Cooperage Inn

Great food. Quality all around. Service is quite good. Personable staff. Beautiful inside dining area. Homemade pot pies are the best I've had anywhere.

Older/country style type of atmosphere inside. Outdoor space is great, but it was hot. Food was amazing. We had the burger and chicken sandwich. Fries were cooked to perfection. Mixed drinks were delicious. Our waitress Isabella had the best personality. It was our first time here and we will definitely be back!

Had such a great lunch here. We needed to be in and out in 45 minutes and the staff was so kind and accommodating. We ordered the short rib pie, chicken pie, and the onion and potato crusted flounder. The flounder was some of the best I’ve ever had!

What a nice venue for dinner or that special occasion. I have eaten at this restaurant several time in the past 6 months and they never disappoint. Just had a birthday dinner to for my wife and everything was spectacular! The service Alexis took excellent care of a party of 12. I don’t think anyone present was in anyway disappointed with the service of quality of what they ordered.

The quaintness and country feel are a big plus.

I have also gone there for the pot pies to go and they are another thing worth considering.

I will definitely be heading back sooner than later for another great night out. 👍👍👍👍👍

We drove to NoFo pies to pick up a few of their pies and decided to have lunch at the Cooperage Inn. We were delightfully surprised at how beautiful it was. We sat outside and got to enjoy the wonderful weather and the scenery. They have a gorgeous koi pond adjacent to their outdoor seating. The food was amazing, and our server Alexis was awesome.

Cooperage Inn is a family favorite. We have been here 3 times this summer and it’s love by everyone who has been there with us. The food is delicious and service is fast & friendly. Their menu offers something for everyone and the pot pies are divine. Not only are the pot pies delicious but look beautiful. The crust of the pie is puffy and airy. Super yummy! The full rack of ribs can feed two people and falls off the bone. The seafood medley is a plate full seafood and worth the price. All the plates you get are filled up and worth what you pay. I definitely recommend giving them a try and you will want to take pot pies home with you. Make sure you tell your waitress if you plan to stop by the window to take pies home because if you dine in you will get 10% off anything you buy at the window to take home. Definitely get the chicken and short rib pies! We will be back again very soon. We love you Cooperage Inn!

Fantastic food! Quality is always consistent. Service is top notch. Steaks are so tender. Fresh seafood. They have the best baked clams! We've brought many of our friends here and they loved it.

Place is off the hook,food was amazing, service was amazing and the NoFo Pot Pies Togo were a bonus too.

THE spot for pot pies. The waitress was super friendly, and the food was amazing. Potions were appropriately sized, and food was very high quality. Did not have to wait for a table Thursday night during the holidays, which was a huge plus.

The bread basket was super nice. There are lots of different flavors and textures. The homemade hummus it came with was such a nice pairing, and the pumpkin break and zucchini bread were a stand-out creative addition.

There is a pies to go window with heat and eat pies for cheaper than in store. You get a 10% off coupon on ur check, but only for the day you eat there (that's how they get ya) . It worked the key lime pie and coconut cream pie were delicious at home too.

Cooperage Inn has become our go to restaurant whenever we want to have a great, relaxing, hearty meal after exploring the vineyards and highlights of eastern Long Island (NY).
They're famous for their yummy pot pies and there's great menus with so many choices for even the pickiest of eaters.
Last night we shared Broiled Seafood Medley,
Lobster Clam Bake,
Roast, Semi-Boneless Half-Duck, and Braised Short-Rib Pot Pie - every flavorful bite was delicious!
They also have a great drink menu with white wine, red wine and cocktails as well.
Great classic dishes done with perfection and generous portions.

The Cooperage Inn hosted our rehearsal dinner and it was fantastic! The staff was incredibly accommodating, ensuring our large party felt welcomed and attended to. The food was delicious, meeting the varied tastes of our guests. The overall experience was delightful, thanks to the great service and a welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend this restaurant for a stress-free and enjoyable rehearsal dinner!

The food was fantastic and I loved the Christmas decor 🎄

The food was amazing as usual but the best surprise was our funny fantastic waitress Bella.On a very busy Sunday she greeted us immediately and made us feel like we were the most important table in the restaurant.
We will definitely check her schedule and go back on a day she is working.

We had their famous chicken pot pie, it was delicious with a beautiful flaky crust and savory creamy white chicken filling. Refreshing watermelon 🍉 summer salad, penne a la vodka and a luscious peach upside down cake with ice cream and a raspberry drizzle. We were seated outside this time and had a wonderful view of the garden and Koi pond. Our server was really attentive and all the staff was friendly and helpful. Pretty decor country chic inside that they change each season. We got a watermelon martini and Caribbean Cosmo..they do not skimp on the drinks both were delicious.
Clean bathrooms, wheelchair accessible ample parking during regular times. During the fall festival it gets crowded but there is parking across the street.

We had the most delicious dinner this evening!! The Goat Cheese Flatbread - absolutely the best we have ever tasted!! The eggplant fries were good
Our dinner entrees were fabulous!! Great service along w an apple cider donut Sunday to end a perfect evening - thank you!! We look forward to returning soon!!!

Our time here at Cooperage Inn was excellent. We went on New Years Day with reservations as we were not sure how busy it would be. We recommend making reservations as they became busy as time went on. Our server was JoAnne and she was awesome. Very friendly and professional. She was a delight. We ordered the garden salad and French onion soup to start and both were fresh and delicious. It was a no brainer for us both to order the classic chicken pot pie as this is a staple here. The best restaurant pot pie by far. Unbelievably good !! A real nice wine list and craft beer selection. They also offer a 10% discount for any pot pie take away with your table receipt. We will be back !!!

My wife had wanted to come here for forever. So for her 60th birthday we took her here. I am so glad. This place is amazing! When we went in we were greeted friendly like one of the family. Our waitress was fantastic and very helpful. I got their specialty. Their braised short rib pot pie. Oh My Goodness! I know why its their specialty. So delicious. My wife got the duck which she loved. My son got the seafood medley which he very much enjoyed. We also got the tuna tower and baked clams for appetizers. The tuna was great and we couldnt6get over the flavor of the clams. I had a great local beer and a superb cab that our waitress reccomended. We ended with coffee and their amazing! amazing! Strawberry Shortcake which we use to sing happy birthday. I highly reccomend the Cooperage Inn and you just might catch me there because I'm going back. They sell their pies to go so you can bring some home. I have to check out their chicken pot pie and my wife wants to try the lobster pie. I know!!!!

If you want some hearty comfort food this is the place for you. We went during LI Restaurant Week and got a fantastic 3 course meal for $35 each. For starters I got a crab cake with a mango salsa, my wife got cauliflower soup with bacon and monterey jack cheese. For our entrees I had the braised short ribs pot pie and my wife had the chicken pot pie. Dessert was apple cider bread pudding and pumpkin mousse pie. Everything was delicious, the service was extremely friendly and prompt, the atmosphere was comfortable and pleasant, and everything was very clean. Would highly recommend you try this place out.

Thank you for the big part of celebration of my husband's life about 2 weeks ago. The food was absolutely delicious with perfect wine and beer menu and all the staff was amazing. Especially the wait staff was superb.

I had a great time at the restaurant. We were in a quaint smaller dining room with beautiful flowered wall paper and from the minute we sat down service was impeccable. From helpers to waiters everyone is polite, helpful and courteous. Food portions were generous, actually rib eye steak was too big for the two of us and we took it home to our son.