Otterstedt Insurance Agency

I recently switched insurance companies from Allstate to Ottererstedt after being with Allstate for over 20+ years. I worked with Pete Laudenbauk and not only did he save me a lot of money, he was a pleasure to deal with. I highly recommend him!! He is patient, literally available around the clock and explains the policies!

By far the best insurance agency I have ever done business with.Having an intelligent group of employees and a selection in excess of 30 Insurance Underwriters my Broker Peter Laudenbach found me a company with benefits that were never offered to me previously as well as less expensive than I was paying in the past.After an incident with a tractor Trailer my agent has gone as far as to call both the insurance company and towing company and stay on the phone for over an hour and 20 minutes until the towing company picked me and my car up.Anytime I've called Otterstedt's office and my broker was unavailable I was 100% satisfied with the help I received from other representatives no different than if I was their own client.I'll end this now by saying there is not much of a thought process when you have a choice from more than 30 different insurance companies to choose from rather than just one company.Having a highly experienced broker find the best policy for you is the only way to go.

Just a quick note to thank the agency for all the great work they’ve done for me over the years! It has always been a pleasure dealing with the people there. My previous agent Luisa Vera was like talking to a friend, always good advice and helpful! Now my agent Phyllis Cuccinelli has that touch on the phone that makes everything easy and complete. Can’t ask for more! Thanks guys! Look forward to talking in the future.😃

My initial experience with Otterstedt was for the Master Insurance Policy for my 6 unit townhouse association. I wasn't happy with the lack of response and then very vague responses I received from my then agent on any questions related to the policy. After sending a copy of the master policy to Anthony, he came back with multiple questions on specific coverages we had which, as it turned out, we did not even need!! So for years, our association had been wasting money on coverage we didn't even need. Needless to say, I changed my personal polices to Otterstedt as agent as well. Great service, very detailed!! Thank you!!

They were recommended by a friend in New York, I priced 2 other agencies at the same time. Ultimately all 3 agencies came it at similar prices, however I found this agency to be the easiest to work with and the most responsive. So they saved me a little on insurance, but a LOT of my time. Highly recommend.

Good insurance company with fair prices, good hard working, intelligent employees and good hard working, intelligent leadership.

Otterstedt Insurance Agency is the best! Kelly Farrell, our agent, is smart, hard-working and caring. We have never before had an insurance agent (and agency) who was so committed to us.

Carla is the best I have ever worked with. She works tirelessly to make sure her clients" rights and wallets are protected.

Our printing business has used Otterstedt for all our insurance needs for over 25 years. Always responsive and never a problem. I would recommend them to anyone seeking insurance.

I had other insurance companies previously. But Otterstadt buy far is one of the best. The staff are very reliable, professional, and always accessible. I highly recommend this insurance company to my friends and family.

Most ethical Insunce Agency with Specialists dedicated to protect your business, home & autos from all that life may surprise you with. I'm not only an agent with this professional and caring company, I'm a client!

I have worked with a few insurance professionals in the past and by far Carla McSween has been the cream of the crop. Thank you for keeping me informed and by default happy

Great agency. Very helpful and always lightening quick to respond to any question or needs I have on my policies.

We have been working with you for many, many years. We are very happy and secured with your service/advice follow up.

Professional and prompt service by Luisa Vera saved us money on our auto policies.

I have enjoyed my dealings with Otterstedt.
When I needed help they were there for me.
I appreciate all the staff at Otterstedt do.

I would definitely recommend them I have my auto,home and business insurance through them Jeff Stapleton is awesome to deal with.

I would like to commend the efforts of Carla McSween. I receive immediate and excellent information whenever needed. She is EXCELLENT.

It has always been a pleasure dealing with everyone at Otterstedt. They have always been very helpful, informative and professional.

Carla handled my request for a new insurance policy swiftly and professionally