter what you get - pizza, pasta, salad, desserts, and everything inbetween. It doesn't disappoint.

This review is specifically regarding the catering order... it was ready fast and it was made well. I am pretty sure they threw in a couple extra containers of garlic bread as well because OMG that was so much food! I ordered to provide a big feast for my team before the Christmas holiday and it fed many, for many days.

If I could make one recommendation to anyone reading this: Get the cheese ravioli with the mushroom sauce. You won't regret it.

Best pizza by far. This is a must try spot. Had the classics pepperoni, combination, and an order of classic wings. Everything was excellent. Dine in quick service a little small so great for a quick bite. Anyone who eats here will definitely not be disappointed. Left very happy definitely want to try more on the menu.

Massive calzones!!! Fast service and friendly staff. And seriously, if you get a calzone, prepare yourself for a feast!

I love NY Pizza! A great community pizza place. Their Mexican pizza is life-changing…

Honestly, best pizza I had! Everyone was kind and the atmosphere is great so it deserves a 5 star review. Thank you for service!!