Brother's Pizza

Loved everything we ordered. The pasta was amazing and very affordable. It’s a great community restaurant with authenticity!

Having recently moved to McKinney, we've been on a quest to find the ultimate Italian restaurant.
We've found it! BROTHERS New York Style PIZZA on W. Eldorado (#180) by Market Street! It's a super friendly, family owned restaurant out of NYC. A #BYOB with NO Cork fee. Excellent food, excellent service, excellent prices, AND direct delivery to my house! We enjoyed absolutely everything about the evening.
My search for the ULTIMATE PIZZA place is over, as I've found the total package, Ciao!

I love Albania, and I also love this Pizza! The sauce is very unique (in a good way) I love the crust, and the toppings are the best of the best! Very cheesy, so cheesy in fact that whenever you pull the slices apart the cheese stretches like in those fake ads, except this isn’t fake! Real ingredients! All the employees seem to be working hard, and were very nice! Reasonably priced, and good service, a 5/5 for me! Best pizza place in McKinney TX!

Excellent authentic New York Italian comfort food. We just discovered this place today and will definitely be going back to try some other dishes!

Brother's has delicious food & wonderful service. My husband always devours the spicy chicken arrabiatta, older son really enjoys the chicken piccata, my toddler loves the kids lasagna, and I love the pizza slices & salads! They are BYOB as well for people who like to eat out. We always leave more than satisfied!

Friendly service and clean location. The “Cheese Pizza” is indeed the best pizza in McKinney. We love NY-Style pizza and they make one that is really close especially when they use Grande cheese.
The meatballs are also delicious. We always get them a la Carte it is so versatile you can make meatball sandwich or spaghetti and meatballs at home. It is only $1.25 each.

Great pizza, wings, salads, and a homemade ranch dressing. Been here multiple times and it’s a great little locally owned and operated joint. Highly recommend.

The place was nice. The food was AMAZING!!! We will definitely be back!

We discovered Brothers Pizza a few months back, and they are our new go-to for pizza. I've lived in McKinney my whole life, and this is the best I've had here.

Staff is always friendly and quick to help.

I don't usually write reviews so you know it's good. Best pizza in town. The jalapenos are fresh not pickled. My kid doesn't usually eat pizza but today she ate a ton!

We ordered a delivery. So, I can't comment on the atmosphere. the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. The food arrived in good order. It was very delicious. We will definitely put Brother's on our list of favorite places.

Superb pizza and pasta...but I usually get the pizza. Great tasting and plenty of tasty toppings. Owner recently got a hold of a mobile wood fired pizza oven also and it produces outstanding pizza & crust! Wow was it good! Cannot wait to go back for another pie! They really know what they are doing...

This place did not disappoint. The prices are really good, and the food quality was great. The ingredients they use are fresh and the cooking is done perfectly. The pasta dish I had (penne pesto) was very good, not oily like many pesto can be, but creamy and not over powering. The caprese salad was really good and my son's calzone was really well done and portions are generous but not oversized.
Also tried a spinach pinwheel, which was basically a spinach pizza pastry.
It was really good as well. It is not a chain, and everything is fresh. Loved it, a great find!

Best Pizza around. Always the freshest ingredients ! True NY Pizza however Texas friendly staff and management. This has been my go to since they opened. Their fried calamari is also the best ! They still use a pizza pad to keep your pie off the box and the little plastic center support so you can bring a stack home with no problems. The best !!!!

I absolutely LOVE this place!!! I don't know if the guy I see most of the time back there making the pizza is the owner or manager, but he is super friendly, and so is the woman that is there a lot. Although, I haven't seen her our last couple of visits. They recognize us even if it has been a while since we have been in. Their pizza is great, I have also had some of their pastas too, and never have been disappointed. Their baked Ziti is excellent!! I also have gotten one of their sandwiches, which was great. LOVE their house salad dressing too. We have never been disappointed when we have selected Brother's to eat.

We really enjoyed our meal. The pepperoni pinwheels were amazing and the dinners were very good too. We dined in and the restaurant was super clean and everyone was friendly. Great selection of traditional Italian dishes. Everything was served nicely and super hot too.

This is our favorite pizza in Mckinney. Reminds me of my trips to NY and NJ. Different taste than other pizzas. It’s the real red sauce and quality cheese. The crust is the best. Can’t even consider eating local chain pizzas after eating this pizza. We get take out every Friday night.

We got it to go but while we were there the family was super nice and the pizza turned out awesome! We just moved to McKinney because we were upgrading having lived in Allen for the last few years and it was such a pleasant surprise to find a wonderful pizzeria! Mckinney really has it going on if you're trying to be a social climber! We have two fridges now one in the regular house and one in the servants quarters outside...

Tried something new tonight. So glad we did. We wanted pizza but we didn’t want the usual stuff. We were not disappointed. Ordered a meat lovers and a half cheese half pepperoni. The meat lovers was out of this world! I knew we were in for a treat when I put them in the truck. The smell was heavenly. Will definitely be ordering again. Service was fast. Staff was pleasant, I can’t recommend them highly enough.

The pizza has been good every time I have ordered there. It is excellent New York style. I really don't understand the complaints about the manager on here unless the one I met is a different guy. We called in a pizza with numerous ingredients split in halves on our pizza. When we got there, one of the ingredients was wrong ( it happens ). The manager came over and immediately offered to cook another one for us. I told him just to add the missing ingredient to the half it was missing on - no big deal. He did that, and came over with the pizza and 2 free deserts. He was a real nice guy. The deserts there are VERY good. Mistakes can happen, and he went out of his way to make us happy.