Island Treasure Toys

Love this little store! It’s a small space but has a great selection of items. Legos, crafts, outdoor toys - lots to choose from. So grateful to have this store in town and not have to go to the bigger spots to find great birthday gifts.

Wow, so pleased and impressed with this team at the Yarmouth location! Today 12/23 I desperately needed multiple items but had my little ones with me; I called the store in advance and explained the kids were coming with me and when I arrived to purchase my items the team had everything together and wrapped and kept things very discreet from the kiddos! Their friendly service never disappoints but today they really went above and beyond!!

This is such an amazing store - and it has thrived even more with its new management as of November 2019. This store is always super up to date on what is hip (for kids AND adults), the products are awesome, new offerings are always popping up, and the service is exceptional. When COVID hit this spring, this was one of the first companies that got super adaptable and made it possible to still get gifts (delivery/curbside) without missing a beat. The management is also SUPER awesome with feedback, requests or questions - and it is light years better than giving your business to the big online retailers. THIS is the place to give your money and local support!

The best quality neighborhood toy store! The selection of toys is amazing. So many open ended toys, including games, puzzles, arts & crafts, dress up, baby, science, trains, books,outdoor toys and cool tween stuff! Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable!!!

Local business nice place the kids like it
You need mask when you visit

Nice little toy store! Friendly staff and excellent selection. Great way to support local business!

Great shop- super helpful employees.
Local is always the way to go!

Great selection and very nice staff. Thanks!

This is a small store, packed floor to ceiling. The counter helpers are nice. Lots of small toys. I've been there four times since last september.

Don’t waste your time, inventory on the website is completely inaccurate. Ordered 5 different items and they canceled the entire order. What a waste of time!
****Be careful, if you leave a bad review they’ll send you nasty emails attacking you!****