Amici Italian Restaurant

All of our dinners were made perfectly! There were 3 of us, for appetizers we ordered fried mozzarella and had the white chicken chowder(please keep this on the menu). Fried mozzarella never lets us down and the chowder was amazing! Not to forget about the fresh baked bread and garlic herb dipping oil!

Then came the large manicotti, shrimp alfredo, and chicken Parm! Portion size didn’t disappoint and flavors were on point. See pictures below.

We were greeted with smiles and our waitresses Sam was attentive and polite!

It was a wonderful dinner and you will definitely continue to see us. Thank you.

This was our first time. We dined in with friends. Our waiter Brian was amazing. The digital menus are a stroke of genius. The bread and dipping oil, was absolutely delightful. I have tried this at other places, and this was the best so far. I like that you can customize each entree. I had the angel hair pasta, with marinara sauce, and meatballs as big as a tennis ball! This is a must stop in Saint Augustine. We will certainly be going back again.

Amici's Saved the Day!!!!
Our family was having a beach wedding and a reception at the Carriage House. The afternoon of the wedding the family realized the original food supplier for the reception fell through with hours to spare. One call to Amici's and we were able to turn the day around completely. I and WE as as a family can not thank your staff enough for their kindness and generosity with helping us on short notice. The food was incredible. Yes-Incredible. I eat a lot of Italian food all-over the world. This meal made me remember family dining in Italy. So very wonderful. We will definitely be back to visit.
If you are considering dining here- what are you waiting for? Get in the car already!!!!! Again- Thank you-Thank you- Thank you from the bottom of our hearts.

This place is so good . I’ve been a few times now . Sadly no full menu all day. I’ve been for lunch and for dinner now and sadly for dinner they were out of about everything I wanted tonight .Food was still really good. Drinks are also good but food is better though.I suggest going a bit earlier for dinner . My server was really friendly and helpful tho .I will definitely be back . Thank you.

An incredible meal, amazing service from Sandy and beautiful place. Definitely my new favorite restaurant. Thank you Sandy.

Appetizers were great, Calamari and corn ribs! Party of four, had filet mignon, chicken Alfredo, spaghetti & meatballs and Greek salad with blackened chicken. Very, very good meals and would recommend. Our server, Sandy was polite, knowledgeable, attentive and an asset to the Amici organization. Thanks again,
Tim Todaro

My husband and I had our wedding reception in their banquet room and it was absolutely perfect. Food was fantastic with huge portions, the service was excellent, and the manager, James, was great to work with and he made our special day everything we imagined and more. If you are looking for a place to have an intimate wedding, Amici’s is the perfect place, right in St. Augustine Beach.

Update: Another great meal! Antipasto Platter perfect selection and flavors.

We've wanted to eat here for a long time and finally decided to go for our date night dinner. Very happy we did! Food was outstanding and the service was excellent.

Love the tablet menus. Ordering was simple and fun. Decor inside is a tad dated and could use a little refreshing, but overall pleasant enough. Plenty of parking in the shopping center lot outside.

They started us with warm bread and an excellent garlic clove infused olive oil for dipping. Delicious. I had to try the signature Celery Datil soup which was a unique combination of tasty and pleasantly spicy. Not something I would have put together myself but very good.

The Chicken Francese was the perfect balance of citrus and butter. The chicken so tender I could have cut it with my finger (then licked my finger after). I haven't had this dish so good since I left Brooklyn many years ago and I will return just to have it again.

My wife loved her Wahoo Crab Cannelloni.

The desserts sounded amazing as well, and they also offer pizzas I will have to try in the future.

Overall, very happy we finally made it and definitely looking forward to our next meal here.

Pro tip: You can substitute pasta with zucchini noodles for any dish!

Everyone in our party was delighted with their food selections. Shrimp-plump and perfectly done. Meatballs-both large and tasty. Sweet sausage-fennel heaven! And the fettuccine Alfredo-bliss in every bite! For dessert, the limoncello cake was outstanding!
Our meal was enhanced by excellent service: attentive without being disruptive. They have a number of dining rooms, each with its own unique decor. Truly a wonderful experience

I recommend this place if you are visiting St. Augustine, you should stop by this place.
The meat cooked in special way. Must try beef.

Wow...our server was friendly and knowledgeable, the food was DELICIOUS, and plentiful. I definitely recommend visiting, I'll be going back the next time I'm in town. I can't recommend any one thing, because it was all so tasty!

UPDATE: We went back on 1/27/24, and the food was just as tasty. Our server, Richard, was wonderful!

Chose to have date night at Amici's tonight with friends and our meals were absolutely delicious. The attention to detail with every aspect makes it a dining destination. Adriana is hands down the most attentive server we have ever experienced.

Jeremy treated us great! Wonderful service wonderful food

My fiancé and I eat here regularly and it’s amazing. It’s the most authentic Italian food I’ve ever had and they never disappoint!!! I personally recommend the basil cream tortellini with blackened chicken or the chicken Parmesan.

Great food. Our server was very nice and attentive. I had the veal Marsala, it was so tender. The portions were a good size. The kids had lasagna and ravioli and my husband had the chicken francese. They sat us in the bar so it was noisy but a fun atmosphere. Would definitely go back next time we are in St. Augustine.

What an awesome place. At first I was a bit let down because it took a 1/2 hour to get our food, but it was so worth the wait. I have not had such a good meal in a very long time. The chicken franches was phenomenal! The meatball and sausage was delicious and even the pizza was superb. Our waiter Bryan was awesome! We will most definitely be back.

My experience at Amici’s Italian was nothing short of excellent! I arrived at the bar and was greeted by the bartender there named Jeremy. He was extremely friendly and give me a lot of good recommendations. The beer on tap had a good variety with local selections that I love to try when I go out. There are so many good options on the menu I could not figure out which one I should order so I ended up going with the chicken Parmesan after I recommendation from the staff . That proved to be the best choice of my entire day! The marinara was so tasty and clearly homemade. The chicken was nice and crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. I would highly recommend this place, and I will certainly be returning!

Let me tell you, that oil and garlic that comes with the bread I had always been afraid to eat the garlic cloves, but after eating both pieces I am hooked! The flavor that oil had with the bread, I said if this tastes that good I know the food will. You guys didn't disappoint. My wife wanted to eat there for the first time and she loved it, and if mama loves it, I love it. Thanks!

Very ample portions of great authentic Italian food. We took half of it back to the room and had it for brunch the next day. The service was excellent as well. Savory and delicious.

My favorite Italian place in the area. The service is always great. Very friendly and accommodating. The food is so good. The food is cooked to order and absolutely worth the wait. They have the best chicken parm and baked pastas. I love sitting at the bar for a nice drink and dinner. Great place for groups too. They take reservations as well.