The Cottage Island Market

This store has grocery, snacks, surf boards, and incredible selection of wine. Staff is friendly and knowledgable about the area. There are comfy tees and hoodies, hats, and so much more for sale. When I visit this store I feel at home and nothing is more important to me than that (and a great glass of wine to sip while watching the sunset, let's be real). The prices are reasonable- in fact, lower than expected considering we are on an island, so I appreciate not having to make a trek into town.

Cute little market with everything you need for a beach day. I ran in while my dog was hooked onto the railing outside and the clerk gave me a treat to bring out to her!

The best variety of beer, wine, spirits, convenience AND an amazing surf shop with awesome apparel, hats and more. Get it ALL at The Cottage. We’ve gotten so many great pieces there - from kids hats, to adult sweatshirts, beer can holders, and more. Our favorite spot!

Great little store, with an excellent beer and wine selection, and super friendly staff! Plus a surf shop and ice cream in the summer. The people who left one star reviews weren't hugged enough as children!

Great island variety. You can get groceries, cleaning supplies, hats, flip flops, beer and paddle boards. What else do you really need in life?

OMG this place had amazing ice cream, we got it super fast and it was sooooooooooooo good it’s crazy. If you’re ever in plum island you HAVE to go. It’s a must.

Amazing variety of wines, beers, and snacks. New owners are young and very friendly. Great pre-beach stop.

The Cottage consistently comes through with those unique hard to find wines!

This place is AMAZING!!! Literally have everything you would possibly need! Super friendly staff & incredibly helpful! Best place to shop on PI for sure!!!!

They have it all....Liquor, Convenience and a surf shop!

This place is what it is. If you expect more, you’re a clown.

Good quality beach shop

Great store and surf stop. They have excellent boards and is my go to beach store. But, at the ice cream shop one product they have is called the ringer. This includes a donut on the straw of a milkshakes and it seems as every time I go there they never have the donuts. Either get your donuts more often, take it off the menu, or buy more so they last throughout the day. Thank you