Crosby's - Perry Highway

Found their menu on line and tried them. Put my order in on line. They texted me when it was ready for pick up. It's was made just as I had ordered it. Perfect ! It tasted better than it looked. Thank you. I will now be ordering from you. No longer going to sub way, Sheetz or country fair. Wish I would have stopped at your store sooner.

The food is AMAZING 😋 and the guys are very easy on the eyes 👀. Seriously the best in that area
They have great prices too compared to the place across the street. If I had to say anything as a criticism.... they really need to clean the bathroom sorry guys but it's not good.

First time ordering food at this location very impressed.. Ordered 6 whole subs for your customer appreciation sale by far the best experience I've had ALL 6 were correct and tasted amazing the store was clean and the staff was friendly.. Next time I'm in the area I will be sure to stop..

Best Pizza Ever!! The employees are friendly and personable, and the store is well stocked with the usual convenience store items. Always a great experience to come here!

ordered 3 subs from your store today they were fantastic love the Italian rolls very fresh and tasty will definitely order again thank you for the very curteous person who waited on us Thank You Matt good job !!!!

Good food and good gas, clean restrooms and clean pumps, cheap eats and fresh subs. Pizza is really good and the specials are of great value. Would recommend to friends and family

The place has good food and good customer service. The location also has a Tim Horton's inside there as well.

Eat here all the time hard to believe a gas station can make such awesome pizza

Bathroom was clean, gas prices competitive and loved the Tim Hortons! The doughnuts were great, coffee was hot and the prices were low!

Tasty pizza, friendly employees, clean bathrooms

Pizza is great, but another order for a sandwich took nearly 20 minutes. Also the insane price of $1.50 to use the air machine had a wow factor i wasn't looking for.

Guy working the register has a poor attitude, I stated what I wanted twice and when he didn't give it to me I asked for a third time and he said I should have asked and I said I did twice!

Crosby's itself is a decent store.
On the other hand. The Tim Hortons is a laughing joke. Incompetent staff!!
These people couldn't fight their way out of a wet paper bag with the bag being open.
To sit there at the drive thru or even inside
to have to wait almost 20 minutes for 2 coffee's is absolutely absurd.
Then these baffoons can screw up 2 coffee's. I've watched this crew screw up so many orders that I'll drive 50 miles into NY to get a coffee

Pizza will make you explode during the night even though it's good at first. Only eat it if you're willing to chug down Pepto-Bismol beforehand.

No hold-open latch. I'll go elsewhere.

Filthy inside bathroom walls covered in yellow film. Stuff on floor, employees hiding. My last review was deleted. Sheetzs down the road or Pilot across the street are heads above Crosbys. The pizza is good but my last visit was my last.