Black Sheep Gifts

Late post but I’m super grateful for the team at Black Sheep! I took my daughter and niece to their kids shopping event and the girls wouldn’t stop talking about it. They felt so grown up and wanted to go back. Thinking we found a new annual tradition!

Absolutely love this store! The most unique selection. No matter how hard someone is to buy for you will find the perfect gift here! The owner Lisa is awesome! Irvington is lucky to have such a neat store!!

For the entire time I have lived in Irvington, Black Sheep has been an amazing ally to the non-profit organizations that ask for their support.

I mean, come on… not only do the sponsor monetarily, but they think of their own ways to raise money for local organizations as well.

Personally, I can only think of 2 places where I can panic contact them after hours for a last minute gift and they are more than happy to help.

Thank you for always being so supportive of The Benton House.

We can’t count the number of times and ways you’ve supported us.

We love you and all you do, often silently, to support the neighborhood!

Black Sheep has been my go-to for YEARS for gifts, cards, etc. The owner is always so helpful with assistance for what I am seeking.

This place has all kinds of great gifts for every occasion. The owner is always supportive of local charities.

Whenever I need something special for my wife or family and friends- this is my go-to gift shop!! Lisa, Scott and entire staff always pick out the perfect items!
Plus they sale this amazing pancake & waffle mix!

Black Sheep Gift Shop is a jewel in Irvington. Best place to shop!

I absolutely love going to Black Sheep. The owners really take the time to choose unique and fun products for their shop that you can't find anywhere else in the State. If I'm looking for a cute gift for my nieces, this is my go to spot.

I was very impressed by the selection of niche gifts they had in store. What a great gift shop right in the heart of Irvington! The staff was very helpful and welcoming.

This is a great shop if you're looking for a unique gift!

An awesome place in Irvington to shop for gifts. Lisa and Scott always surprises us with new inventory in their store. Definitely try the Stonewall collection! And the fahlo bracelets are super adorable for yourself or the kids- a great gift and even cooler to track an animal!

Great shop! Lots of options, customer service was great, and I LOVE the earrings I purchased! (Little guillotines from Green Tree Jewelry). They even recommended another shop in the area 😀 and they gave me a reusable back and pouch for Earth Day!

I love the Stonewall mixes and food. The products are always changing, and you never know what you'll find. Great selection of puzzles, toys, and games.

I LOVE BLACK SHEEP GIFTS! Seriously, it is such a fun place to shop, with so many unique gits...many for myself! It is an affordable one stop shop for every occasion (and they put it in gift bags too) and for holidays. From cards, jewelry, socks, toys, games, aprons, pet gifts, Eastside pride gifts, Purses, wind chimes, hats, gloves, scarfs, soaps, kitchenware, baby gifts-go buy a warmie right now, candy, yummy cocktail mixers and party foods-pickled asparagus anyone? Oh and the Halloween Merch? So order a gift basket-the owner Lisa is like a fairy God Mother with those things they are jam packed. Dont miss this shop, where shopping is fun!

I fell in love with this shop! I cannot wait to go back. Such cute, unique gifts!

Great selection of items for everyone. Helpful and cheerful staff.

This is such a fun and wonderful store! The owners work the counter and they have such a fun, eclectic mix of items. Perfect for gifts or for yourself! Would recommend 100 times over!

Totally impressed by the variety of super cool stuff in this store. So many fun gifts for anyone. Had the opportunity to have a small conversation with the owner while my wife and I did some holiday shopping here and she was very cool and pleasant to speak with. What a great place little "gem". Nestled in the heart of Historic Irvington just a few shops down from Jockamos. Highly recommend stopping by and checking the place out.

I love love love Black Sheep!!! Gifts for everyone and every reason!!!