Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

The ice cream is absolutely amazing. My fiancé favorite flavor is Ritzy AF mine is definitely the peanut butter Oreo. Every time we go in the servers are always awesome. Sophia was amazing help with recommending me a new flavor to try.

Amazing flavors & Sophia and Caleb are so nice! We got the brown butter cornbread and boston cream pie flavors - would give ten stars if possible

Delicious ice cream, always fresh. Many creative flavors and they also have a great selection of non-dairy options. Sophia served us generous portions and she was awesome! Thanks!

Their peanut butter pie ice cream is absolutely delicious! Loved their window service. Brought me back to when I was a kid getting ice cream in the summertime. Was just passing through Gloucester, but I’ll definitely stop here if I’m ever back in the area!

Very impressive ice cream! Unique flavors and large scoops — even for a small. Expect friendly staff in this award winning shop. Don’t leave Gloucester without stopping by! You’ll be saying “holy cow that’s good” 🍦

Vanessa was awesome! She explained the different flavors and gave us some recommendations. She served us with such grace! Thank you HOLY COW and Vanessa LOVED the vegan coconut cookie ice cream with hot fudge and peanut butter! My husband took a salted caramel brownie one on a waffle cone and also loved it! Highly recommend!

Santana did a fantastic job working the store herself on this warm Saturday afternoon. She was able to serve all the customers in the store as well as the long line of people at the window. She maintained her professionalism during a very busy time. I mentioned that our party had a peanut allergy and she said she didn’t have a new tub but would use a clean ice cream scoop which I said was fine. I also noticed she washed her hands before scooping our order. Great job! Ice cream was very good too!

The ritzy AF ice cream flavor may be a top 3 favorite!! It’s the perfect combination of crunchy & savory ritz crackers with sweet toffee. So so good and this comes from someone who doesn’t usually like sweeter ice cream flavors.

Sophia was an awesome server. Patient while I was having an issue selecting and tasting different flavors. This place rocks

Came in for some ice cream last night with my wife and kids. Was so so impressed by the flavor selection! Everything we got was delicious. Sofia at the counter made our experience wonderful!! So friendly and knowledgeable about the flavors being served. Cannot wait to return to see more of Holy Cow and Sofia!!

Caleb is awesome! Me and my daughter went in to get ice cream for dinner and it was a great choice. Ice cream is delicious, Caleb was friendly and helpful and explained their gluten free options so we can come back with my other daughter!

I had a peanut butter sundae and loved it. So much peanutbutter sauce. We also had a waffle cone and it was warm and made to order. There was an abundance of toppings!

Holy Cow is not only AMAZING ice cream, they are just good people, so willing to please their customers especially the "Littles"!!
My 4 yr old niece had her tonsils out and they put together a special order just for her. With a special message ❤❤❤ she was thrilled!! And felt so special after a really hard day, nothing could have been better than Holy Cow Ice Cream!! Thanks Mike 😊

We got samples of Ritz, S’mores, Peanut Butter Pie, and Cinnamon Churro… everything was amazing and it was so hard to decide! The fresh waffle cones are SO GOOD and super fresh (still warm)! Thank you Eliana!

Always delicious ice cream. Went in with my kids and Caleb and Sophia were awesome. Can’t wait to dig into my pint of Date Night!

Excellent service every time I visit!!! Althea is very helpful in making suggestions and always has a smile on her face. Can’t wait to go back!

What a great ice cream shop! Great vegan options as well.

Pumpkin pie ice cream was dreamy! Love the name of the shop, by the way! Waffle cone was nice & warm & kept ice cream from leaking out the bottom, unlike other places. Definitely would go back.

Sophia on wed, July 5, was such an awesome server; accommodating multiple special requests and generally being awesome at customer service.

Oh, and the ice cream is spectacular!!

I got a small Vegan Strawberry (that comes with blonde Oreos) on their homemade waffle cone and could barely finish because the portion is so generous. But both ice cream and waffle cone were amazing.