The Cottage Creamery

My family loves this place! They give a generous amount of ice cream which is good because the prices are a bit high. But it tastes great and we even buy some to take home. One opportunity for improvement is to increase staff because the wait time can get very long.

The cottage creamery is a great place to take the heat off a minute the beach.

It's connected to the Cottage Island Market and has limited outdoor seating, but is in a perfect location arriving at or leaving from Plum Island Beach.

Try the Conconut Chip with Almond Joy!

Fantastic ice cream, biggest portions I've ever seen, couldn't finish one scoop and I've had some big things in my mouth.

My friend Thomas also loved it, he covered himself in your cream and he wishes he could come back (naughty).

Spend your money here, it's almost as good as drugs. 6*.

Best spot on the island! The staff is always super friendly and knowledgeable of all the flavors. They recently started selling chocolate molten lava cakes and real fruit smoothies. Both of which are AMAZING! Definitely coming back again!

Great little shop. Sometimes the kids working are a bit chit chatty with each other and don’t move too fast. I may be over critical because I worked for years at a large ice cream stand and hustled my butt off while working.

The girls were super sweet, very engaging with my little ones!
Ice cream was amazing. Outdoor seating was super cute.
My only complaint is that the cookies for the Sandy sandwiches were crunchy rather than soft, definitely not what I expected lol, but delicious none the less!
We will be back!

My family went here after my birthday dinner to get ice cream. The ice cream sandwiches were the best ever!!! Huge fresh baked cookies with delicious ice cream of your choice in the middle. I eat a lot, and I would make sure to get only 1/2 next time.

I’ve been visiting Newburyport more frequently the last few years and came across this awesome Ice Cream joint out on Plum Island in 2017 and won’t go anywhere else since! They have tremendous variety, flavorful frappes AND unique treats like The Sandy - fresh ice cream sandwiches between two donut slices. Just EPIC. If you find yourself on Plum Island and in need of ice cream this summer ..blow off the chains or cookie cutter competition and visit these guys! Charlie and staff are super friendly and will take care of ya! Your sweet tooth will thank you...,

Great selection , tried almost everything , the dairy free options were great , alot of the icecream was from Richardsons , I had been looking for a local richardsons hookup ... this place delivered ! The strawberry, the death by chocolate, were some of the best we tried a scoop of all of them tho , great service

Holy cow... Highly recommended place! Really good ice cream, super generous portions, reasonable prices and great service! Can't wait to go there again.

GREAT waitstaff , friendly like the Island. The BEST ice cream EVER!!! try their SAND-DOLLAR OH SOOO FUN AND DELICIOUS 🍥🍥🍥🍥

amazing little ice cream place, i loved the death by chocolate....

Great staff, delicious ice cream and sweet local establishment! Psyched it’s back open for the season!

Friendly staff, great service, excellent ice-cream, great value

Tasty large portions ,places to sit . A nice ice cream shop

Always good! Maine black bear is a favorite!

Amazing flavor, and super large scoops. (go for the small one lol)

Great staff, great food!

We love our local PI ice cream spot!

Good variety of ice cream flavors and desserts