Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

The food here is always so fresh and cooked specifically for you like how can it get better

Salvatores in Walworth NY is now on track. The food has greatly improved and the new staff is doing well. Frank the owner including the Macedon shop needs to be commended for his hard work. Place an order and you will taste the difference . Highly recommended. We oder at least once each week.

First off… Awesome staff! Recco, and the crew rock! I honestly thought Salvatore’s was just pizza, subs…. You know the usual “pizzeria” kind of place! I was wrong! I ordered the grilled chicken parm! It was huge! Seriously!! Amazing portions! Delicious flavor! I have enough for two meals! The garlic bread was a whole loaf! Bread is life and that made my night! They really do deliver everything but babies! Support local!

Warm welcome feeling when you walk in. The service is great and food is very good.

Large slices at a reasonable price. There are daily specials, which I like.

I don't eat subs very often anymore due to some dietary changes, however I had the occasion to order some the other day from Salvatore's in Walworth. What a great sandwich! Perfect sub rolls are the foundation of this culinary delight. Excellent crust and chewy inside provide the perfect juxtaposition to the copious tender and flavorful meats and cheeses as well as all fresh vegie ingredients! Simply Perfect!

This is my favorite place to buy pizza. They use quality ingredients and it always tastes good. Now lets talk about their cauliflower crust pizza. I was excited when I heard about it since I am on a diet. I was so excited because it's made by Salvatore's! It has to be good right? WRONG!!!! The crust is paper thin, dry and even tough! I ate 3 pieces and was still hungry! So the 5 stars is for their other food,. The cauliflower crust pizza I give a 3 stars and those stars are for the toppings and their amazing sauce. So if your hungry or looking for a good cauliflower crust I would recommend you keep looking and not waste your money on this one. There are recipes on line and they are actually easy to make and tastes amazing.

I have only ordered pizzas from Salvatore's in Walworth (always pickup) quite a bit and I've never had a bad one yet thanks Frank !!!! I like this one of all the Salvatore's near me the best the next one would be the one on Bay Road
Oh and by the way Frank. Adam makes a great pizza like yourself........great pizza the extra sauce is killer!!!!

I'm not from around this area but my girlfriend lives down the road I went in one day for a quick slice very friendly staff. With that said I fell in love with their pizza like I said the employees very friendly yup I'm the guy with the tattoos on my face best pizza ever.

I always go here. I'm never disappointed and the food and staff are both great. I live close by so ordering regularly is a no brainer for my family and I.

Very good pizza. A little spicy (hot) for my taste, but excellent none the less. Small dining area but appealing decor, staff were polite and efficient. Will revisit!

PIZZA like it should be. Hot, crunchy bready crust. Mmmmmmmm....

They have a $12.95 large pizza special on Mondays. We try to take advantage of this to feed the family on the cheap. We love their pizza!

Delicious pizza!!! If you haven’t been to Salvatore’s Walworth, with new owner Frank Freida give it a try. Friendly service, nice dine in area, big selection and great food.

Always friendly service. Clean restaurant. Employees are fun! They're professional, have excellent sense of urgency, and teamwork.

I was very impressed with how friendly the staff was and that the owner was on site. Very clean, excellent customer service, amazing pizza. Would highly recommend.

Pizza and wings great, staff super friendly! Medium pizza, 10 wings $30. Reasonable compared to competitor in our little four Conner town

Have to say I’m amazed at this place !!
Not only is the food great ; but also we left
Our $ behind and the young man turned it in !! Thank you so much !!! What a honest young man !!!!

Always great food and service. Pick up or dilivey, always worth the price. Called this time around and got great service and deal. Came to pick it up and was greated with a smile and a hello.

Great customer service and the best subs in town. Pizza is always delicious