Cold Spring Fish

I can’t believe I found this place!! No where to buy fish in Newburgh and at last I found Cold Spring Fish. I was so impressed by the quality of their selections I couldn’t decide what to bring home so I decided to buy both wild halibut and sockeye. Both were immaculately fresh! I plan to be a regular customer! Well done Cold Spring Fish. And shout out to Jane who works there, she was lovely!

Cold Spring Fish has become our go to fish store. After the closing of Sally’s, in Newburgh, New York, we thought we would not have any more options for fresh fish, but Cold Spring Fish saved the day!

Now we get all our fish here, always fresh, always tasty.

You can order in advance online, which is great, and if your order is over a specific amount, you can even get a delivery!

This business opened during the pandemic and made deliveries during that time. The fact that they survived that start is a testimony of how fantastic they are. Then their store opened. They have fresh fish, seafood, poke bowls, soups, other prepared meals and sides, and daily/weekly specials (e.g. lobster rolls, lobster mac & cheese, etc.). My favorite special is the sea scallops wrapped in salmon over mashed potatoes...incredible. They also have a wonderful assortment of food and non-food items for the kitchen-cupboard or as gifts (e.g., olive oils, chocolates, etc.)...it's way more than a fish store. And it's immaculate. Sarah (the manager) and Alejandra (the owner) are beyond helpful and welcoming, as is the rest of the staff. And don't leave without a bag of these potato chips from Spain...sophisticated, elegant, and addictive (in a good way). I shop there almost every week now...HIGHLY recommend.

Outstanding selection. Ordered a fish and was fresh for pickup 10am the next morning. Clear eyes, bright red gills, very fresh. They bad they could get anything in for me fresh.

Best new store in the Hudson Valley! Their fish is super fresh, super tasty. I’m addicted to making poke bowls since I’ve had their sushi-grade tuna. Unbelievably good! I also appreciate that I can preorder bread from Balthazar, which is a treat!

Such a fantastic fish store, lots of specialty grocery items. I’ve gotten sushi grade fish here several times. Lovely staff! What a great addition to our area!

This is the best fish store in town! You can get all types of great seafood from there and the owners are very nice and helpful!

This is a fantastic place to purchase all sorts of seafood.

We love their salmon cakes, pieces of salmon, and scallops, Thai soup, and more. The scallops are "dry" and by far the best I've ever purchased. It's a nice store and they're very knowledgeable. I love that all the seafood is certified sustainable.

We here in Cold Spring are very lucky to have Cold Spring Fish! They offer the freshest, high quality fish with friendly and really helpful service. When I asked for help in how to prepare a whole fish, they provided all the support I needed….and I got the credit for the fabulous meal we had that night! They often have items not found anywhere else like cherrystone clams, which my husband adores.

Great fresh fish at reasonable prices with friendly customer service! They also have terrific sushi, specials, ingredients for international dishes, and creative gifts. Come to Cold Spring Fish and get inspired!

Absolutely the best quality fish/seafood. The store is beautiful and inviting, the service is great, the delivery option is very helpful. We've been ordering for over two years and will continue to do so!

I love this place!!!

We’re in Newburgh and love having orders delivered right to our door! The selection and quality is so much better than what’s offered at any of our local supermarkets. So happy to have Cold Spring Fish as an option!

The freshest fish I’ve purchased in a store. On Christmas Eve we made a large purchase for the feast of seven fishes and the staff were so helpful. Again when I recently purchased caviar and crackers and needed help choosing they couldn’t be more helpful.

Cold Spring is so fortunate to have this shop. The fresh fish choices are outstanding and the shop is full of delectable items. Sarah and the staff are the best in town !! And now, ice cream!

Excellent fish and seafood, always fresh. The staff is knowledgeable and helpful, friendly too. Everything is enticingly displayed.

Cold Spring fish has the highest quality fresh fish and an amazing selection of items. In addition to the fresh fish, they have great poke bowls and soups. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly and they will get anything for you if it’s not already in the store. A wonderful addition to the area!

Great people, always friendly. The fish quality is amazing!!

Seafood Always fresh.
Staff extremely friendly.
Have been a customer since before the store opened.

The fish is very fresh and the selection excellent
I am glad you are in my neighborhood

Cold Spring Fish is possibly the best locally owned small business in the Lower Hudson Valley and Northern Westcheste! The owners are incredibly knowledgeable about their products and sources and did a wonderful job with the store design. In a world flooded with cheap fake food and non stop Amazon deliveries it's such an up lifting experience to even stop by the store and say hello. Born out of a true need to help the community during covid the story behind the business is also a must know....trust me, make this your go to store for all things seafood... You will never be able to shop anywhere else!!