Siracusa's NY Pizzeria

Great little neighborhood pizzeria.
We came in for dinner one night and enjoyed a nice conversation with many of the regulars that are around the bar and the high top tables. There was a steady stream of pick up orders going out the door.
The owner, Dave was always helpful to me when I would order 10 to 12 pies at a time for our business down the street. The pies are still as good as they were then.
We specially like the eggplant pizza. The Caprese salad was remarkable.
Not sure how they get the crust so perfectly thin and yet not soggy to hold up so well.

Dave Portnoy needs to come and do a one pizza review.
Recommended.

Randomly found this spot before I moved, Not to be dramatic but this was probably the best wings and pizza I’ve ever had, I think about it time to time and wish I hadn’t moved so far away. I will definitely make the drive for this place soon!!

We ordered take out. This is some of the best pizza we have ever had. They also do direct delivery through their website. We tried the Margherita and Veggie Pizza and both of them were delicious and fresh.

We came back here for our second time, had an amazing meal!! Regular house salad was big enough for 2 and it was excellent!! Then we had a medium pepperoni, mushroom and black olive pizza that was wonderful!! Jennifer waited on us and she was attentive and incredible!! We will be back for sure!!!

Stopped in while my better half was getting her nails done a few doors down. Low key, chill vibe, and the pizza was FIRE. Absolutely what I needed. Good prices on food and the beer selection had some brews you don't always see (Dale's Pale Ale for instance) on tap. 10/10 will return.

Cozy. Regulars come to watch the game.

The genuine article. Killer pizza.

If I could give this place 10 stars I would. I just happened to see the sign and give this place a try for gluten free pizza, instead I had the wings. And oh my were they on point! They were well seasoned, with the right amount of crunch and moisture. The best lemon pepper wings I've had in years! I was told that they have .50 wings Wednesday. I'll be back for sure. I HIGHLY recommend this place.

Our favorite local pizza place! You see a lot of the same locals over and over. Great NY style pizza. Fantastic crust quality with just the right amount of crunch near the outside and foldable goodness closer to the center!

It's a small restaurant and the service can get a bit slow when they are busy, but they wouldn't be busy if the food wasn't good, so I can live with it.

Got a little hungry out running holiday errands and stopped in for a slice. It was the best slice I've ever had! Perfect amount of everything....not greasy and the crust was crispy perfection! In the immortal words of The Terminator..."I'll be back!!"

Nice small restaurant vibes. Pizza was great and was quite surprised on how good the wings were. Overall great place to grab a slice.

I am visiting the area for a few weeks, but originally grew up in Syracuse, NY and now live in Charleston, SC. I stumbled upon this place through google maps today while searching for a NY pizza spot which are very difficult to come by in the South. The pizza & wings are reminiscent of what I grew up with in NY. The staff was very friendly and the patrons at the bar were fun to talk to while I waited for my order. I will definitely be ordering from here weekly for the remaining time that I am in town! Great atmosphere and great food!
GO ORANGE!!!!🍊🍊🍊

Absolutely loved it. The pizza was great and the wings were crispy just the way I like them. Definitely reminded me of home. Our server was also great. Definitely be back next time we are in town.

I ordered two pizza's on Sunday. I had never ate this pizza before.
I had the meat Pizza's.
It was by far the best pizza I ever had and I've been alot of places.
My husband is from Chicago and he knows good pizza and said it was OUTSTANDING!

The pizza was HUGE. The sauce was super tasty and the meat was fresh and lots of it.
Also, the cheese and bread had flavor, did I say that?

This was AMAZING!
I will tell everyone I talk food with about this place.
As long as I'm in Atlanta this is my go to for Pizza.
I wish I knew about this year's ago, it would have saved us from several disappointments.

Did I mention that my husband and I are foodies?
He is currently a chef and we ran our own catering company
.
The young ladies that greeted me at the door was exceptionally courteous , even holding the door for me when I left.
The owner and management of this place is doing a wonderful job.
It's been a long time since
I experienced this type of satisfaction.
Don't sleep on this place, please!
If there was a way to add another STAR 🌟
This place would definitely get it!

Updated: review. Siracusa (and long ago fortunatos) has been our go to for 15 years in Smyrna. It’s had some ups, some BIG downs, but this picture is with a 1,000 stars. We always get the Margarita with sausage but this past week it was the best one we’ve ever had. Fantastic wings too. Keep up the great work!

Popped in right before closing and had a pie. Their medium pizzas are huge. Could feed a family.... great beer on tap (sweetwater420) great staff and good pie for sure!!

Great service from Jennifer. Food was great. Favorite are the honey siracha wings. Our margherita pizza with prosciutto & mushrooms was delicious. Thank you, Siracusa’s!

The lady named Sydney was nice ,does a good job at her work , she is very nice when you approach her, and she is good with kids.

We stopped in following a three hour ride on the silver commit for some much needed calories. I ate the meat lasagna which was flavorful and a huge portion for the price. The menu also includes a variety of pizzas, paninis, pastas and salads which based on the table were all equally large.

Seating is somewhat limited, but they have a great patio (where we sat) with umbrellas and fans. Inside smells like one of the pizza joints from my childhood with fresh backed dough permeating everything.

Prices were reasonable for the area, quality, and quantity at $10-14ish per plate.

Great pizza. Thin crust. We did the Meat Head (delicious) and the wings (hot) were great. Their hot is not effing around. We chose delivery and ordered straight through the online system. I'm so over Doordash and their fees and slow service

Amazing pizza for sure!! We love coming to this place. Great customer service