Cottage Cafe

I loved having lunch at this little cottage! The service was outstanding and everyone was so friendly and attentive. Food came out fast and fantastic sandwiches and salads! Loved the chicken salad sandwich and they did not shy away from the meat! But let’s talk about the real gem of this place…the dessert! Oh my heavenly goodness! Lots of mouthwatering options! I opted for the orange dreamsicle cheesecake and it was delightful! Will definitely eat here again!

My partner and I went into Cottage Cafe on a whim and we’re so glad we did! The service was fantastic, and our food arrived to our table super quickly. We left with the last slice of coconut cream pie (it was delicious). We will definitely be back!

“ Strawberry 🍓 cake , deviled eggs, potato salad & tomato dill soup “ were delicious ! I attended a lunch here yesterday for the first time ! Food was very tasty ! Staff was very kind ! Service was very quick especially for our large group !

The food was excellent, and at a good price.
The deserts are homemade and fantastic we tried two, and the slices are big enough for two people. Real home feel atmosphere!

BIG, BIG SHOUT OUT to Cottage Cafe!!!
Susie and her staff are absolutely amazing! I called Susie on Thursday to see if she could make an oreo birthday cake that our son requested. She did absolutely an amazing job on such short notice. Cottage Cafe will be my go to for our birthday cakes for now on! It’s homemade from scratch with real whipping cream. It’s huge and so moist - I can go on and on. If you haven’t visited Cottage Cafe in downtown old Middletown go. Thank you Susie! ❤

Absolutely amazing cakes and pies. Some recipes passed down from generation to generation. The best kept secret in Middletown, KY. This little cafe is run by the sweetest family. Their homemade chicken salad is scrumptious. Light yet tasty and filling. I can't tell you in words alone how decadent everything we purchased and tried was. Highly recommend going to eat here or picking up a nice desert. We purchased the strawberry jelly cake roll. Oh my it was melt in your mouth. If you want a cute story ask about the flamingos! I met Rachael and her mom and they are some really good people. They put their all into their products and reputation. Support you local small businesses but also worth the drive if you aren't local.

Wonderful lunch spot, only open from 11 to 3 , take the alley and park in the back, the entrance is in the back. Lunch specials every day, and a small menu, soup, sandwiches, and wonderful dessert place. We had the bacon and benedictine sandwich, deviled eggs, and a hot brown. The a huge piece of marbled cake and coconut pie. The food was large portions and outstanding! I took the chicken salad.and cake home!! Will definitely go back!

I visited Cottage Cafe for dessert on my birthday. Not only was the dessert amazing, but everyone there went above and beyond to make my day special.

Nice little lunch place for a good, home cooked meal. Had the tuna melt, which was served open-faced with a slice of Provolone and a slice of American cheese. My friend had the Benedictine sandwich, which she said was good. Didn't skimp on the Benedictine.

Delicious food, attentive staff and charming atmosphere—we look forward to going there again.

This is a small family owned Cafe with excellent food. The deserts are heavenly and most are old family recipes. Rachel was the gracious hostess.

Who loves a BLT? The Cottage Cafe has a great bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich! Try it, you won’t be disappointed.

The food is excellent and delicious desserts.

I found this gem of a cafe, which is about 3/4 mile from my home, by reading an article in the newspaper. One visit and I am a fan.

The owner is such a lovely woman. Always love to see her and the wonderful staff. Never disappointed every time I go. I love how the food is handmade and passed down generations. Definitely a spot you need to try once, twice, or a hundred times. The cakes are huge and generous. Only thing is beware if your tummy is sensitive to butter and dairy.

Always friendly. Always delicious food. And the desserts... there's a reason they display them in case you see as you enter the restaurant. They are the biggest appeal of all. The portions are huge! Pro tip - order dessert before you order your food. It might run out if you wait until after you finish your meal.

Had a picnic at their outdoor tables! Great food and super friendly staff.

Great food and service! Excellent desserts.

Delicious food and plenty of it!! Got chicken salad, so good and the cakes were so scrumptious. Will be back!! Everyone friendly, like being at a family gathering. Alicia is so sweet!!!

We went there on a busy Sunday night, with a party of 10 and they got us right in! We were blessed to get Margaret(meg or mag) as our waitress! I don't think I ever had a Better waitress! Cute as a button, bubbly, attentive and down right great waitress! She treated the kids as queens and the adults just as great! Then the food came out! The portions were huge and the food was absolutely delicious!! We Will go there again and we will ask for Margaret to be our waitress! Did I mention the food and service were great!