Decent Pizza

Simple review here: food was good, pizza was yummy, service was kind and the atmosphere was laid back and fun.

Overall we got 3 different items. I got a slice of cheese with jalapeños (yes it really is that big), and my friends got a cheese and margarita pizza. My friends are from Italy, and co-signed that this is the most authentic Italian pizza in Tallahassee (in case anyone was wondering).

The environment is fun and laid back and you can watch the employees working as it’s relatively open.

Overall great time and I’d come back!

It was a great Spring Day so I walked over to Decent Pizza and had a slice and some cheese bread.
Their Garlic Knots looked good too.
It reminded me of a few Pizza Places I use to hang out at in the 1980s including an arcade style video game.

SHOULD BE NAMED PERFECT PIZZA. we got the veg head and it was so good that i don't want to eat any at other pizza place again. the music was fantastic, the atmosphere was superb, and the service was amazing. it was very clean, very cozy, very welcoming, and i loved every second. i will be coming back.

We went to Decent Pizza on Saturday night and it was delicious!! We tried the Veg head pizza and the Buffalo chicken pizza. It was sooo good! The service was great, wonderful atmosphere, great staff. The new owners are definitely putting in some hard work!

I want to start by saying we have always had good food here. We placed a business order couple weeks ago and the calzones were thin which isn't usual we made a call an Olibia straightened it all replaced our food and was very apologetic about our situation. Being great people ans standing behind their great food this is a place we continue to support as a local business in tally. Thanks decent pizza family for taking care of us we will continue to do the same on our side

First time visiting, Long over due. I ordered a Supreme Calzone and it was absolutely delicious. Fair portion for the cost.

The owner made it which was sort of cool. She has created a unique Tally vibe and delicious recipes to go with it. I'll be coming back for sure and recommending to friends and family. 💯

Ordered Specialty pizzas, Veghead and Margherita on cauliflower crust. Also ordered a Huge slice with pepperoni and mushrooms and Garlic Knots! Everything was Yummy!! The young man taking orders, working the register, grabbing pizzas and boxing must have washed his hands at least 30 times while we were there! He was so calm and it was super busy! Great place! Great Food!!

Caution: buyer beware!
You will hurt yourself here. The pizza is the best I've had in a long time, each slice is huge and very flavoring. I ate entirely too much, it was thin sliced but soft and each slice is huge!

Great pie if you like NY style!
UPDATE: They definitely passed the consistency test. Great sauce, crust is delicate like pastry! My new favorite pizza place!

If you like New York Style pizza, you are going to ♡ Decent Pizza. Hand tossed Pizza, made fresh. Fresh produce, fresh local sausage, REAL Cheese! Love the stringy slice! Great quaint local feel. Nice selection of Beers.

I've ordered from decent pizza before as takeout. I love this pizza. Family came from Orlando to visit in route to their destination. Dinner was suggestion and with 3 Teenagers,Pizza was the destination. I took them to Decent Pizza. Being the night before Thanksgiving I was unsure as to what to expect for a crowd. 8:30 pm and only 2 other parties were there. They soon left and it was my sole group there. Upon arrival to the desk, a very polite and friendly woman, Riley greeted us and patiently waited for us to get our order together. Upon payment, the crew flew into action and we weren't waiting long before our Garlic Knots and Salad were delivered. Riley took care of everything and served the table. When the 20' pizza was served, the 3 Teenagers eyes were wide open and smiles to their faces. They devoured the pizza with compliments of the freshness of the cheese and ingredients. They loved it! No more Papa John's for them. Riley and the crew were fantastic and ensured our satisfaction.
Thanks for providing us a great experience and fantastic pizza.

Well being from New York and eating pizza 24/7 growing up this is about as good as it's going to get the pizza is excellent the service is great and the restaurant is kept up very clean price is a very reasonable I couldn't ask for anything better or closer to Eat this place is a must try and we definitely recommend it I really hope this review helped you out if you read this review and you going to get pizza and eat there please let them know you read my review I really appreciate it

First time here. Tried a slice of cheese and so far, best pizza in Tally since I moved here two years ago. Very friendly staff, clean, great atmosphere. Highly recommend.

My first time in Tallahassee, FL and I was looking to eat elsewhere but see this place on google. Good conversation from the employees, beer was cold and food was just how I spelled it cooking. Will definitely visit again

Hands down the best pizza in Tallahassee! It was tantalizingly delicious in a way that tickled my taste buds and sent them into a frenzy of joy. I grew up in the city of Chicago and this gave me a taste of home like no other pizza place has done before. Now let me tell you about the staff. WOW, what amazing service! They made every customer feel like a family dinner on Friday night. Plus, the food came out fairly quickly for being baked fresh. I am just blown away by this place and can't recommend it enough. I wish I could put down 6 stars!

It was a bit of experience in the beginning, nothing more than just fun times in a restaurant I wasn’t really in the mood for that though . It was quickly settled with the amazing service from the lead girl and then jack in the kitchen came through big time and made it right with the pizza - kudos to you guys for having great service and teamwork, pizza was great !

So delicious and the price is very reasonable. The parmesan bread knots were scrumptious, too. One of my favorite pizza places in Tallahassee!

Decent Pizza is one of the best pizza places in town run by an extremely awesome person. Jacob is passionate about his customers and delivering a fantastic product. The name couldn't be further from the truth, it's excellent pizza. It's one of the few places that can/will make a delicious keto pizza.

For no particular reason I haven't been to Decent Pizza in many years. Decided to give it a try today and it was phenomenal. The only complaint I have is that I ordered online and waited a fair amount of time to go pick up my order and it was just being made when I arrived. However, the young lady at the counter apologized and offered me a free drink while I waited. I ordered the Meathead and cheese bread and both were fantastic. It will not be years before I go back. I believe I found my favorite local pizza place.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at "Decent Pizza" in Tallahassee, Florida, and it's safe to say that this place stands out in the realm of pizza joints. From the moment I walked in, I could sense the passion for pizza-making that permeated the air.

The decor, a mix of modern and rustic elements, created a trendy yet cozy atmosphere. The dimmed lighting added to the ambiance, making it an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a night out with friends.

Now, onto the star of the show – the pizza! The menu boasted a creative selection of toppings, allowing you to customize your pizza to your heart's content. I opted for a combination of caramelized onions, feta cheese, and sun-dried tomatoes. The result was a burst of flavors that danced on my taste buds with each bite.

The crust was a perfect balance of crispy and chewy, providing the ideal foundation for the toppings. The cheese was gooey and tantalizing, and the sauce had just the right amount of zest and sweetness.

What impressed me further was their commitment to sourcing fresh, local ingredients. Each bite felt like a celebration of the region's culinary offerings.

The service was exceptional, too. The staff were knowledgeable about the menu, offering recommendations and ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

In conclusion, if you're in Tallahassee and craving a uniquely delicious pizza experience, look no further than "Decent Pizza." They've mastered the art of combining fresh, quality ingredients with innovative toppings, resulting in a truly exceptional pizza that lives up to its name. I can't wait to return for another pizza adventure!