Hot Stuff

Love the variety of pepper sauces, dat'l too, seasoned olive oils and they have key lime jelly beans! Love this place!

Great store with a huge range of hot sauces, marinades and honeys. We were served by Bryce who was super friendly and knowledgable, helping us understand the different kinds of peppers and heat and giving us taste samples to find the perfect sauce. Came away with 4 different bottles of Datil pepper sauce and two slices of the best Key Lime Pie I’ve ever eaten!

Amazing friendly staff!! Delicious sauces🔥 My only problem is I didn’t buy a few other sauces we sampled!

This place was fantastic. I am new at eating peppers and read about the Datil pepper. This store is so great. So many to choose from. Best place to buy from. Super friendly and the samples were great. I had the best experience due to the owner's knowledge and enthusiasm. What a neat place. I bought just a few to enjoy.

Love this place. Tried a few hot sauces and they were all great. Staff really knows their stuff and has a passion for the heat. They also share the store with limes and they have great wine ! Stop in try some and you will bring something home with you!

Cool little shop the guy at the counter had vast knowledge of the sauces.

Absolutely fantastic. Just tried about 10 different hot sauces and bought 3. Loved the heat and the service. 10/10.

Stopped here to get some datil pepper sauce. The employees were friendly & knowledgeable. They even had several kinds of sauce to sample.

Chris, the owner, is an absolute legend. He is extremely knowledgeable and personable. He took us through a variety of samples, really listening to our feedback before making the next selection. He helped us find our new favorite hot sauce (Datil Verde) and barbecue sauces (Blackberry Barbecue and Datil Mustard Barbecue). Definitely stop in here. You’ll be hooked.

I love hot sauces and have a large collection. I was so pleased with my experience in this shop. It’s beautiful inside and they carry high-end, hard to find products, as well as low-priced local products that anybody would enjoy. There’s something for everybody here. The guy who helped us was fantastic; very knowledgeable and patient. Definitely a must-stop while walking in the Old City.

We live about an hour or so from St. Augustine, I’d drive here over anywhere else hands down. I wish I caught her name, but the young lady running it today was incredibly knowledgeable and passionate about hot sauces. She made the experience. Only wanted to grab one new sauce to add to my collection of sauce but after sampling some sauces and chatting about everything spicy, I walked out with three! Trust me, If my wallet wouldn’t hate me, I’d leave with 15 more. This family shop is a must see, I’ll be back for sure. Thank you!

This gourmet treasure store offers items to please the fussiest culinary chefs. From sweet to savory, each sauce, pickle, oil, or vinegar is a delightful treat. Service is excellent. The owners know how to make a customer feel welcome. I can't wait to go back to discover more taste-pleasing items. The online shopping is also a convenient alternative. Love this place!

I am not a fan of super hot sauces, and my boyfriend is and we both walked out of here with things we liked! Awesome selection of sauces and even better service! The two brothers who were working pointed us in the right direction as to what sauces we would like. They were super knowledgeable and we had a great experience tasting and purchasing sauces to take home with us. We would highly recommend this place!

Huge variety of hot sauces. You can sample some local varieties at the counter. Good gift ideas! The owner is really personable, friendly, and nice!

Great NEW OWNER!!! I loved that it wasn't another franchise. This unique shop supports local St Augustine products including my favorite Datil Pepper Sauces and Jellies which are local only to St Augustine. There are literally hundreds of the hottest most flavorful hot sauces I've ever tried! Reasonable prices. The service is exceptionally friendly and knowledgable. Love it! I wish you great customers and success in your new venture!

Knowledgeable and friendly staff - I was offered sauce samples within 30 seconds of walking in the door! Huge variety of sauces including custom ones - I took home a strawberry hot sauce that hasn't been released yet! 🤫 (It is amazing!)

If you have questions about anything, ask! I learned a lot in our 15 min trip here.

I got the best sweet hot honey I’ve ever had from this place!! Very friendly staff and very helpful! Got to sample lots of yummy hot sauces! 10/10 recommend!

Our family’s favorite new place for hot sauce, the gentleman helping us was a pepper genius he knew everything about hot sauce, it was fun! My daughter had a blast trying all there hot sauce. He was so helpful we bought a bunch of sauce, will be back next year for sure! Oh by the way the place smelled amazing maybe it was all the keylime in there, it’s connected to the island keylime shop.

Like Spicy Stuff !! This is The Best Store to go in St. Augustine. Have personally tasted and we ❤it all. Also have tried their Key Lime Pie (Awesome)They also have a Great Variety Of Balsamic Vinegars & Oils, Datil Jams & Jellies. You can try before you buy 🥰 Tell them Donna sent y’all 😎

They had my favorite hot sauce!! I'm obsessed with the hot ones show and they carry so many of them here and they have super rare hard to find sauces:) my new fav place hands down this hot shop is a must see must taste!