Isabella's Pizzeria Napoletana

I've been to Napoli so I have something to compare it to. It's not quite as good but it's close. I had the Diavola and wife Margherita. Both were delicious. I'll definitely return the next time I'm in Tallahassee.

Someone highly recommended this place to me and I’m so glad I went because this is the best pizza I have tasted🙌🏽. They were out of small size so I got a medium and for that I’m thankful lol. All around great service the woman explained to me the different types of pizza and it came out pretty fast.

Tallahassee, FL. Great pizza with a thin wood fired crust. The sausage had great fennel flavor, the red sauce was light, all fresh and really good. My husband said, “The pizzas great. It’s better but I can’t figure out why.”

Another review mentioned it was close to what he’d had in Italy.

My salad with prosciutto di Parma, Kalamata olives, marinated artichoke hearts and spring mix was also fresh and delicious; however because the prosciutto was not cut it was difficult to chew. Don’t order this if you’re trying to impress a date because you’ll be forced to take huge bites.

Vibe is perfect for Collegetown.

The pizza is amazingly good. The crust is light, the toppings are high quality and the sauce has a tangy tomato flavor instead of the sweet tasting stuff that has become far too common. It was far more than I expected to find in that part of town. I'll be back soon. I just went back for another Thursday bike night and realized that I would pay twice what they charge and still be happy. See you there.

Best pizza in Tallahassee and it's not even close. Cooked in their authentic wood fired oven, you will not find better. I was in Italy this summer and the pizza here was as good if not better than I had there. Try the Capricciosa pizza!

I come from New York and I’m very critical when it comes to pizza. The pizza is one of the best I’ve had in Florida. It compares to New York pizza if not better then New York. The sauce was delicious and the mozzarella is homemade. If your in Tallahassee you have to stop and have a slice. Me, I eat a whole pie. Great place, great pizza and great people.👍👍👍👍👍

Best pizzas in town. I would recommend to all my friends and family 😍

What a nice addition to Tallahassee! Wood fired pizza neapolitan style. We had prosciutto and arugula and a La Carne with magnificent Italian meats. A must try while in Tallahassee! Our service was over the top, thank you!

Excellent wood-fired pizzas and wings, fresh salads, and housemade gelato pairs well with great customer service. This is our favorite pizza in Tallahassee.

Best pizza place in town..
they also delivered pizza to our office last week .. so delicious 🍕❤

Nestled away on Gaines Street, you will find this little pizzeria. It's amazing. The best pizza I've found to date in the city. They have a wood fired oven right behind the counter. Try the bottled root beer.

Pizzas and calzones are always fantastic here, so is the customer service, and the place has a very cozy vibe to it.

Delicious pizza and salad!! Tasty crust, tasty mixed greens, variety of beers, and cozy atmosphere near FSU

Stopped here 40 minutes before close and had nothing short of 10/10 pizza. If you are a fan of the brick-oven, thin crust that folds over on the best cheese pull in town, this is the spot. Only knock was that there was no parm on the table and the ranch was incredibly thick, almost like mayonnaise. 3/10. But don’t let that hold you back from the pizza.

Best pizza I've ever EVER had! I stopping for lunch and had the diavola and wish I could buy another to stuff in my suitcase for dinner tonight. Perfect slices of pizza heaven.

Fresh, tastes amazing, and the price very low for the quality of food! After living in Italy for a few years and becoming addicted to the authentic Pizza Margherita, I thought that we would have to "make do" after moving back to the US. Isabella's proved me wrong! Try the Margherita, you will not be disappointed! ps. Ask for some house-made spicy olive oil for your crust, incredible!

The best pizza I have ever had!
I have been here twice, both time regardless of what we get, it is AMAZING!
The pizza is thin and crispy, the taste is just perfect, the attention always on point, all of the servers and owners are always so kind and friendly.
On top of all that, the place is cozy and inviting!

Definitely the best pizza in town!! I could even say that it is the best pizza in all Florida.

My new favorite Tallahassee pizza place. For good reason. Great quality ingredients and good service. Love the brick oven and the incredible crust.

1st time visitors! This place was amazing! Tasted just like the pizza I had in Italy

Seriously the very best pizza and amazing salads too. Outstanding experience every single time we go! Truly love the food at Isabella's ♥ Thank you for being so delicious!