New York Water Bagel Co

The bagel was delicious and they had a whole host of different flavors of cream cheese. The service was really kind and it looks like they have amazing subs and burgers. I could see the steaming of bagels upstairs.

First time customer and ordered on DoorDash. I got an egg, meat, and cheese sandwich with a hash brown and an onion bagel with butter. They followed my instructions for the sandwich to a T and it was perfect. It was not overly greasy which was so great because I’ve had trouble finding a place whose sandwiches aren’t dripping with grease. The bagel was good also. I wish there was a bit more onion on my onion bagel but definitely not a deal breaker. I wish I didn’t live as far as I do because I’d be coming here all the time. Good job guys!

They have a huge selection of bagels. I went and got the French toast bagel with turkey, bacon, egg and cheese and I forgot to take a picture before I took my first bite. It was so good. I recommend everyone go in there and give them a try.

Absolutely one of the best - if not the number one best bagel place in Toms River! Their bagels are always fresh & delicious! The staff is so friendly and they always go above & beyond with every order to make sure it’s exactly how we ordered it, how we like it & there’s not any mix ups or mess ups. Their other breakfast food is also beyond amazing & don’t even get me started on their sandwiches! Delicious, fresh, filling & I can’t say enough about how amazing everything New York Water Bagel Co. has to offer!

This is a spectacular bagel place. Got a bacon egg and cheese in a poppy seed bagel lightly toasted. It’s was perfect. Came out hot and fresh. Delicious melted cheese and bacon. Bagel had good crunch and doughyness. Poppyseeds in perfect amount, not coated too heavy.

Just reading other reviews now about the Taylor ham and flies — I’m surprised because I had no issues at the store today! Came in at 1pm, ordered right away and took a seat, didn’t see a single fly. I am definitely returning.

Great bagels and breakfast sandwiches. They are big so prepare to split them. Always consistent good food here.

Wow! I see I’m late to the fan club. Stopped off this morning. Sesame with Sun Dried Tomato CC. So very good. The best bagel I’ve had here!!
And the bonus was normal regular coffee was very good.
CU Soon

The staff and service staff is awesome. Great food and awesome atmosphere. The breakfast sandwiches are stacked and amazing!!!

We loved them. My 1rst try. Cheddar bacon egg bagel with bacon Cheddar cream cheese.
Also did the French toast...like omg there butter is amazing 👏 😍 😋

Was nice to come back home to the shore, and get some real bagel action!!!!!!!!!!
The staff is always friendly, and food is always quality.

Excellent service & food. Can’t go wrong with some NJ bagels/breakfast sandwiches. This is easily a 5 star place.

Loved the set up and flow of everything. That staff was great and the food is amazing! We will definitely be back.

Amazing bagels! Great chew and crunch on the outside. Great selection. Nothing too crazy, but all the flavors you want. The kids loved the striped bagels. The cream cheese is creamy and yummy. Photo of bagels and donuts from across the street.

One of my new favorite go-to places.
From the great selection of bagels to the even better selection of flavored cream cheese this is definitely a place to try.
Not only can you get your favorite flavor cream cheese on your bagel but they already have it packaged for you to take home if you choose to.
The staff are always so happy and friendly it is a pleasure to come here.

Fresh made sandwiches are quite delicious and many to choose from. Nice array of different house made cream cheese spreads to try. Best bagels around

By far the best bagels I've had in NJ. Very friendly staff. Expect a line as the season hits. Very, very smart to have people make their coffee while they wait to order the food. Worth the wait.

A great establishment, with delicious food, and a kind staff! Lexi, Luis, Sergio and everyone else on staff are the best!!!!

Best place for breakfast in town by far! Ask for Kathy or Sophie! They vibe is remarkable since the switch of owners!

We order breakfast from NYWB every so often and it’s always fantastic! Most recently we got a toasted corn muffin with butter to share with our meals and it was out of this world. Easily the best we have ever had. Can’t wait to order again!

just went to this place for the first time and it was fantastic. the girls that work there are super nice. the place has a really chill Jersey shore vibe. and I got a Central Park sandwich on a multi-grain bagel and it was delicious. definitely my new spot for breakfast and lunch