Dairy Isle

Amazing ice creams! So creamy and yummy. The Oreo brownie sundae is to die for and the strawberry shortcake ice cream was so refreshing and delicious. A must try place if you happen to visit Put-In-Bay

My favorite ice cream shop on the island. The service is always friendly. Definitely recommend if you have a sweet tooth like me 😋

Pretty good food with good prices, the fries that come with toppings shouldn't be salted in addition but were. They have dole whip and it's fabulous! The staff is friendly and the place is very clean! Great views too! Perfect photo ops on the jet ski and large Adirondack chair off to the side!

We got a strawberry shortcake sundae and an oreo flurry. They were both really good. Even though the area and shop were busy, we were able to order right away and didn't have a long wait to get our order. I would definitely go back to try another treat.

Great little place to grab a quick lunch or ice cream. Hot dogs, corn dogs, chicken nuggets. The fries were absolutely delicious. Free refills on the drinks while you're there. The staff was super friendly and very quick. Restrooms were clean too.

They have amazing icecream and desserts. I would recommend getting some ice cream. I personally like the caramel shake.

Great place for ice cream treats. Plenty of indoor seating and lots outside too. The only downside I saw was that prices are a little high but everything is high everywhere. It's well worth the time to enjoy and relax for a bit.

If you want some real ice cream in Put-in-Bay this the place - make sure to try the Oreo crunch flurry, hubby had the Heath/Snickers flurry

First ignore the bad reviews stating high prices, if this wasn't on Put-N-Bay then yes they would be high, but for where they are located the prices are fine, better than most other places on the island. The food and ice cream is really good. This is my family's go to place to eat on the island after trying many others.

I got a pretty decent ice cream cone with sprinkles, chili cheese dog and fries!
Everything was good. The only weird thing is that they fry the french fries and funny cakes in the same fryers so the fry's taste super sweet. It's good for a bit then gets too much. But they are still worth a try!

One of my favorite places in Put-In-Bay. Their ice cream is delicious and the chicken fingers meal is worth the value for the money. Yes, everything is "over-priced", but c'mon, they aren't open all year round and they have to make enough to survive when they don't have business in the winter. 5/5 stars always!

A very convenient casual fast food family friendly restaurant on Put-in-Bay. The servers were very friendly and courteous. Our food was fresh and delicious including the local fried perch. I highly recommend stopping by for lunch, dinner or snack.

Variety of ice cream options.. tried Oreo Sundae, Unicorn shake and chocolate ice cream.. also tried chicken burgers.. kids liked it and had good time

Incredible staff. Appreciate the service and delicious ice cream for my family!

The staff is all very courteous and the food is gotten out quickly and professionally.

It was good. Pricy. The customers smelled. And a 'smother' was trippin' over the bathrooms. Like woman, I need to whiz move yo self! Fries saltier then a mug though.

We had ice cream nachos..... yes it was good. What an experience to ride the ferry just for ice cream!

Everything was so delicious 😋

It is an amazing place to eat and enjoy soft serve ice-cream!!! Their fries are amazing! Also they have amazing Managers, and employees! Here is the place to be on the island!!!

I'm surprised this got such bad reviews because my family and I thought the food tasted good and it's one of the cheaper options for food on the island. The employees were nice to us also.