Colonial Insurance Agency

My parents have used your agency for insurance needs and I was looped in when I started driving many years ago. My insurance needs have changed over the years and I’ve always felt that your agency had my best interests in mind. Shopping around to make sure I’ve got a solid policy at a reasonable price point. I’ve had a few instances when I’ve needed help and your team has always been friendly, knowledgeable, and had my back.

I've been with Colonial Insurance since the early 1990s and could not be happier. They've always provided fast, efficient, top notch service. They really make me feel like a valued customer and sincerely care about their customers!

Don and Dan have handled my insurance needs for years. I've tried shopping around on my own and couldn't find anything better than what they did. I've got two duplexes four cars and my lady's small business all protected through colonial, and they've always been readily available, and genuinely care. It's a saying in my family, when something goes wrong "call Don"

Jack Larsen has done a great job quoting everything from auto, home, and business insurance for me and my family. He is professional, knowledgeable, and prompt with his communication and work. I would recommend Jack and Colonial for any and all insurance needs.

Dan provides exceptional service and expertise! He tailors the perfect coverage to fit needs and budget, explaining everything clearly and promptly addressing any questions. I highly recommend him for anyone seeking reliable insurance guidance.

Our agent was great. Very professional, a good communicator, and quick to return messages. He was able to walk us through the steps to activate our flood policies and he collaborated with our bank to make sure that their criteria were met.

We have been with Colonial Insurance fot many, many years and have received nothing but five-star service. Don and Dan McLeod and their staff have been amazing to work with. Our two children are also with Colonial and are very happy as well.

The team at Colonial are exceptional from their overall customer service to their communication. I always feel at any time I can give them a call and they're there for me with assistance. Thank you, Colonial.

I moved to Menomonee Falls and was looking for a local insurance agent. I was referred to Jack Larsen by a good friend. Jack did an outstanding job finding the best rate as well as a good fit for the coverage I was looking for.

Insurance is often confusing and you worry if you have enough/not enough coverage. Dan helped explain coverages so we understood it. Still very happy after two years with Colonial Insurance! Highly recommend them!!

Couldn't ask for a better group of people to have selected for my car insurance. At one time they also had my renter's insurance policy as well until I no longer needed one. Professional, caring staff and very timely when needed.

Been a client since 2020. They have always been reliable, quick with responses and offer superior coverage. I can't say enough good things about this company. Worth the investment.

The service at Colonial Insurance Agency is excellent. To have an agent that represents multiple companies ensures that we get the best possible rate for our insurance needs.

Always able to reach you if I have a question. Always answers any question I might have. Very knowledgeable. Always informs me if I can get a better insurance premium with the same coverage. Always helpful, curteous and friendly. Very happy with you.

Excellent customer service!! Anytime I have had to call they have always answered my questions and helped me no matter what I needed. Never had I encountered a bad experience and we've been with them for many many years and have no intentions of leaving! Thank you for all that you do!

It is nice to make a call with a question and the person answering the phone may be able to answer the question. If they cannot answer the question you can talk to another agent if your agent isn’t available. Also great that if you need to leave a message you get a timely call back.

Highly recommend, very good customer service. Extremely responsive to needs. Also great rates compared to other agencies.

I couldn’t be happier with Jack. Always available in a timely manner. Friendly professional service and always great options for my insurance needs.

Dan was very knowledgeable, responsive, and easy to work with. We will continue to use him for all our insurance needs!

Colonial Insurance has been responsive to our needs with immediate communication, often thinking ahead for us and making suggestions to benefit our needs.