Haymaker Toys & Collectibles

Amazing store. A great addition to the neighborhood. Jeff has a very nice selection of vintage and modern toys. If you are a fan of Star Wars, GI Joe, or Masters of the Universe this place is definitely worth a visit.

What a cool store, very fairly priced. You have to come back often as the inventory is constantly changing. If you're looking for some vintage toys, this is the place.

Always have had a great experience, takes me back to my childhood and gives me a chance to reacquire items I once had.

Amazing store! Very rare to find a store with premium statues and collectibles and comics! Highly recommend!

We stop by every couple weeks, always an amazing experience and good prices.

A great selection of new and used toys!

My kids were marveled at an actual toy store!! They loved it!!

Excellent selection!

Nice ownership... love the Gi Joe and Star Wars collection... needs more Transformers...80's toys rock!!!

The store is alright. The selection of vintage toys is limited, and even then it's mostly NIB and/or on the pricier side. Most of the inventory is the latest retro-inspired releases from NECA or Super7, which are available elsewhere as well as direct from the manufacturer. Don't know what niche the business is trying to serve but I wish him the best of luck.

Nice selection but overpriced and unreasonable.

Owner Jeff Kallum sends unsolicited vulgar threatening messages on social media. Very "Alpha 😆" male??? Not exactly behavior expected from the owner of any business especially a toy store. And as you can see by his response he still has to play "alpha male". Can't find me on facebook? It's because after you sent the unsolicited nonsense, blocked me. Not like I care about your need to be an internet tough guy. I speak the truth and you should not be around children. Now he tells people to stalk me on Facebook. TIME FOR AN ATTORNEY AND VISIT TO OHIO!