Nancy's Restaurant

I recommend anyone looking at this to sit inside the restaurant instead of the quick serve, it’s worth it for the amazing service. Everyone was super friendly, the food was amazing and so were the drinks.

My top recommendation is the hummus and the clam chowder as it’s creamy and delicious!

Had a wonderful time catching up with a friend at Nancy's. The streamed lobster meal was delightful and filling with potatoes and corn to accompany it! Most of the guests were families or friends enjoying the food with a view. And you never can go wrong with a dirty banana 🍌 if you like to drink!!

There was a long wait when we got here, so we grabbed the bar tables on the outdoor deck and had the most amazing view of the water and the gingerbread houses. The food was really delicious, and it was beautiful to sit and enjoy a sunny summer day here.

Food was really good we ate at Nancy’s three times during our stay on MV. The sushi was amazing!!!! My NYC sushi place is Kazu Nori. Staff is pleasant overall it’s a winner for lunch or dinner. Outside is a different vibe than indoor dining. Must experience both

Amazing menu, the sushi is great and they have tons of options for it. The service was good too and the view you have when sitting upstairs out the balcony is just breathtaking. A must when visiting Oak Bluffs!

We decided to sit on the deck on first come bar seating facing the Marina. Food was great, drinks were made correctly and the service was impressive. Since we weren't staying in oak bluffs,after great table service conversation, the manager gave us great recommendations for places to enjoy the rest of the night. I checked out other people's plates and wish I hadn't stuffed myself all day. I'd be happy to get back here and try more but instead we drank for a while and enjoyed the view past sunset.

The food was amazing. The drinks were delicious the view was breath taking the waitress Julie was phenomenal.
I plan to make this an annual trip specifically to Eat at Nancy's and visit the inkwell beach.

The Lobster roll was good, but not worth the price for the amount you get its the size of a Hot Dog. I know people love this place but I was shocked that for 1 Lobster roll and $4 French Fries we $41 dollars meaning the roll alone was $30 plus bc I did leave a tip. The staff are super friendly and the vibes here are great, just expect to spend $$. The views are great and the drinks are too. Perfect views of the Harbor!

We ate here with friends (not take out), and had a fantastic meal - the (hot) lobster roll was full to overflowing with lobster, the roll was perfectly toasted and enough butter that I needed extra napkins, so the perfect amount! What was most memorable and important to our party was the food allergy treatment we received. We had a severe nut allergy in our party, and our server took extra precautions with our orders, marked the whole table's order for nut allergy, and they could eat comfortably with no anxiety. We could not be more grateful and will be back, without a doubt!!

NANCY'S IS THE BEST RESTAURANT ON MARTHA'S VINEYARD. DO NOT SKIP THIS PLACE.

The highlights include some of the best seafood New England has to offer as well as the famous dirty banana.

If you don't know what a dirty banana is, run to the ferry and head to Nancy's NOW

Love this place with all my heart

Nancy's restaurant provides a lovely atmosphere just off the harbor. The service is jovial and attentive, maintaining a smile the whole time. The food whilst amazing lacks some distinct flavor. Overall this is an amazing lunch or dinner spot.

Great views with a pleasant and clean atmosphere. We were a party of 5 for dinner and our server Kyle was fun and engaging. The calamari was tender and nicely seasoned. I had the fish tacos. It was light and flakey with nice crunch. It was topped with a slaw with a slight spicy heat. I chose to have a side of slaw but, I tried a few fries...delicious. After having the cocktail, the Dirty Banana I had no room for desert.

Went here after a Martha’s Vineyard tour, before boarding the Island Queen ferry. The food was very fresh! The butterfly shrimp was the best I had on the entire trip! Jumbo, butterflied, and not too heavily battered. Others with me had the platter, and the calamari and all loved it!

Wow! It was super busy but we were seated promptly. The seafood was awesome fresh and plenty of it. The price was right for the quality of the meal. Great service as well. We would definitely be going back.

Atmosphere: It’s right on the pier. Beautiful place. Always packed. Indoor and outdoor seating. I mean it’s Martha’s Vineyard, You know the vibe.

Wait time for seating: 25 mins to an hour (it really depends). Make reservations

Order to table time: 10-15 minutes (not bad at all given how packed it is)

Food: I ordered grilled salmon. It was cooked to perfection. With that many people, I thought the food wasn’t going to be as good but I was surprised.

One of the people in our part ordered their lobster roll and love it.

Overall a great place. If the wait is long no worries. There’s plenty to do.

Also, if you’re getting frustrated due to longer wait. Don’t be in Martha’s Vineyard, you’re killin the vibe bro (get off drinking and take in some Vitamin D from the sun ☀)😎 #chill

Fantastic lobster roll 😋 👌. Tasty fries and good portions. Great location right on the bay.

This place was so good and a great atmosphere! We got the lobster ravioli it was the special that day and it was amazing!!

Such great food. The price was fair- but what do you expect for this area and the AMAZING VIEW!!!!! Our server- Sara was incredible and super attentive and was super friendly and extremely knowledgeable about the menu- Bc my wife asked sooo many questions and she answered all of them w perfection. Serious hats off to her and her professionalism. I had the scallops and added shrimp for $12. And as an app- had a shrimp tempura sushi roll. My wife had some sort of tortilla soup w a lobster on it. We had too much but ate allll of it (I did at least). I had 2 local drafts and my lady had the “show me your spritz.” Leave ample time for parking if you make a reservation. We just sat at the first come/serve overlook seating.

Excellent food and service. Great views of the Marina. Highly recommend the Lobster roll and
"Get it Hot"

I didn't eat at Nancy's, but I'm rating it 5 stars anyway. Why? Once you've had the Dirty Banana (read: frozen chocolate banana drink that will quickly rid you of your inhibitions) you'll understand. The location is also very pretty around sunset. Sounds like a plan coming together to me...