All Mixed Up

Great selection of high quality comfortable footwear but be sure to ask the super friendly owners to show you to what you are looking for because they have shoes in every nook and cranny all over the store and you don't want to miss the perfect pair! I love my purchases!

Pretty cool place to visit this is a Birkenstock shoe Sandle retail store, many many styles to choose from... however there's so many more items to look at... nick knacks, jewely, and more it is well worth the visit.....

What a great place. A unique selection of shoes, sandals, boots, clothes, and all sort of other cool things that you have to see to believe. Super nice owners who are helpful and fun to talk too. I shop for my girlfriend there and I always come out of there with something she will love.

This business has the largest selection of Birkenstocks I’ve ever seen! You seriously have so, so much to choose from, as well as other brands!
It carries beautiful clothing lines and hundreds of gift items! I never leave without something and if you’re looking for a gift, there’s something for everybody!! The owners and their staff provide excellent customer service! I would highly recommend !

Great store 😊 love the couple that own it. Real gem 💎 if you blink you will miss it but it’s definitely worth the stop. So many collectibles and odd and ends and bags and berks.

I can only wear Birkenstock footwear and I’m a popular size as well. I’ve been online even to the Birkenstock site and couldn’t find anything. I ended up remembering seeing All Mixed Up when I was down in the area previously so I stopped in and not only did I find my shoes, I found several styles in my size and my husband ended up buying a pair of boots as well. To top off our visit the owner was awesome! I’m a forever customer now! I’ll drive the 50 miles to get there. Thanks for making shoe shopping easier now.

All Mixed Up is the best local store around! The owner is so sweet and helpful. I always go here for my Birkenstocks and love anything extra I find 🥰 A true gem

Been a customer for over 20 years. Great store with unique beautiful trinkets, clothes, shoes, gifts for anyone. Associates are always helpful, courteous and knowledgeable. Prices are a little high but you can't beat the quality. Also a smoke shop!

Owner is always incredibly helpful and nice, transparent about product/inventory shipments

Friendly staff and a great selection. I also loved the restaurant attached to the store, All Fed Up, as well. I visited the restaurant for lunch one day and wandered into the shop. It seemed as though there was something for everybody at this local business, from Grateful Dead tee-shirts to gifts for a first communion. Charming. I would recommend it to someone looking for a great smoke shop, but also to anyone looking for one-of-a-kind gifts or for the most comfortable sandal in the world, the Birkenstock! The staff is friendly and helpful, and the selection is so interesting that you can spend hours browsing the little shop. All Mixed Up actually makes traveling to the Cicero area worthwhile for non-residents.

This is one of the best shopping experiences I have ever had. Every time I go in this place there are new items that weren't there before. Fresh inventory and a great and knowledgeable staff to boot. Speaking of boots wait till you see the selection of casual shoes, they will blow you away. This is a great place to get gifts or something for your self.

Don't forget the deli next store on your way out the door, the food was as good as you'd get in NYC. Sandwiches, soups and more. This is a must stop if you are near by.

All Mixed Up is a gem of a local retail store on Rt.11 in Cicero. From tye dye to Doc Martens or the coolest gift for the hard to buy for, its THAT place!

Went in for CBD oil after recently reading about it. She was very helpful and informative and gave her honest opinions!! She wasn’t just trying to sell me things she seemed like she wanted to help! I didn’t even know they had gummies so that is what i bought. The rest of the store was so cute and i wanted to buy everything in there!! Will be back

Such an eclectic place. It’s nustled away beside a carpet place and a restaurant. It’s got the cutest assortment of kick knacks, shoes, hippie like items. The friendliest staff. It’s a surprising find with such a unique assortment of items perfect for a one of a kind gift.

A great place to get shoes & birthday gifts! I also grab my dog's blankets there. It's a great little local shop!

Great place to get insents! They have some clothing, footwear, jewelry, knick knacks, and more. Great, friendly staff!

Love this store! Unique products! Decent prices, on most. Dont k what to get the person that has everything - get them a Gift Certificate from All Mixed Up! I k I want some!!

I love this place and the owner. They have a great selection of Birkenstock’s and other great stuff. So friendly. I go every birthday for every family member to get new pair of Birkenstock’s

As always, great service and caring owner to help find products that are right for you or if you're trying to by a gift. I've been stopping by for 20 years and am always treated with kindness. Thank you!!

Great little shop, lots of grateful dead merchandise. Always a bunch of gift options for deadheads. Staff is super friendly and willing to bargain.