Amazing Olive

We LOVE amazing olive. The first visit, I went with my mom and sister who are from out of town. We were greeted with a smile and told We could try as many as we would like. We tried a few and purchased a few as gifts. I asked about their custom labels knowing my boyfriend had a birthday coming up in a week. They said, no problem! It came out great!

My second trip was to pick it up and purchase a gift certificate, knowing he would want to vote visit and try them himself!

Today we made that trip, again for a 3rd time being greeted with a smile. We tried so many, spent a while and then purchased some fig balsamic, jalapeño white balsamic and a Tuscan olive oil. Plus a few tasting dishes.

We are so excited to try each and every one of them and when we finish I'm sure we will be back for more.

Great for gifts, wedding/baby showers, hosting, so many reasons to come visit.

Such a neat, beautiful little store placed on the Main Road. The store owner Candy was very friendly, polite and helpful.
A must visit place. I’ve never seen such a large variety of olive oils in all kinds of mixes and variations 😍

Great little shop. Everyone was extremely helpful. Able to taste before you buy. Assorted flavored oils and vinegars available in different sizes. Also have the option to purchase bottle for party favors with customized pictures and lettering.

Stopped by this quaint little store we chanced upon. We were greeted warmly and informed that we could sample any if the oils and vinegars. Tried several varieties and was informed of the nuances and make up of each we tried. Very friendly staff person made helpful suggestions from her experience inline with our tastes. Thanked for our business as we bought several selections. If one likes infused olive oil and vinegar, this would be a worty stop and shop.

The Amazing Olive really is amazing! The owner, Candy, was knowledgeable, attentive, and incredibly helpful when it came to creating custom gifts for me. She made three impeccable baskets and included alcohol I added in as an addition. Everything came out lovely. Can’t recommend this place enough!

Me and the family visited here on Friday before we went to Joey's Z next door. The amount different type olive oil is amazing! Huge selection, and the place feels very cozy. I got the Scorpion Hot sauce from here, it's very hot and very tasteful. I keep using it a lot! Thinking about getting back on the Ferry and get more of that haha!

The Amazing Olive is a very well organized, beautiful and amazing shop! They have so many options of olive oils, vinegars, soaps, and rubs. I wish I can buy them all! They also ship out orders which is very beneficial. The staff that works there knows a lot about the history of the oils, and vinegars. They are very friendly and sweet once you enter the door. I would recommend going there when you are at Port Jefferson!

Best olive oil shop around. Don't confuse Amazing Olive with the recent chain store that opened nearby. Amazing Olive is by far the better quality products and better prices. Staff is super friendly and very knowledgeable, I have to control myself when going in here otherwise I'd spend all my money.

I visit here every few months to stock up on my olive oils and balsamic bottles... great for anyone who loves to cook. Perfect place to buy holiday and birthday gifts.

Love this store! The owners are extremely nice and very knowledgeable. They must have over 60 different oils and vinegars. I brought Chocolate Balsamic vinegar and Jalapeno garlic olive oil.

Such a great variety of products! The owners are nice and accommodating. The basil and shallot Olive Oils are amazing as well as the soap and body products.

Just got home with my truffle vinegar and I'm in love. Great Friendly staff. So happy I love close and can go here. Highly recommend to anyone. Great prices too.

Staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Great products as well. They even have a loyalty program which helps bc it is a bit pricey.

Staff is incredibly friendly, and they always have an amazing selection of oils and vinegars. They’re our go-to spot!

Great flavored olive oils and balsamic vinegars. The only down side is the price, but it is still worth the money.

This place has great prices, a pretty good selection of food for a smaller store.

Getting this delivered is so awesome!

The Employee Hannah was extremely Friendly and helpful

Friendly atmosphere staff very helpful

Amazing atmosphere and people. Selection is endless