Colosseo Pizza

Solid! Epic crust, sauce n cheese. Great spices and flavor. Grandma slice was one of the best I’ve ever had.

The pizza is amazing! Always consistent, thin crust, delicious sauce, high-quality cheese. so much better than most of the other places in Port Jeff Station!

This is my all time favorite pizzeria. The pizza, garlic knots (the best I’ve ever had), the salad are all amazing. I don’t live close and make it a point to always come back here. It’s always consistent and delicious!

This pizza place is amazing. The food is always phenomenal each time I go. This Italian loves it! The best!

The pizza is just deliciously perfect. I had a regular slice, garlic knots & a slice with mushrooms & onions. The dough is perfectly crispy, no grease dripping off your slice, soooo good, the sauce is delicious, I love that it's not acidic. Cooked right. The garlic knots... soooo good. I could just sit and eat the garlic knots. 😋 Colosseo only serves pizza and a few other things. It's not a place to sit and have pasta. The menu is small, but if you just want delicious pizza, you won't be disappointed.

Amazing pizza place where you can buy pizza pies or even slices! Extremely busy throughput the day, which means the pizza is constantly fresh and always coming out of the oven. The pizza and staff are fantastic!

When you're hungry and need a great slice either Sicilian or round this is the place to go. Eat in is comfortable and the slices come out and stay hot. I was impressed.

This place is the best around. Always have fresh slices, great service, clean, friendly..
Most of all the pizza is DE Liscious!! The had Seagram's ginger ale too!
Come by for a slice after your Christmas shopping, they're open till ten pm

Simple, straight forward New York pizza. It’s the best Sicilian slice in the area. The salad is also delicious—ask to add mozzarella!

Hands down best pizza in town!!! Buffalo chicken slice is top notch. Also pinwheels are very delicious and reasonably priced. You have to try the grandma slice also!!!

Driving through the area and it was dinner time . Saw this place and just ran in for two slices. Amazing 🤩!! What a great surprise, caught me off guard in the best way possible. Delicious 😋

Haven't been here in 20 years... Still the best damn pizza in the USA.

Our local pizza place closed a few months ago. We were looking for a place that had a good sauce. We tried the pizza here and it was delicious. We had takeout and the service was efficient and the place was clean. We will try some of thier other dishes next time. We bought a plain pie and garlic knots with sauce. Brought it home and had it plain and jazzed up with pepper flakes and garlic. Delicious both ways. Wheelchair accessible. Large parking lot with ample space.

I have been coming to this place since I was a kid by far one of the best pizzerias around!

One of the best pizza in the world. Amazing cheese taste & excellently done in brick oven. Very good service. Lots of waiting on the weekend. So either go there in the afternoon or go a little early in the evening.

It is always good pizza. Love the pizza and great staff.

It is the best pizza place I've ever been to in my life.
Dough is soft and puffy with a great crunch outside.
Sauce has very rich flavors with low acidity.
My personal favorite topping here is pepperoni, it crisp up like a bowl after they put it in the over. Perfect texture for the ring and juicy in the middle.
You must try their fresh garlic knot as well.

This is my new favorite pizza stop. I highly recommend if you haven’t been to go try it!!!. The should get 10 stars!!!

Delicious pizza! The best I ate in Port Jeff. Fresh food, both salads and pizza slices. Friendly, staff.

Just as good as any place i ever been to in nyc and i work in pizza places also the best pizza place in long island that i had pizza ok for now thanks again