Key Lime Shop

Very cute shop. Lots of local products inside!! They support local and flogrown which is amazing. Chris and Sarah are absolutely lovely people and work very hard to keep the shop up to date and keep products rolling. Lots of hot sauces, mixers, wines, candies, desserts, and even organic body and wellness products. Lots to see inside the small store and lots to eat!!! Definitely worth a trip!! Very close to the Hilton hotel and across the street from the Castillo, and Flagler College!! The wine here is amazing, definitely recommend.

We were told about the famous chocolate-covered key lime pie, but we got so much more! The lovely man behind the counter let us taste wines and hot sauces, all of their best sellers. We left with Key Lime wine (so delicious and tart!), a hot sauce and BBQ sauce that we are putting on everything!, and of course those delicious key lime pie pieces. We'll be back! A lot of products are local Florida brands and even some made by the owner.

My wife and I came in yesterday and we come here every year from Maine for there key lime pie. But this time was by far our best expericance yet going here, it was completely remodeled. There where more key lime products then ever, and we meet the new owners, they were very nice . We bought 2 key pies on a stick, key lime pecans and a local key lime sponge cookie? Never heard of that but WOW it was amazing. Will be back next year! Was nice to see it grow very cool.

Lots of cute key lime items. They share a store front with a pepper shop and let me tell you the products are phenomenal but even they cannot surpass the staff who works there! Shopper beware the staff will convince you to buy AT LEAST one thing that tempts you and you will NOT be disappointed. Another one of the wonderful boutique shops tucked away in the many winding side streets of this beautiful city. Id highly recommend if not for anything but the staff who works there.

Our family was on the hunt for the perfect piece of key lime pie on our trip to Florida and we found it! I worked as a baker and have high standards, and this pie was magic! Thank you!

I had such a great experience here! It's a cute shop with all kinds of lime goodies. The owner was very knowledgeable about the fruit wines and made excellent recommendations. The whole experience was very inviting and enjoyable. I absolutely recommend stopping in and plan in returning asap

Great NEW OWNER!!! I loved that it wasn't another franchise. The Key Lime Pies were so delicious and The Key Lime on a stick was very good and easy to eat while shopping!!This unique Shop also supports local St Augustine products with Reasonable prices. The service is exceptionally friendly and knowledgable. Love it! I wish you great customers and success in your new venture!

Re visited this little gem today! And as always super fun atmosphere and great key lime everything. They added all these new tropical themed snacks and foods and they now sell wine! Yes wine, we bought 4 bottles of Florida wines, 2 key lime pies on a stick and some key lime shrub drink mix for my gin and tonics! This is now my fav place to go for everything citrus.

Love this store’s new face lift. One of my favorite shops downtown. Love the key lime selection, I don’t think I have ever seen that many key lime products in one store. This is a must see “taste of Florida”. It’s super fun

Very friendly staff and oodles of fun bits of limey choices! Conjoined with Hot Stuff you get sweet or savory or downright aiyeeee! We had a sample of the key lime nuts ~ yum! Buy the coconut chocolate candy bar at the front counter ~ delicious! We will be back!

A unique little shop with a nice array of key lime products. We had the chocolate covered key lime pie and key lime truffles which were delicious. Definitely worth a stop.

Adorable little shop full of key lime goodness. The key lime pie and chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick are delicious.

Great key lime pie. Awesome owner!!! Thanks for having us and the pup

Keylime pie on a stick and dipped in chocolate is AMAZING 😍 The owner was awesome to open back up to let us get one!! 👍

Great customer service, I got to try hot sauces and get key lime pie after to cool down

Best key lime pie in all of St Augustine after five days of trying this all over!!!!! Will be back again.

The Key lime pie is amazing!! 🤤

Nicest staff and the key line was insane! Crazy hot sauce selection featuring a lot of the hot sauces on the hot ones.

I love their Key Lime Pie on a stick! But sorry they don't ship!

Best Key lime I ever had