Gabby's Pizza & Pasta

Got a pizza, panini and calamari to go
They were all great! Very good pepperoni on a solid pie. Depending on your preference, I may ask them to cook the pizza a little longer next time. The calamari was very good quality which was surprising for a pizzeria - and so was the sauce.

2024 Super Bowl Specials. Gabby's Pizza Flemington NJ. Great Food.
Pizza Wings Knots Hot + Cold subs
Antipasta Pasta Dinners.
We had the Pasta Dinners + Pizza + Appetizer. ALL Delicious. Open Late. 7days/wk.

Great food and service, went there last nite with great people ,also a great atmosphere, Checkmate 👊👊😇

This is my go to spot!! Food TASTES excellent! I've tried other places but I can't find a better one. You won't be disappointed 😁😎🍕

Prompt, courteous, service. Good food. Late night deliveries!!

The guys there are friendly and helpful. You can tell they have dedication to their craft.

Hands down the best pizza out there! Delizias & Lennys is decent in the area as well. But Gabbys is undeniably consistently perfect & makes a better pie than anyone else out there. Never had a slice that beat Gabbys in the city, Gabbys simply is the best around.

Amazing pizza by the slice options. I get hungry just remembering them. Reasonable prices, friendly service.

Chicken Marsala thick crust pizza. First had it at Gabby's seems like 15 years ago. It was great. Haven't seen it offered anywhere else. Stopped in for a slice once in a great while, like every 2 years, and ordered it if they had it pre-made. Never disappointed. So last night, the power goes out just before dinner, decided to order 2 pizzas, a white broccoli pie and the Chicken Marsala. Both were great, but I gotta say they have evolved the Chicken Marsala pizza to a higher-level art form. If you live in the area, and the idea of a chicken marsala pizza sounds good, you HAVE to try this.

Coming from someone who made pizza for 6 years, this place is awesome. Their pizza is cooked perfectly with great dough, just the right amount of cheese, and they don't skimp on the toppings either. I've also had sandwiches and appetizers there which were great as well. Delivery times are on average with other places in the area and the pricing is fair too.

If you love pizza from Nothern Jersey and NYC you'll love Gabby's. They also have stuff, deep dish and specialty pies. It's the best pizza in Flemington. The sandwiches are excellent and soups are homemade. Dinners are very good and they DO honor food restrictions and allergies. There is outside seating too. Enjoy

First off whoever the girl is now that answers the phone is wonderful, she's so genuinely kind and she understands what you're saying and repeats back when necessary and is just a pleasure to talk to (I really hope Gabbys knows how sweet she really is). Their deliveries are always on time or sooner. The pizza is wonderful, the sauce is the best anywhere in Flemington easily. Anytime I have a choice on the pizzeria I get delivery from it is always Gabbys. Their food is so good. Everything from salad, jalapeño poppers, mozzarella sticks to baked dishes. Everything is great. I have nothing negative to say.

(5 Years ago I had a lower review but it was solely based on who they used to have answering the phone's, the girl now is a blessing)

Thank you guys (everyone there) 😀

Delicious calzone and Sicilian pizza!!! Tiramisu was great!!! Quality ingredients, and at a reasonable price. Friendly staff. Adherence to mask requirements was observed by both patrons and staff. I'll definitely be returning for more!!! I highly recommend this establishment.

Great food and good slices the chicken parm sandwiches excellent. My wife grabbed a couple of vegetarian white slices last minute and they were very fresh. Also good cheesecake and pretty good dulce de leche. And also good fountain soda sometimes those soda machines give too much syrups. This place had a good dispenser. Definitely one of our regular places to grab a hero or a slice or two when in Flemington.

Gabby's is my go to for many items. The best Meatball Parm subs, Calzones and really good Sicilian pizza around in my opinion. The staff is kind, polite and Hector leads the group like a boss should!

Great to know they are open past 10pm. Great pizza too!

Very accommodating and great food, prices and staff. The owner's son is a little cutie helping set tables at the age of 7. The bathroom was dirty due to the resturant being busy. I like how they hire high schoolers from the community. I will defiantly eat here again.

Just a few blocks from work so I go there a few times a week. Have always had GREAT sandwiches and dinners. Their Chicago Pan Pizza is my favorite. VERY nice folks too.

Only got wings today, and they were excellent! We've gotten pizza and dinners from here in the past, before we moved out of town, and the food has always been great!

Had chicken alfrado thing w the salad. Didn’t even know you got a whole loaf of bread with it, total plus. Salad had a cucumber that tasted whack too me so I jus didn’t eat it but the noodles and chicken was bussssinnnn. 10/10 would munch here again