Small Town Creamery

We love this place, everyone is always so welcoming! It's nostalgic and a happy place to visit! The butterscotch bomb is my all-time favorite. No other flavor beats it! We visit multiple times when we're on the island!

such a cute spot- so much so we have been every night here! we appreciate all their vegan flavors made with coconut milk- tastes no different than the other real dairy ice cream!! friendly staff too :)

Freshly made vegan ice cream. Was informed by owner there are usually 4 rotating flavors. We tried the chocolate peanut butter and it had chunks of peanuts in it. Extremely delicious and tastes so fresh like they just made it. Lovely small business. Very reasonable prices.

I highly recommend this little ice cream shop! The staff is the most friendly. The variety of specialty flavors is amazing. The candy variety is mind blowing. It's a visual party inside with all the fun items. There's no inside seating but there's a fun bench right outside to sit. There's free parking in the parking lot. It's handicapped accessible.

This place is super cute! The employees were on it! They were so nice to us and gave us samples of the ones we were on the fence about. The fudge looks amazing but I didn’t get any on this visit. I had coffee ice cream in a cone and it was really tasty! This place has a lot of character, it was clean and had quick service. I would recommend!

We got ice cream here every night on our vacation! Don’t let the line fool you-they know how to keep it moving quickly, so you don’t stand there for long. Appreciated that they’re open later than the other shops in town. It let us have a sunset walk on the beach and then get ice cream afterwards, when it was too dark to be outside. They had a great staff working. There were two college aged men who were super patient with my 8 and 10 year old girls placing their own order “with whipped cream, sprinkles, and cherries.” They seemed to really enjoy their job, and I appreciate how kind they were to my girls, giving them their ice cream with a smile (and extra cherries!)

I've been to every ice cream shop on Anna Maria Island. I will only return here. The best Ice cream on the island.

Another ice cream store that we visited in the island. Was very nostalgic with different types of candy that you would see many years ago. Lots of flavor choices. Staff was very friendly.

Very clean! The staff is very friendly. There are so many options. Various flavors of ice cream, candy, fudge and other specialty items made to order. Just outside they have a mailbox with “fun maps” which have excursions listed.

We really enjoyed this place and would come back again! They have a TON of ice cream flavors, including some really unique choices (see photo). I enjoyed Trash Can (it had HUGE chunks of candy bars in it) and highly recommend Mexican Hot Chocolate if you’re feeling adventurous. My husband wasn’t wowed by the Cookie Dough (it was good, just not special), but he loved the Key Lime Pie flavor. The staff was friendly and helpful, and encouraged samples! We got the small town size, which was just enough for us. We didn’t have kids with us, but most other groups there included kids of all ages, and families seemed well accommodated.

We also tried the old fashioned chocolate and peanut butter/chocolate fudge, which were both great!

Very cool spot !! First of it’s so cool when you walk in and see the ferris wheel on to the left (which was built by a 9-year old) extremely impressive. We were automatically greeted to try all kinds of fudge and it was impossible to make a decision (DELICIOUS!) the ice cream, there were so many choices and all delicious (we also got to sample any flavor) staff was super friendly! Fudge was delicious! And ice cream off the wall! Definitely recommend, will be back here every time we visit Anna Maria island

Took the family there and it was so refreshing the staff was the friendliest I have truly ever experienced in an ice cream shop. Everyone was smiling and very helpful. Even answered and interacted with my kids while they were ordering. The ice cream was delicious, all 4 different flavors we got, and we will be coming back.

Sooo much to choose from! My family loved it here. The ice cream is tasty but the fudge? Even better! I have to note how friendly the staff was as well. We had a fairly large group and it was an hour till closing time. The lovely ladies working remained calm, patient and happy to help us. We will definitely be returning customers on our next trip to the island!

Stopped in to have a treat with our grandchildren. Great place with some really tasty choices of both ice cream and fudge. How can you go wrong with that combination. The young lady behind the counter was really nice, friendly, and knowledgeable about their products. She made some great suggestions for us.

We had such a wonderful day on the island and this place was at the top of my list to visit. It did not disappoint!
The ice cream was delicious and the staff was helpful and kind.
There's no sitting inside but there are a few benches and tables out on the sidewalk. Be prepared to wait and stand but you won't mind because you'll need to time to decide what you want. There are so many choices and toppings!
You can also take your ice cream on stroll around the shopping center. There's a shop nextdoor to the creamery with some beautiful parrots. I think my daughter loved the birds just as much as the ice cream.
We had no issue finding a place to park in the parking lot. And after a day on the beach, who doesn't love some ice cream?

We served their ice cream at my wedding - that's how amazing this place is!!! They are just so sweet and accommodating; it doesn't matter who helps you, EVERYONE treats you like you are their most important customer! The key lime pie ice cream is second to none!!!

Visit AMI yearly and finally checked out Small Town Creamery! Great decor, friendly staff and FANTASTIC ice cream. Prices were more than fair. Line moved swiftly! 4 of us and spent less than $20. Highly recommend you check it out. Pic here is a coffee type ice cream I loved! We will be back!

Their ice cream was delicious and the wide variety was nice for our large group. There was something yummy for everyone!

We love this ice cream shop. We went in one evening and Christian was so helpful with picking out some great ice cream flavors. It’s a fun experience, the k’nex Ferris wheel in the front is pretty cool and reminds me of my childhood. This is also a great place for some fun pictures on their sundae bench.

We found this ice cream spot the second night of our trip & went every night. I loved the fun names of the ice creams & the workers were so efficient, friendly, and attentive. A must for an after dinner treat in AMI.